Haha no. Fuck this. Seriously, fuck this. This post has so many things wrong with it I barely know where to start.
One, you are not understanding why we are upset with the conclusion of Korraâs recovery arc as presented in the show.
âBeyond the Wildsâ was a wonderful conclusion to that arc. It left off with a Korra who wasnât fully healed but had fully accepted what happened and begun to move on mentally and spiritually. That was fine.
And then they had to go ruin it with the last ten minutes of the show. Korraâs BS âI had to suffer so I could learn compassion and connect with people like Kuviraâ line not only completely erases the entire point of Korraâs recovery arc but also trivializes and erases the incredible compassion sheâs shown throughout the series (to Mako, to Asami, to Tarrlok, to the nonbenders, to her people in the Southern Tribe, to Eska and Desna, and during the entirety of Book 3).
She was already compassionate. She was already understanding. She was hot-headed and naive, but these do not negate the fact that those traits are simply youth that underscores her incredible compassionate and willpower to help those in need. She didnât need to go through that incredibly traumatic event to learn compassion.
âWhere were the lynch mobs when Aang found meaning in his suffering, after he lost his entire people and culture and way of life? Where where the lynch mobs when Katara turned her sorrow and loss into compassion? Where were the lynch mobs when Zuko found meaning in his abuse and mistreatment by his father, instead believing his struggling made him strong, and made him who he was?â
Repeat after me: finding meaning in suffering is not the same thing as believing you needed to undergo said suffering to become a better person. Not one of the Gaang ever had a line like that that undermined their own arcs, not like Korra.
Each of them had something terrible happen to them, and each of them moved past that into a better place. Since the progress Korra made in âBeyond the Wildsâ is undermined by Korraâs âsuffering for compassionâ line five minutes before the entire end of the series, we are never shown any evidence that Korra has moved into that better place.
Aang didnât spout off the idea that he had to undergo suffering, that he needed to lose his entire race to gain personal growth and a sense of compassion for those who have lost people they love. Neither did Katara, and Zuko sure as hell didnât. Zuko in particular is a case I think youâre trying to parallel, and there are so many reasons why it doesnât work, starting with the fact that Zuko never even attempts to say he deserved what happened to him or that it needed to happen.
âMy father says she was born lucky. He says I was lucky to be born. I donât need luck, though. Iâve always had to struggle and fight, and thatâs made me strong. It made me who I am.â
Zuko: You, my father, who banished me just for talking out of turn. My father, who challenged me, a thirteen-year-old boy, to an Agni Kai. How could you possibly justify a duel with a child?
Ozai: It was to teach you respect!
Zuko: It was cruel! And it was wrong.
Ozai: Then you have learned nothing!
Zuko: No, Iâve learned everything! And Iâve had to learn it on my own!
âIt was cruel! And it was wrong.â And thereâs the difference. Zuko finding meaning in his suffering and believing that it made him stronger is very different from believing that the trauma he went through was something that needed to happen to him. Compare to Korraâs line:
But I finally understand why I had to go through all that. I needed to understand what true suffering was so I could be more compassionate to others, even to people like Kuvira.
Fuck that line. Damn it all to hell.
Do you see the drastic differences now? Zuko saying his struggles have made him stronger is very different from Korra saying that she needed to understand what true suffering was so that she could become more compassionate. It legitimizes what Zaheer did to her. It basically states âWhat Zaheer did to me is okay becasue it taught me compassion.â Yeah, fuck that. Not only does it contradict everything we know about Korra and what weâve seen over the previous three seasons, it both undermines her entire recovery arc and legitimizes the abuse inflicted on her.
The racism and sexism complaints are about the undercurrents and implications of how the show handled Korraâs recovery: due to the aforementioned legitimization of abuse, it paints a terrible picture for how abuse victims (particularly women, and particularly non-white women) should view and respond to their suffering: as something that is justified becasue they need to be taught something, becasue they were not good enough before the trauma and abuse occured/started occuring. It normalizes and provides a justification for abuse and mental trauma. And that, my dear friend, is not something that people will look back on as âempoweringâ for an entire generation of people, including non-white people, women, and abuse victims.
Compare that line with Korraâs line in âBeyond the Wildsâ:
Mako: Do you think youâre finally able to forget about what Zaheer did to you?
Korra: No. But I am finally able to accept what happened and I think thatâs gonna make me stronger.
That was Korra accepting what she went through and beginning to move on.That is Korra echoing Zukoâs arc. Not the compassion line in the finale.
And actually, you trying to parallel Zuko with Korra makes me laugh, and you know why? Because you sound like Ozai, thatâs why.Â
âYou will learn respect and suffering will be your teacher!â Ozai burned and abused Zuko in order to teach him respect, in order to teach him a lesson. Zuko grew up and came back with âIt was cruel, and it was wrong, and I learned nothing from you.â Meanwhile, over in Korra-land, Korra looks at the abuse she suffered at Zaheerâs hands and goes âNah, itâs okay. I understand that I needed to learn compassion.â Itâs the equivalent of Zuko telling Ozai that he understands why Ozai abused him, burned his face, and exiled him and that it was something he needed to go through in order to become a better person. But that didnât happen to Zuko. Instead we get, âIt was cruel. And it was wrong.â If you want to get a little deeper, you could look at why Bryke felt Zukoâs trauma and abuse could be flat-out stated to be cruel, wrong, and unneeded while they felt the need to justify Korraâs suffering with false reasoning. Justifying suffering is not the same as finding meaning in suffering.
Bryke having Korra finding meaning in suffering is her statement in âBeyond the Wilds.â Bryke having Korra justify suffering is that final conversation with Tenzin. And thatâs a terrible place to leave your main character at the end of the freaking show. For more on that, see here. Korra didnât need to be âtaughtâ compassion, and she sure as hell didnât need to undergo the trauma she did to be taught it. Sheâd already been through âtrue sufferingâ (unless you donât count the removal of her bending and the trauma she went through during Harmonic Convergence as âtrue sufferingâ).
She basically underwent the exact same arc twice: first in Book 1 with the removal of her bending and then in Book 4. And yes, the resolution of that arc in Book 1 was rushed and executed within the space of half an episode. But that resolution left off in a much healthier and much more satisfying place that Book 4â˛s long and protracted recovery arc did. Book 4 handled the execution of a recovery arc better. Books 1 and 2 handled the resolution of those recovery arcs far better. Just look at âEndgameâ and âLight in the Darkâ if you donât believe me.
And your whole laundry list of reasons people will look back on this show as empowering forgets one very important detail: with the exception of âmentally ill,â every single thing on your list was true of the show before Book 4 and applied to Korra before her trauma. Every. single. one. Korra was already subversive and revolutionary and inspiring before Book 4. Her recovery arc did not magically make her any of these things.
And youâre still not listening to our complaints. As I discussed back in Book 1 after Korraâs bending was removed, crap happens to protagonists, and Korra should not be excused from this rule just because she is a woman. Itâs not the trauma weâre concerned with: itâs how they handled the aftermath. The arc is not the problem; the resolution of that arc is. Bryke went ž of the way and nearly got there with âBeyond the Wildsâ only to undermine the whole damn arc in the last ten minutes of the show.
I love Korra. She is a wonderful and complex character, all passion and fire and compassion and so much heart. And thatâs why Iâm so outraged, months later, over the crappy hand she (and by extension, the audience) were dealt: yes, I will call Book 4 crappily and sloppily written. There were high points (Korra Alone, Beyond the Wilds, bits and pieces in between), but there were so many low points I canât even begin to put them all into words. Several character arcs were rushed and sloppily handled, several important characters were sidelinedâagain (hello Asami. Hello Jinora, hello Kai, hello Airbabies and the Kataang children), unimportant comic relief characters were elevated to b-plot status (Wu) or got an inordinate amount of lines for their relative importance (Meelo, Varrick), there were plot points and entire arcs that made little to no sense, and there were several other pacing and writing issues, including the complete non-presence of proper romantic development for Korra and Asami. Stop erasing the sloppiness of Book 4â˛s execution, and stop glorifying Bryke and dismissing their mistakes.
Yes: how Bryke handled Korraâs recovery is extremely problematic, because they ended up doing so by justifying and legitimizing the trauma she went through and erasing her actions and characterization during the first three books and the progress she made during âKorra Aloneâ and âBeyond the Wilds.â An entire generation will not be âbetter offâ with this ending; an entire generation would be âbetter offâ if the âcompassionâ line didnât exist (or was clarified and edited to erase the dangerous implications) and if Korraâs characterization hadnât been so terribly undermined during those last ten minutes.
And a big double fuck you for trying to make this about shipping. Korraâs romantic arc had squat to do with her recovery arc and all of the many reasons people despise that exchange at the end of the show. Weâre angry about the Makorra/Korrasami ridiculousness for an entirely different set of reasons. Frankly, how dare you try to turn a conversation about legitimate concerns over Korraâs character and recovery arcs into a conversation about shipping.