The Odyssey Review - Spoilers
OK. I thought the movie was fine. Not bad, not great. I was saying to initiumseries (she hasn't seen it, so don't send asks!) that it was technically proficient but ultimately soulless, which frankly is the mark of a Nolan film but for me, the material of his other movies allow him to get away with his soullessness more than The Odyssey did because well, it's The Odyssey and so I would like to see imagination when watching an adaptation of a --- of the Greek myth, you know?
While it was visually nice because, again, it's a Nolan film, it was not as much of a spectacle as I expected it to be and seeing it on imax would've definitely elevated the scale of what I was seeing, like you could see the scale on a regular movie screen but also know, oh yeah, it would be all the More on an imax screen, and yet it still wouldn't have been a visual spectacle. Like I actually kept thinking about the original Pirates trilogy and how if it was made exactly as it was made in the 2000s but with different actors, like with Actors, now in 2026, I personally think it would've blown The Odyssey out of the water
and would've been lauded with the same type of praise especially because it would've had the imagination. The characters in Pirates treat Calypso and Davy Jones and his damned crew and the cursed crew of the Pearl as fact, as just a part of their world and yet the movie itself is mythical and with Nolan and The Odyssey, I just feel like he did the Ancient Greek version of dressing everything in his movie-signature tailored suit
and that isn't particularly interesting but it's also not surprising because while I don't know anything about comics and while I do enjoy The Dark Knight immensely, from what little I know of Batman, that's effectively what he did. He put the material in its version of a tailored suit.
And of course the point could be made and probably has been made that it's not about being imaginative or romanticizing the journey Odysseus and his men take to get home, it's a battle of his conscience, a struggle against fate, against the gods, a battle with against nature both human/self and the elements, and so we are meant to feel that slog, that weight, we are meant to feel the years pass by, except I think it needs to be more of a character film for that to work and still be interesting. And I don't really think we get that. We get Odysseus' pride/hubris and his regret and his guilt for effectively ending civilization with the sacking of Troy and the violation of Zeus' law but personally, I don't think we spend enough time on his actual arc, on him getting to the point of humility for that type of argument to work. Because even though we see his hubris and his arrogance, it's not portrayed in a way for him coming back to Ithaca as a beggar to have the symbolism it should because we also don't really see his need for glory in the movie, what we see is a man who thinks he knows best and then gets his men killed. Sure, he listens to Calypso when she tells him to just let the raft take him home and accept Poseidon's punishment and Zeus' mercy/grace in equal measure but him reaching that point of acceptance isn't fleshed out enough for it to really feel like an actual arc.
There were certain plot points/elements that were way more interesting to me than others. The actual battle of Troy was compelling.
The men on Circe's island.
Zeus' wrath was a good sequence though I couldn't look at it directly in the theatre because of the flashing
The weight and significance of Odysseus and Penelope's marriage was done well all because of Anne really
which leads to the acting where everyone seemed to be acting in a different movie. The women deserved better screen partners idk
They had presence, they had gravitas, they emoted, they had nuance and it felt like Nolan's direction to the men was legit you just have to be there. Robert was kind of the only one who seemed to want to do something with his role. Tom was bad. I think it didn't bother me that much because him being out of his depth across Anne Hathaway translated to his character being kind but naive and untested.
Matt just didn't work for me as Odysseus because Matt Damon is just a guy. He is not someone who I think has the presence or the range or the talent to encompass the spirit of who a character like Odysseus is meant to be, like he's a guy where I would expect his crew to kill him after at least the, like, second time he leads them to peril.
It felt like 3 hours. By the time Odysseus comes back as a beggar I was ready to leave. For all the bitching about Travis Scott being a bard, he's onscreen for like 30 seconds, I'm not even exaggerating. Maybe a minute but I doubt it.
All in all, I give it about a 6.















