As someone who has bought LED lightbulbs for a while now, the effective ban on incandescent bulbs is very typical of the current year - a sideways motion masquerading as "progress."
If the bright blue spike or some other aspect of LED lighting proves problematic later on, it's probable that those in power will just downplay it rather than allowing people to take care of the problem themselves.
One absolutely bizarre thing about the framing:
āNew Energy Department rules will save consumers $3 billion and cut annual carbon emissions by 222 million metric tons over 30 yearsā
Havenāt LED bulbs been available for a long time? Are there people who want LED bulbs who are unable to find them? Framing this as cost savings for consumers seems quite disingenuous.
If I wanted to buy an LED bulb I would - and I did!
It isn't like insurance where it's a complex product that's easy to get screwed over on... and incandescent lightbulbs are less dangerous and less toxic than compact florescents, which contain mercury, so there's not a safety justification either.
One might imagine taxing them so that they have the same purchase price as LED equivalents if they want to limit incandescent lightbulbs to specialist applications, but they didn't do that, either.
It's just... there's not a good way to summarize this... it's like an enthusiastic elementary school teacher is in charge of things.
There's a small but real number of thingies that were specifically designed to function using the normally undesirable heat produced by incandescent bulbs. You kinda need an incandescent bulb to make those things work. (The examples that leap to mind are a bit warmer, to warm up metal horse bits a la a polite doctors office warming up the metal tools for greater comfort, and projector nightlight that spun using a paper shade with a fan-like top)
Itās also interesting to note that the whole āLEDs last decadesā claim seems to be pretty optimistic.
Itās hard to know why LED bulbs die, and apparently in many cases the answer is just ātheyāre shitty knockoffsā. Which will hopefully get better, but has also been caused partly by the government-mandated abrupt spike in demand.
More interestingly, LEDs tend to get fried in certain fixtures. Sometimes this is easily solvable (enclosed fixtures or their bulbs can be changed), sometimes itās hard but urgent (your wiring is faulty), other times itās very much not. If your mains voltage varies or your lightbulb circuits arenāt isolated from large appliances, you can kill LEDs and CFLs extremely fast with spikes in voltage+heat. Incandescents will weather this just fine and merely flicker a bit.
Turns out, lots of rural areas have overvoltage or irregular voltage mains, and lots of old homes (e.g. New England) have crummy, poorly laid out wiring. Which means I replace some of my LEDs every couple of months, doing way more environmental damage than replacing incandescents on the same schedule.

























