betts, i'm having trouble with letting myself "write badly" (and with coming up with ideas, but mostly the former). how do you do it, how do you teach yourself?
first of all, major props to you for trying the shitty first draft. this past semester it was the #1 thing i wanted my students to take from the class. for those who do not yet know the power of the SFD, i have made a very helpful visual aid:
letâs say you read anne lamottâs âshitty first draftsâ (and you absolutely must read anne lamottâs âshitty first draftsâ), and you come out of it believing in the three draft method:Â
dental draft: check every tooth
but you think, potentially, the better your down draft is, the better your up draft will be, and the easier your dental draft will be. perhaps you think, the shittier your first draft, the shittier your final draft, or maybe, the more youâll have to revise.
iâd like you to turn your attention to my gorgeous and professional graphic which took me a whole 30 seconds to make. iâve drawn two spectrums which indicate the quality of writing, from :( (awful) to :) (most excellent) based on your own definitions of good/bad writing.
letâs say the top line represents a writer who has written a very decent first draft. the absolute best they can do. theyâve put their all into it. they revise it once and itâs a little bit better. they revise it again, but at this point itâs mostly fixing a typo here and there. they have checked every tooth. but itâs still not great.
the bottom line represents a writer who projectile vomited onto a piece of paper (metaphorically) and then cried for an hour (literally). their first draft is written partially in wingdings for reasons they donât know. they forgot the word for âwristâ so they wrote âhand ankle.â objectively speaking in the grand history of the universe, according to god, it is in the top 1% of worst things ever written.
then this writer cleans it up a bit. now, itâs about where it would be if the writer had tried to write a clean first draft. itâs something they might be willing to show an extremely tactful friend, or someone with very low standards.
and now, magic happens. they revise again, and the draft is infinitely better than what they knew they could write. i donât know why this happens! but it does. itâs happened to me. itâs happened to every student who has had the terrible fortune of stepping into my classroom. i promise you it works.Â
writing badly is not just about getting your ideas down in a somewhat messy way. itâs about writing intentionally badly. itâs about aiming for the absolute worst of what youâre capable of. to write badly means to identify and define what you think is good writing, because youâre aiming for the opposite. maybe you hate stories that have run-on sentences, or which seem to lack self-awareness. that means your first draft is going to be FULL of run-ons and have no idea what itâs trying to be. but run-ons can be tidied up to create beautiful prose. and mindless nonsense that relies on tropes and cliches can be organized and added upon to be meaningful. but you need to get it down before you even know what the thing youâre writing is. we write as the process of thought, not the product of it.Â
which brings me to my next point: *commentator voice*Â
iâve written before on the interaction between fear, the unknown, and writerâs block. one day iâll write a big fancy craft essay on it that iâll try lamely to publish, but for now iâll be very blunt:Â
all writerâs block is fear. all fear is the unknown. to resolve fear, you must make something known. to make something known, you enact a procedure.
this is true of almost everything in life. everything you hesitate to do, everything you procrastinate or put off. every bad attitude you have. itâs all the unknown. if you open yourself to the process of knowing, everything in life becomes less scary.Â
how do surgeons perform life-saving surgeries? how do pilots keep a plane from crashing? how did i go to work as a bank teller in a bad part of town, day after day, knowing i would eventually get robbed? we have procedures. if this happens, you do this, this, and this.Â
as mary ruefle puts it in her essay âon fearâ â what is the poetâs procedure?
this is, of course, a rhetorical question, but iâve taught this essay many times, and read it many more, and i am obsessed with the idea of a writerâs procedure. combined with donald barthlemeâs essay ânot-knowingâ which is also about the making things known, we have a foundation for which to understand the process of knowing.
i have my own process which might work for you, which i adapt from project to project, but youâll have to make your own. and when you do, you have to trust it. writing badly is easier when you know, like me, you have at least 8 more drafts to do no matter what. no matter how good i think it is, i will do every step of the procedure, every time. i have faith in my process. there is no point where an element of the story is so unknown to me that i am afraid to continue. i know that by the end of the process, i have done my best work, and thereâs not much more i can do without the help of the people who have accepted it to be published.
recently iâve decided i want to start drawing. itâs a daunting endeavor â i used to draw a lot when i was a teenager, but like many of us, certain creative interests we had when we were younger get shoved to the side for one reason or another. for me, i never got the hang of shading, and i couldnât handle ruining my lovely line drawings with my hideous attempts at making things look three-dimensional.Â
now, iâve tasked myself with picking it up again, but iâm afraid. i ask myself why iâm afraid. itâs because i donât know anything about drawing anymore. i donât know what to draw. i donât know where to draw. i donât know what to use to draw. i donât know when to draw.Â
but now, just by acknowledging what i donât know, i have a list of things i need to make known, one small thing at a time.
what to draw: i take a picture of a fruit basket. i follow some mandala artists on instagram. i look at art blogs. i make a list in google keep/drive of things i want to draw. i keep my mind open to inspiration as it arrives.
where and what to use to draw: i need tools. iâm interested in watercolors, ink drawings, and calligraphy. i go to amazon and i pick out a couple things â a watercolor notebook, crayola watercolors, micron and brush pens. itâs about $20. enough to get me started at least.
when to draw: i schedule two hours three nights a week to draw. i download the harry potter audiobooks to encourage me to do it.Â
when it comes time to draw, the only unknown thing is where to place the first line. there is no risk in it, no fear â i do it with pencil. it can be erased. there is no way to be wrong. once the first line is down, i move to the next and the next, making the drawing known one line at a time.Â
the first step in the process of knowing is naming what you donât know.
so my advice to you is this: make a list of questions you have for your narrative. if theyâre too broad, break them up. make them tiny. then ask yourself, not what are the answers, but âhow do i make these things known to me?âÂ
the response is usually âi donât fucking knowâ followed potentially by âwell iâll have to try doing this thing that i know is wrong.â it might be wrong, but itâs known. and so you have to write it down, then trust that it will eventually be right.
thanks for the great question, anon. more on this at the start of the new year, but soon iâll be launching a ko-fi gold! if youâre interested in getting one-on-one feedback for your writing or would like to buy me a coffee, feel free to follow me on ko-fi!
and hereâs my writing advice tag.