So, thereâs this interesting thing where a certain degree of saturation in stories will train the audience to just accept stuff thatâd normally strike them as bizarre or unrealistic, and move on without questioning it. Itâs sort of like âwilling suspension of disbeliefâ, except that phrasing doesnât really encapsulate it precisely. Itâs more like⌠commonality breeds acceptance.
For example, a humble young boy who rises to prominence and becomes a hero is such a standard piece of storytelling, that virtually no one ever sits down to watch a movie and actually goes âwell, but, this is just a young farm lad - surely he canât do a single thing to help stop the Forces of Evil!â People in the movie might do that. But unless the audience is very, very young, or has somehow managed to avoid most books, movies, songs, comics, television shows, and oral traditions for the whole of their life, theyâre going to sit down and think âah yes, hereâs our guyâ.
Even though, in real life, it actually IS still pretty far-fetched for Ye Humble Village Lad to turn out to be the only thing standing between mankind and destruction.
The interesting thing, though, is that if you change enough elements of what is so common as to be thoughtlessly accepted, the image you present will no longer resemble the familiar narrative. Even if, below the surface, the other components are exactly the same.
This, along with the above-mentioned misogyny, is another contributing factor to the Mary Sue thing.
Because there are fewer female heroes who are just unabashed power fantasies, embodying unlikely rises to success or mastery of untold skills, if you take a very typical story that stars a dude and swap him out for a lady, the elements once rendered invisible by familiarity, are now noticeable again. The audience is jolted out of complacency, and begins to think more critically about what theyâre being asked to believe. (You can accomplish the same thing with other demographics, too, i.e. putting characters of colour in roles typically given to white actors, or having LGBT+ characters with the same abundance as straight ones, and so on and so forth.)
So even people who like to think of themselves as totally fair and unprejudiced can end up enforcing double-standards in entertainment. Because if you donât catch yourself, you will not even realize that you managed to sit through three Iron Man movies without ever questioning the premise of Tony Starkâs genius, but somehow Shuri in Black Panther just struck you as âunrealisticâ.Â
janainaart
theartofmadeline
snowghoul
germansingergirl
