If Much Ado About Nothing premiered today and had a thriving tumblr fandom (donāt think about it too hard), it would be made up of the following groups:
Beadick stans who genuinely donāt understand why anyone else is here but are the majority, so they can filter a lot of this out and just make parallel posts. This is the stuff that gets cross-posted to Instagram.
Subset of the above who call it Benetrice because itās less embarrassing but who have lost the war
Claudihero shippers who think everyone else is literally missing the point of the play
Claudihero ENJOYERS who think the above are literally missing the point of the play but enjoy exploring the dynamic and writing divorce fic
Members of both of the previous two groups that start regular flame wars with Beadick shippers even though their ships donāt intersect in any way
Benedick/Claudio slash shippers, most of whom make angst content about the dual that never happens
AĀ somehow even larger contingent of Borachio/Conrad slash shippers
A somehow even LARGER contingent of Dogberry/Verges slash shippers
Hero/Beatrice femslash shippers, most of whom end up in flame wars over whether the ship is problematic because theyāre cousins
Hero/Ursula shippers, all of whom promote their ship as the Ethical Alternative to the above
Margaret/Benedick shippers that are mostly just doing their own thing although Beatrice stans do screenshot and mock them
The extremely small group of Margaret/Beatrice rarepair shippers that are just *chefās kiss* the most valid group on this list
People who are only here to write like 50k word Margaret/Borachio fix-it fics
People who are only here to write Don Pedro x Reader fic
Don Pedro stans who write whump fic about Beatrice turning down his proposal
Don John stans who write meta about how his villainy and deceit is fine because heās sad that heās a bastard :(Ā (āDon John apologistsā)
People who create blocklists of the above
Weird class of Benedick stans who are NOT Beadick shippers and instead write screeds about how Beatrice is abusive because sheās less outwardly affectionate
Weird class of Claudio stans who are NOT Claudihero shippers and instead come just shy of actually calling Hero gendered slursĀ (āClaudio apologistsā)
People who create blocklists of the above
āBeadick is clearly compulsory heterosexualityā truthers
People who are only here to call Leonato a DILF
People who create blocklists of the above
All of the above groups are participating in the site-wide #anti maan #maan critical discourseĀ āIs tricking your friends into falling in love abusive.ā Greatest thread in the history of forums, locked by a moderator after 12,000 pages of heated debate.
Iām sorry but I canāt stop thinking about āwhat if tumblr had existed in the 90sā, cause:
It would have been nuts
All of this is true, but there would also be rarepair Pedro/Beatrice shippers writing AUs like crazy. (I know because I would be one of them.)
Also, this inspired me to share one of my favorite fanvids, Girls Chase Boys by grammar woman.
Um, excuse me, where is the Benedick/Beatrice/Don Pedro OT3 shippers representation??? Which is the part of fandom where Iād be hanging out



























