This Rick and Morty episode has got me thinking about the Timeless Child again. Because one of the things that rubs people the wrong way about it, is the idea that One didn't leave Gallifrey because of the strength of his character, but because of his secret repressed memories of being mistreated by Gallifrey and of being a Renegade before.
But what if its not that. What if The Doctor did do that twice?
Imagine Division trying to come up with a way to contain the Timeless Child. After all, you can't kill them. They say they never wanted to be your black ops secret weapon, they just wanted to be an ordinary Time Lord with a family that loved them. And every time they're left without something to do, there's always the risk that they'll go rogue and escape to fight injustice in the universe.
So fine, give them what they claim to want. Force them to regenerate into a child, fob watch away their memories and give them to a random woman to raise as their own. After all, you can always reactivate them later if there's a threat that needs containing. Maybe even tell them they're half human in an attempt to explain some of their differences between normal time lords. Hell maybe they actually are half human, the Fob Watch doesn't just seal memories after all.
Imagine Tecteun's horror when the child stares into the Untempered Schism to choose their name, sees all the horrors of the universe and again decides what it needs, is The Doctor. Surely not? They've erased all their memories of being The Doctor. But you can't fundamentally change who they are as a person and that is someone who wants to stop suffering.
Still the years pass, and despite this minor blip, the plan seems to work. The Doctor has settled down into Time Lord society. They have a child. A grandchild. A slightly unsuitable boyfriend! They have ties to Gallifrey they never had before. And their memories remain sealed. Little do they know that the Doctor is observing the exact same universe around him, the mighty powers of the Time Lords and their refusal to help others, and while it may make take them longer without Division, sooner or later they're going to come to the exact same conclusion and act on it in the exact same way.
Because even with an entirely different childhood and set of memories, they're still The Doctor and that's what The Doctor does






















