Okay, so I have been asked by a friend for a HR rec list. This is in no way comprehensive of all thee best fics in fandom. This is me going back 35 pages in my AO3 history and picking out the ones that I remember well and that stuck with me for whatever reason. Please mind tags and ratings, I'm not your mom. Enjoy some of my favorites!
strike-slip tectonics by PenAndInkPrincess - delicious miscommunication trope. Shane doesn't know he has a boyfriend.
struggle for supremacy by congee4lunch (WIP) - congeelunch wrote one of my all time favorite FirstPrince college AUs, and this one is just as good, if not better.
make me feel something by nettlepixie - mind the warnings, this is an infidelity fic. Ilya cheats on Shane, and they are utterly toxic about it.
If it wasn't for that meddling kid by ARustySpork - everyone, meet Ilya's rookie Pava. If anything happens to him, you will all pay. (In which Ilya doesn't go to the centaurs, and he and Shane are still stupid and in love.)
Abolish private property by fonduebroski314 (anon_carrots) - so Shane buys a building, right? Well, these are his tenants. And most of them have no idea who their landlord is.
all my perversions by probablylily - a sex tape of Ilya leaks. If only Shane could stop watching it.
The Importance of Strawberries by lostinpinerocklands (celiazwrites) - there are a lot of amnesia fics in this fandom. This one is my favorite.
Home Ice Advantage by taywrites11 - Shane gets traded to Boston. It goes okay.
Hayden Pike, Noted Ally by eden22 - Hayden sees the dick pic on Shane's phone and realizes why his buddy never brings Lily around. So he takes it upon himself to make sure Shane knows that Hayden is good with trans people.
Mercurial by delcatty - there are also a lot of Omegaverse fics in this fandom. This one does something unique and wonderful with it. OmegaIlya/AlphaShane.
Little More Close by maplesalad - the CNC fic we all know Shane wants.
tongues a-wagging by Anonymous - in which Shane is learning Russian, but not from Ilya. That's a problem.
The Axiom of Equality by kooksie - Ilya hurts Shane in bed by accident. He spirals out about it and I try to crawl into my screen to hold him.