So I am just curious: What do you think is wrong Chloe's writing?
Inconsistency. And an inability to commit.
The show kept zigzagging where they stood with Chloe. Was she an absolutely terrible person with no redeeming qualities? Or was she a sad rich kid who genuinely wanted to be liked and just didnât know how to deal with people because of her trashy mom and overly indulgent father? Both things can be true, but the problem is that ultimately neither was. Chloe sucks at being both so she fails at being either.
The show couldnât seem to make up its mind which of these camps Chloe was supposed to be in and didnât commit to either option. Furthermore, Chloe wasnât even the one moving between these campsâshe stayed in place, itâs just the line was being moved UNDER her to have her be positioned wherever the narrative wanted her in a specific moment.
So we had zigzagging moments where Chloe was generally horrible and was âwhateverâ about it vs some really jarring moments where Chloe was sad and we were clearly supposed to feel for her and think she was capable of being more except she did nothing and learned nothing and was still consistently horrible with little to no accountability or repercussion.
The thing is that this duality can be done well. These characters exist. It is fully possible to have a character that can be both horrible but sympathetic. Zuko in Avatar. Grace and Simon in Infinity Train. Ash and Avocato in Final Space. Caine in The Amazing Digital Circus. Anakin Skywalker in Star Wars. Odysseus in Epic the Musical.Â
But knowing the reason why someone does what they do does not in any way detract from the fact that what theyâre doing is still horrible.
We need to acknowledge the actions are horrible. We need the storyâs narrative to acknowledge the actions are horrible. Not laugh them off. Not dismiss them. Not ignore or forget that they happened. Not describe them as being ânot that badâ or âjust how they areâ. Not deflect by using other characters and especially not by consistently pointing at a character who doesnât act with the sheer malice and lack of remorse the way this one does and acting like their actions are in any way the same.
Chloe, like Lila, is a tool. The narrativeâs stance concerning her and who she even is depends on the scene and who is writing her at the time. But the writers canât seem to agree and they canât seem to commit to any one stance, so Chloe is all over the place. Sheâs horrible without her horrible acts taken seriously as the problem they are and sheâs viewed sympathetically without actually being sympathetic.Â
Just a reminder: we as the audience were called idiots for thinking she was ever supposed to be redeemable when the writers were the ones who consistently made light of her horrible actions and put in so many of these scenes showing her as a sad, sympathetic character with no control of her situation.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Genuinely so important to me that there was no romance in phm.
"You just need someone to be brave for."
And the person he needed to be brave for was his best friend. It wasn't a lover, a partner, a romantic interest. It was his best friend.
And honestly this isn't even specifically about aroace grace- Rockys story could so easily be a romantic one. He's been completely alone trying to finish an impossible mission without his crew for years. And then an alien comes and they learn how to communicate. And with that alien they both save their planets. Rocky gives Grace fuel with no hesitation, even if in the movie it means he will get back home 6 years slower. 6 years longer to see his mate. And he still does it without hesitating for even a second.
That kind of devotion and story could have so easily been romantic. Two aliens who help save each other, who are both the most important people to each other, but they're not lovers.
Phm being a story about friends means so much to me
Okay, so I ran into a problem while writing Number 6 and that I kept getting distracted from the specific character due to other issues that I felt needed to be addressed, but kept taking away from the character in the number six spot, so it seems necessary to make those other issues itâs own essay so I could get my feelings on this issue known and out of the way.
And the issue is simply put:Â kwamis.
Why? Just why?
I get it! Itâs a magical girl show, so we need the magical girl animal familiar to be the mascot characters for the series and a guide or source of power for the heroes. Itâs a staple of the genreâŚbut itâs kind of a silly one. But the other shows at least donât have NINETEEN of them to fill space and give additional powers that arenât going to be used half the time!
I hate to say it, but the kwamis as a whole seemâŚkinda pointless in general.Â
The kwamis are tools. They are there to empower the heroes and to serve as someone for them to talk to so theyâre not just talking to themselves all the time. We donât see them get arcs or development the way that most characters do (though to be fair, it is Miraculous, and aside from the main characters and a very select few, itâs hard to say anyone really got development). They are there to serve a function, but the function isnât really explored. Other than one or two incidents, we donât see them test the limits of the kwamis or how they manage. We also donât really see how the kwamis feel about the conflict or their respective users or the day-to-day situations. It makes it hard to invest in them.
This leads to a problem. While I have some sadness for their situation when theyâre being used by someone like Gabriel, I canât find it in myself to particularly care about them personally because we barely get anything personal about them and there are so many of them that need to be explored. And I canât help but feel that a lot of issues in the series would have been avoided if they were just removed altogether.
For Scarlet Lady, screen time as a whole is limited due to the format, so it was expected that the time the kwamis get will also be limited. I expected that. I think a lot of us expected that. So it says something that Zoe was able to give each of them some focus and make them stand out. It says even more that weâre actually able to understand where the basis of the relationship between each of the heroes and kwamis comes from.Â
Certainly more than Canon where we have the pairs based on âwell you were conveniently there the first time and used them once, so weâre just going to keep this pairâ without any consideration or exploration of how these human and kwami pairs function, how they get along, or if they are even compatible.Â
Look, Iâm all for interesting dynamics and pairing people with opposite personalities. Itâs a common trope for a good reason. But if you expect me to buy that the stuck up kwami focused on fame and nobility and appearance is gonna be most compatible with the no-name no-fame scrawny brainy kid, you need to show me why. I donât need some long drawn out character/relationship arc or an entire episode of them butting heads and eventually learning to work together, I just need something that explains how these two characters with completely misaligned personalities can have even the beginnings of a bond.
In Scarlet Lady at least, we get SOMETHING.
Look at Pegasus!
Kaalki asks Max if he is glorious and famous. Heâs not famous yet, no, but to try and appease her, he tells her that heâs created evolving AI, which all of us know is a big deal. Kaalki, as a kwami uninvolved with the world for who knows how long, has absolutely no idea what that is, but it sounds cool, so she accepts him as her user.
This here? Itâs not a bond. Itâs a trial run. This is a tentative partnership that is just starting to get off the ground.
Then at the end she meets Markov and can actually see Maxâs brilliance first hand though sheâs sad that Markov canât see her in turn. THEN Max responds by promising to create a camera that can break the established rule that tech canât capture images of kwamis and you can see the heart above her head! Max has effectively won Kaalki over! Over the course of one episode shown in eight panels in two comics pages. Thatâs it! Thatâs the basis for the relationship and that was all that was needed to show us that yes, these two can be solid partners!
Canon just gave us a joke and a throwaway line. And that seems to have been a common trend with most of the interactions between the temp heroes and the kwamis.
So it says something that even with the limited amount of time that can be given to the interactions between the users and the kwamis in Scarlet Lady, they seem so much more meaningful.
Max endearing himself to Kaalki by matching his pride in his tech to her vanity.
Sass praising Luka as a perfect snake.
Longgâs initial greeting an explanation getting cut off and the resulting anger and eventual forgiveness over it after Kagami apologizes and calls him âkami-samaâ, showing a bit of vanity as well.
Roarrâs exuberance and encouraging Juleka.
Barkk similarly supporting and encouraging Mylene, telling her that they are both strong guard, dogs that protect the pack and especially the line âItâll be okay cuz Iâll be with you the whole time!â Tell me that isnât the sweetest thing! Then at the end with both of them calling each other a âgood dogâ!Â
Rose and Daizzi sharing their mutual joy of bringing joy to others and actively trying to get to know each other to the point where Marigold has to interrupt them to remind them that this isnât an adoption (silly girl, it will be soon enough)!
The two artists of the group uniting over their love of art, but Nathaniel accidentally insulting Ziggy by calling his power a downgrade and creating a drawing of them both as an apology and Ziggy eating the drawing in joy!
Lila trying to work out the mechanics of the rooster power.
Alya and WayzzâŚjust Alya and Wayzz.
Marigold and Chat at points having to STOP them from bonding because this is totally a one time thing, I mean it!
You can see the bonds being formed! You can see that they matter, not just power wise, but also emotionally. These are new friendships being formed! And you can see why each of these kwami/human pairings were not only first chosen, but continued to be used at later points instead of the obvious answer of multi-wielding.
It resolves a lot of the issues I had with the kwamis in Canon while still retaining the same rules, functions, and personalities of the Canon.
It kind of goes to show that the true issue wasnât necessarily the concept, but the execution. Kwamis CAN work. They CAN be useful and meaningful with their own individual personalities and characterization. They CAN get enough focus to highlight those aspects even with there being NINETEEN of them!
They can be silly without being stupid. They can be naĂŻve without being childish. They can have opinions and feelings that may clash with their users or their Guardian without anyone needing to be âwrongâ for it.Â
Zoe made the kwamis MATTER again. She made me love the kwamis in a way Canon couldnât. And she justified them in every way Canon didnât.
And as this point keeps coming up as I continue to work on the next essay, Iâm hoping that throwing it out here and now will allow me to proceed without getting further derailed from the specific character question.
Yes, you can take that is a spoiler for who number six is.
phm time travel fix it fic, Rocky wakes up in the past. BUT. Rocky wakes up allll the way back before the Eridian ship's even finished being built, so he can fully fix all the problems possible. He teaches about and shields them from radiation, he talks about relativity but still insists on carrying extra feul anyway, yada yada yada.
Years later, ryland is born and grows up. the petrova line is discovered. suddenly, the moment Stratt walks into his classroom, Ryland time-travels/remembers the future as well.
He's fully prepared to go into space.
He goes through the motions.
They get to the Vat.
But then there's a signal from space, and suddenly the Eridians are showing up in their orbit with taumeba like "hello earth, we are here to help save you, plus we want to meet Ryland Grace."
boom
Grace gets to stay on earth! Everyone lives!!! Nobody dies!!!!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
It was a huge milestone of scientific and technological advancement. (Plus, at the time, politically significant). Humanity went to space! We set foot on a celestial body that was not earth for the first time in human history! Thatâs a big deal! Iâve never thought about it before but now that I have, itâs ridiculous to me that thatâs not part of our everyday lives and the public consciousness anymore. Why donât we have a public holiday and a family barbecue about it. Why have I never seen the original broadcast of the moon landing? It should be all over the news every year!
Itâs July 20th. Thatâs the day of the moon landing. Next year is going to be the 54th anniversary. Iâm ordering astronaut shaped cookie cutters on Etsy and Iâm going to have a goddamn potluck. Youâre all invited.
PITCH: We call it Moon Day, and then every 7 years when it falls on a Monday, that's an even BIGGER deal and we call that Moon Day Monday and go absolutely apeshit about it (the next Moon Day Monday is in 2026 so we have a couple trial runs first)
I scheduled this in 2025 to give you all a week to make Moon Day Monday preparations! I think I will order a little rocket cake or bake some moon phase cookies!
i can understand changing elements of a story for an adaption (and im a big advocate for this! no adaptation can or should ever strive to be completely faithful to its source material) however. cutting the nobody part from the odyssey is a huge indicator that you have fundamentally misunderstood odysseus as a character i fear
Miraculous Ladybug is about what if you gave a girl with extreme anxiety the superhuman capability to actually prepare for every scenario of What Could Go Wrong
I'm cleaning out my "Potential Art" sketch folder, enjoy these hella rough sketches that I let rot in my files.
Since some of my first fanart was of @imthepunchlord's Little Kitten and Little Princess, so I wanted to redo it some nearly 10 years later lol
Some Minnie Miraculous AU extras for @goatlilly's AU
Headcanon fun stuff with Kitty Section
I just love drawing Clara, she's so fun in my style. And some Lukanette that I'm sure I'll get flak for from @miraculous-content for never posting lol
aaaand some Miraculous Rewrite AU stuff for my own reboot that I never got too deep into (this is also First Draft Alya, I have way more sketches of her cuz I'm not sold on what to do with her hair lol it's Koki Marina ALL OVER AGAIN!)
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
It was a huge milestone of scientific and technological advancement. (Plus, at the time, politically significant). Humanity went to space! We set foot on a celestial body that was not earth for the first time in human history! Thatâs a big deal! Iâve never thought about it before but now that I have, itâs ridiculous to me that thatâs not part of our everyday lives and the public consciousness anymore. Why donât we have a public holiday and a family barbecue about it. Why have I never seen the original broadcast of the moon landing? It should be all over the news every year!
Itâs July 20th. Thatâs the day of the moon landing. Next year is going to be the 54th anniversary. Iâm ordering astronaut shaped cookie cutters on Etsy and Iâm going to have a goddamn potluck. Youâre all invited.
PITCH: We call it Moon Day, and then every 7 years when it falls on a Monday, that's an even BIGGER deal and we call that Moon Day Monday and go absolutely apeshit about it (the next Moon Day Monday is in 2026 so we have a couple trial runs first)
I scheduled this in 2025 to give you all a week to make Moon Day Monday preparations! I think I will order a little rocket cake or bake some moon phase cookies!
I like how sheâs glaring at him in that first panel, a mix of annoyed and embarrassed because she thinks heâs being a jerk and trying to make her look bad to new people by calling out and describing her specifically by her past mistakesâŚonly for it to turn out that no, sheâs in good company actually and is just the latest in an ever-growing line of people who have tried to kill him initially before ending up being pulled into his friend group. By that last panel, the tension and fear is gone and sheâs even joking around with them.
âLook, once you get to know me, Iâm very likable.â He is. He doesnât make the rules, heâs just at the epicenter of them.
Miraculous Ladybug is about what if you gave a girl with extreme anxiety the superhuman capability to actually prepare for every scenario of What Could Go Wrong
How do you think the Dolls would react to meeting bigfatbreak's "Blasphemous" Kwamii's? Or any of their other Au's?
Well I already did a take on Dolls in @bigfatbreakâs Villain Dad AU, but for this oneâŚ
They observed the small being, considering.
âThe little sage holds the power to create vessels for godsâŚbut you arenât gods, are you? You are something else.â
Iâm baby! Chaton expressed proudly, as if that explained it. And perhaps that was enough explanation.
Imago chuckled.
âSo you are.â
Chaton was similarly observing the new visitor.
New thing was big. Very big!
Friend? Chaton wondered, staring up at them in curiosity. Friend Inside? Not Friend Inside?
âI am and yet I am not like the kwamis you know.â Imago explained.
Chaton nodded. That made sense! The big one was similar yet different. Bigâmuch bigger than the Friends Inside. And felt samey but not.
Not Friend Inside? Friend Not Inside?
âI can be a friend, though I am not âinsideâ, as you say.â
Chaton beamed and held up a cookie.
Friend!
âAh. Thank you, how kind.â
Imago carefully took the cookie.
âFriend, indeed. I rather like that idea.â
It was rather unusual for them to receive gifts. They werenât sure how they felt.
It was a new, rather warm sort of feeling.
================
Imago was used to tests. To judgement and evaluation. The previous sage had him and the others perform constantly with a variety of trials. He was hard and strict, insisting on rules only they seemed required to follow and expectations of constant deference to him. When they were allowed to speak to him. How to speak to him. Giving them tests and trials and tasks to complete to prove that they are worthy.
Always being tested. Always being judged.
And alwaysâALWAYS somehow lacking.
These new tests were not pleasantâŚ
âŚbut they were nothing in comparison.
Not hurt? The red doll questioned, suspicious.
âNo.â
Do not hurt? She asked once more.
âNo.â
Will not hurt? She pressed.
They raised one hand and covered where their heart would be with the other. âI have not, do not, and will not intend to hurt the little sage or your loved ones.â
The doll tilted her head, assessing them cautiously.
Then she lifted her hand up to them.
Promise?
Ah. It wasnât a test so much as reassurance she was seeking. They could understand the feeling. It was what they and the others had so desperately sought in the past as they jumped through the various hoops the previous sage demanded of them in the desperate hope of being chosen to be given form and join this world.
They held her hand in their own.
âI promise, little one. I will not harm you or yours.â
She smiled.
Then she gestured them to come closer.
Curious, they lowered their head.
The little one reached behind her and pulled outâ
âOh!âÂ
It was a ring of flowers! Which she gently placed on their head.
âAh.â They didnât quite know what to say to that.
Except perhapsâŚ
âThank you, little one.â
She smiled and nodded. Then she gave their nose a gentle pat before walking away to rejoin her father.
Imago brought a finger to theâŚâflower crownâ, was it called? The petals were soft and silky. And the crown felt so fragile they were almost afraid to touch it.
âŚthey rather liked it.
âIt seems I shall have more happy memories.â They mused with a smile.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
In response to the "Littlebug in Look Outside" post, I'd say the answer depends on whether you take the Unity ending as canon for the timeline of the meeting, as that could make the Visitor out to be a bad dad figure, and thus be subject to Littlebug's interdimensional crusade against such beings (I believe the last one was Fire Lord Ozai, right? It's been a while).
Thatâs a good point!
Even outside of the Unity ending, if you think about it, technically, all the monsters and creations are result of The Entity. Technically that makes it their creator.
Technically that makes it a dad.
There are also two other things to consider:
First, that Littlebug is magic! Itâs not obvious magic, but her magic is actually very powerful and wide reachingâthe sort of magic that lets her get an outcome she wants.
Look Outside takes place in relatively normal world that does not have magic or magical beings. The closest exception would be The Entity, which is less of a magical being and more of an eldritch abomination that simply warps reality by existing rather than any intentional alterations through magic.Â
In that sense, magic could arguably be a defense against it.
Second, all the twisted monstrosities The Entity creates are some variety of former humans or animals/insects or otherwise living beings.
Littlebug, on the other hand, is a doll. A living doll, yes, but still a doll. One that was already brought to life prior to The Enitityâs arrival. And one with a very different perception than humansâcapable of seeing and sensing and just perceiving things humans canât.
It could be argued that her magic and the nature of her own creation could protect her from losing her mind (because she doesnât technically have one) or losing her form (because the nature of her magic lets her have the form she chooses).
That being saidâŚI could see another joke ending where The Entity is suddenly hearing boss musicâŚ
Ok, now I'm torn. Because on one hand, logically, I can't really buy that interpretation outside of a Unity-based timeline, because that would be like saying Hawkmoth is father to every akumatized villain because he took who they were and made them into what they are now. But on the other hand, it'd give Littlebug another reason to put Gabriel on her hitlist.
Besides that, I can certainly see her nature as a living doll, in conjunction with the powers of a kwami, giving Littlebug innate defenses against the Visitor's passive gaze. A full-on fight though, yeah, I just don't see it. I mean, it's not like Littlebug can Miraculous Ladybug a Meteor Strike or something...
Hmm, she'd need something of a party though if she's getting in a boss fight... oh! How about the Lantern Ring Siblings?
(Donât say that! Littlebug will take it seriously!)
The Lantern Ring Siblings, the Lantern Entities, plus the Miraculous and the kwamis themselves and alternate timelines with more. Sheâs got options!
Iâm not saying Littlebug is so totally awesome that she could actually beat down a godlike eldritch entity (though she is awesome and would likely try if she has reason to), Iâm saying there could be a joke ending like the Meteor Strike ending where she does.
As it stands, itâd be more likely that she would just go out and directly communicate with the Entity to let it know whatâs going on because of it and ask it to leave. Iâm not sure she would even need a ritual to do so since sheâs magic to begin with and can communicate on a different wavelength. The Entity would probably leave shortly afterâif it even got that close to Earth at allâand spare a number of people who would have been affected otherwise.
But maybe thatâs just me looking for a good ending.
In response to the "Littlebug in Look Outside" post, I'd say the answer depends on whether you take the Unity ending as canon for the timeline of the meeting, as that could make the Visitor out to be a bad dad figure, and thus be subject to Littlebug's interdimensional crusade against such beings (I believe the last one was Fire Lord Ozai, right? It's been a while).
Thatâs a good point!
Even outside of the Unity ending, if you think about it, technically, all the monsters and creations are result of The Entity. Technically that makes it their creator.
Technically that makes it a dad.
There are also two other things to consider:
First, that Littlebug is magic! Itâs not obvious magic, but her magic is actually very powerful and wide reachingâthe sort of magic that lets her get an outcome she wants.
Look Outside takes place in relatively normal world that does not have magic or magical beings. The closest exception would be The Entity, which is less of a magical being and more of an eldritch abomination that simply warps reality by existing rather than any intentional alterations through magic.Â
In that sense, magic could arguably be a defense against it.
Second, all the twisted monstrosities The Entity creates are some variety of former humans or animals/insects or otherwise living beings.
Littlebug, on the other hand, is a doll. A living doll, yes, but still a doll. One that was already brought to life prior to The Enitityâs arrival. And one with a very different perception than humansâcapable of seeing and sensing and just perceiving things humans canât.
It could be argued that her magic and the nature of her own creation could protect her from losing her mind (because she doesnât technically have one) or losing her form (because the nature of her magic lets her have the form she chooses).
That being saidâŚI could see another joke ending where The Entity is suddenly hearing boss musicâŚ