I know you aren't with Tumblr anymore but idk who else to ask. Why does tumblr make so many random changes AND never give any forewarning or a reasoning for why they made it, AND never give any data on the feedback we send or the results they get from those changes? I understand that tumblr doesn't make money so changes are necessary but it's the sudden changes with no warning or explanation combined with the fact that they ask for feedback and then ignore all of the feedback we send and never release anything related to that feedback we send in that gets to me and makes me not want to use tumblr and refuse to recommend it to friends.
this is a very difficult question to answer. Because⦠things⦠are complex.
I guess the gist of it is āthe reality where a good part of the tumblr community lives is not the same reality that staff experienceā. Mind you, Iām not saying that Staff is oblivious or uninformed. Kind of the opposite. Staff manages a big extra layer of data we the users donāt get access too. Things from āhow long we have to achieve X or closeā to āthis change had very bad feedback but didnāt make the usage numbers go down and itās bringing 0.03% more revenueā.
Thereās a hard reality we tumblr users who like tumblr as-it-is need to start accepting: We are not making tumblr make money, so we are not going to be the āclientā here.
While I was in staff, we tried. We tried hard: Post+, the merch store, blaze, ad-free ⦠all those were attempts to make tumblr a platform funded by its community. The results were ⦠not great. Like, two orders of magnitude worse than they needed to be. That let tumblr in the hands of advertising money (that even if tiny compared with other sites, it still is the main Tumblr source of money by far). And for that, if you want to make the site stop burning millions per month you need way more people than we tumblrinas are right now.
Mix that with.. a certain disdain for tumblr as a platform from part of the top management. A big bunch of staff are hard-core users of tumblr who are more or less in tune with the feelings of the community, but in the upper management layers⦠thereās only one or two persons I can think of that actually seems to like and enjoy tumblr. The rest of them are mostly users of other platforms in their personal lives, and ⦠they just donāt get why tumblr is so hooking for some of us. They donāt understand how it works, they donāt understand the popular content here, they donāt understand the people who already use this place.
Earlier this year I actually had a call with the CEO to try to explain him why tumblr was a great platform for a certain type of mindsets, how I have adapted to this boiling cauldron of feral goblins so quickly and become enthralled by it when I started using it four years ago. And I think I failed completely at trying to make him excited or even interested in either the site culture or its community. Or convince him that tumblr could expand vertically (bringing more tumblr-minded people in) instead of horizontally (broad the appeal of tumblr for the masses even if it dilutes the current essence).
So for management, itās just a game of numbers: The current tumblr community doesnāt cover the costs of running the site, so they need a new community that does. And if in the process, some of the old community leaves forever, :shrug:, not a big loss, since they werenāt making the company any money anyway. Itās more important for them to get all those people leaving twitter or other platforms to actually come here and stay, and get those key metrics up up and to the right. Of course, this is just my personal opinion and Iām sure if someone send this post to those in management who Iām vaguepostingly mentioning here, they would be all āOf course we CARE about our community and tumblrās history!ā. But hey, you know you really donāt.
āBut Javi, isnāt alienating the core community who creates most of the content in this platform a stupid and terrible idea in the long term?ā. Why, dear anon, of course it is. Or thatās what I think. And thatās what I ended arguing about again and again and again and again while I was part of staff. And thatās, maybe, one of the handful of recurrent points where I wasnāt āaligned with the direction of the companyā that made me un-staffed (take that, tiktok kids!).
Why, then why tumblr management keeps pushing for this pace of rapid and alienating changes? Because Automattic, tumblr owner, is a private funded company. And there has to be smoke and mirrors showing that tumblr is actually moving fast and making the numbers go up up up. Every. Fucking. Quarter.
Do you know whatās the most stressing time of the year for your random staff member? Is it eurovision with its peaks of traffic? aprilās fools with all the tomfoolery? No. Itās the biannual Automattic board meeting. Because in every. single. one. of. them. we didnāt know if that was going to be the day where tumblrās downsizing would be greenlighted. Literally, every six months the board would look at what happened at tumblr and say āok, this is terrible but moving in a promising way, letās see if these things you are planning work and re-evaluate in six monthsā.
Does this mean they are in the wrong and me and the people pushing to keep tumblr more tumblr were right? Well, no. Not necessarily. Tumblr has been under a very real existential thread for ⦠at least a couple of years. And the reality is that ātrying to monetize tumblr as-isā didnāt work at all from a purely economic point of view, and tumblr wouldnāt have survived for much longer without showing clear gains. So who knows, maybe by diluting tumblr they could manage to make it profitable and keep this site live for decades. I would be VERY happy to be in the wrong here.
At the end of the day, put yourself in staff shoes. You have been trying a lot of āsensibleā things to try to make Tumblr sustainable. Your boss is reminding you that tumblr keeps losing money and setting dates for ālines of no returnā where the company would need to deinvest on Tumblr if there is not a clear financial improvement. You know you are burning the midnight oil and the sensible changes requested by the community you have made barely had put you closer to the goal. So itās time to try the crazy stuff and see what happens. Yeah, maybe that makes the boat explode, but maybe it changes it enough to keep it afloat. The alternative is letting it slowly sink into the darkness.
So, as I warned at the start of the post, this is a very complex issue with a lot of factors involved. And of course, this is just my particular view on it, Iām sure other ex-staff members would see it in a different way. Staff members need to keep their voices āaligned with the directionā so they donāt get un-staffed, but I can tell you that a good bunch of them are in private slack channels saying things like what Iām saying here (hello friends from #********* and #******-****!). Some of them like the X change but hate Y. Others donāt really care and are just doing their job and doing what their boss told them (which is a completely valid stance⦠this is a job).
So yeah, itās complex. Believe me, a lot of folks in staff listen to what the community says. Deeply. But right now I donāt think management thinks that catering to the current community is a valid path. And given the constraints of time and money that staff needs to operate within, Iām not even sure it matters much.