Commentary on Chapter 16 of The Blue Castle
“Big cars went purring past in the violet dusk—the stream of summer tourists to Muskoka had already begun—but Valancy did not envy any of their occupants.”
How different she is from the envious Valancy of the first few chapters!
“Muskoka cottages might be charming, but beyond, in the sunset skies, among the spires of the firs, her Blue Castle towered.”
Blue Castle is less a particular place and more her journey of emancipation. Which is also relevant for the very end of the book.
“It had once been a snug place enough in the days when Abel Gay had been young and prosperous, and the punning, arched sign over the gate—“A. Gay, Carpenter,” had been fine and freshly painted.”
A happy carpenter! A homosexual carpenter!
“Valancy showed all her pointed teeth in a grin.”
What do we think Valancy’s “pointed teeth” means symbolically? Is it the changeling thing?
“I didn’t think you’d so much spunk,” said Roaring Abel admiringly. “And look at the nice ankles of her,” he added, as he stepped aside to let her in.
If Cousin Stickles had heard this she would have been certain that Valancy’s doom, earthly and unearthly, was sealed. But Abel’s superannuated gallantry did not worry Valancy.”
To be fair, Abel’s behavior is pretty close to “catcalling” but his age and the fact that he first complimented her spunk makes it a bit more tolerable.
“Besides, this was the first compliment she had ever received in her life and she found herself liking it.”
Being a stranger to it, Valancy quite enjoys the “gallantry”. I like that the book will go on to acknowledge the complicated nature of this type of thing in the Chidley Corners episode.
“Valancy had not seen Cecilia Gay for years. Then she had been such a pretty creature, a slight, blossom-like girl, with soft, golden hair, clear-cut, almost waxen features, and large, beautiful blue eyes. She was shocked at the change in her. Could this be sweet Cissy—this pitiful little thing that looked like a tired, broken flower? She had wept all the beauty out of her eyes; they looked too big—enormous—in her wasted face. The last time Valancy had seen Cecilia Gay those faded, piteous eyes had been limpid, shadowy blue pools aglow with mirth. The contrast was so terrible that Valancy’s own eyes filled with tears. She knelt down by Cissy and put her arms about her.”
A scene out of a Victorian melodrama.
“Oh!” Cissy put her thin arms about Valancy’s neck. “Oh—will you? It’s been so—lonely. I can wait on myself—but it’s been so lonely.”
Both women had been so lonely.
“It—would just be like—heaven—to have some one here—like you. You were always—so sweet to me—long ago.”
Little Valancy was kind even in her ostracized state.
“Old things had passed away; everything had become new.
“Most things are predestinated, but some are just darn sheer luck,” said Roaring Abel, complacently smoking his pipe in the corner.”
Luck is important but so is taking initiative.
I don’t want to be a “Live love laugh” type of person but Montgomery turns me into one. I love this book.