It's not even complicated. Because of the frankly medieval way in which Jewish heredity works, where you're, "only Jewish if your mother was Jewish," marrying customs and such, Jewish culture retains its ethnic roots rather successfully in the face of miscegenation and living in decidedly non-Jewish populations. They more or less learned the mechanics of retaining your ethnic identity reproductively even surrounded by more entrenched, native populations, and not diluting away. And family planning practices that compliment that.
So you'll see a strong pattern of hereditary characteristics and maintaining those cultural family lines, anywhere Jewish people go. This is kind of why they wind up pissing off nativists that would prefer Jewish people dilute and miscegenate out into the majority until there is no more "Jewish problem." But, that's just not how Jewish culture works.
Arab people and Israeli people share roots, historically. They're Semitic people. And while culture and reproductive habits are different and preference and pretense of whom is marriage material and why, even if they're different distributions of different culures and systems, it'd be like trying to distinguish a Medditeranian people. There's more genetic similarities than differences, even if they are a distinct people. Growing apart, re-integrating, in different cultural cycles and generations over and over again.
They'll tell Jewish people, "You aren't natives to this area so your occupation here is illegitimate, you stinky foreigner. Go back to where you came from, European colonizer."
But it's largely because Arab-supremacists want the Protagonist Culture credibility. According to Islamists, Islam is the successor to Abrahamic faith and the only true religion. While they imagine Judaism as an imperfect, incomplete version that would eventually become Islam, the complete and perfected state. Therefore, they argue, Judea and all the lands important to Abrahamic creation myths belong to, "the rightful inheritors of this story; Muslims!" Which in Islam just so happen to center Arab people as the people chosen by God as most relevant and Most People of all people.
And they hate the Jews, because the Jews are objectively the original protagonists in the Abrahamic mythology. You can do mental gymnastics all you want in the 6th century AD, but Jews were Jewing and recognizably Jewish before Jesus was Jesus, and they're still here. It's hard to claim you're the true Player 1 when the actual guy is still standing right there, living, breathing, having children, speaking their language, writing in their text and speaking philosophy and taking part in traditions.
And then it gets a little complicated, because: Enter the Marxist Socialist shits, who are starving for attention and validation and for everybody to accept their views and philosophy on what justice means and why everything should mix culture with law and government, but get rid of the parts they think prevent all of humanity from just being one legal system and economy based on their ideas.
The Marxist argues about Class Struggle Theory, which they use as circular logic and just-so that there is an Oppressor Class and an Oppressed Class; always two, one or the other, and then goes on to define the relationship and what the oppressed is owed by their oppressor, pre-Marxist ideas of equality. Which involves solving this inherent, inescapable, medieval inequality via socialism as the natural cure for the sickness. They argue, without socialism and their ideas on redistribution for equality, everything is oppression and oppressed. Like a social form of original sin.
The Marxist argues that the European, the white person, is the oppressor class. That all Europeans by class are oppressors of those that are not. That all Europeans owe everybody else money, land and unconditional, string free support in return for oppressing them for centuries, that nothing the "oppressed classes" do to them is bigoted or hateful, "because the oppressed may lash out at their oppressor with impunity, as it's the right thing to do."
They argue that Jews are part of that 'white supremacy and patriarchy' and rally behind Arab Supremacists, seeing Jews in Israel as oppressors, and foreign colonizers on behalf of Europe. It's largely just politicing and putting a histrionic drama behind their anger over what Islamists feel should be their exclusive narrative holy land. Despite the fact those holy lands were predominantly Jewish, until the Romans stomped them flat and evicted a lot of them from Judea with threats of genocide.
So what you're actually seeing is the furious screaming of an Arab-Supremacist doing mental gymnastics about how they're the inheritors of the world and the most important real estate in their religious text, combined with a similarly histrionic pseudo-intellectual demanding everybody validate their views on class, economy and law. "Jews aren't even real middle easterners (anymore) is a product of this.
kianamaiart
theartofmadeline
discoholicmusic
titsay
dededos
