Separating Culture from People
There are Black people who live in Asia and use chopsticks. There are Black people who donāt live in Asia that use chopsticks. Diaspora exist. Diasporic communities exist. There is cultural exchange and trade all over this planet. So when writers use that, I think itās really neat.
But when writers go āWhat would happen if I randomly had this people group have this other groupās culture?ā it makes me feel like they think other peopleās cultures exist to be their toys. For funsies!
Culture is not for shock factor. A people groupās culture, history, cultural artifacts and traditions - these arenāt toys and doing this is not the way to insert originality into a work.
Cultural elements donāt have to go with certain skin colors because thereās a huge range of skin colors in almost every country. Diaspora, immigration, intermarrying, thatās all stuff that happens. But cultural elements donāt exist as a sort of external force that has nothing to do with the people of that culture. Culture is created, consumed and changed by people. So when you pick things here and there willy-nilly, youāre divorcing people from their culture for no reason.
And Iām not sure if you know this, but chopsticks (what theyāre made of, how they look, proper usage) vary all over Asia/East Asia. Their usage has evolved differently in different countries. For example, Koreans like metal chopsticks that are kind of skinny/flat, and theyāre intended to be used in sets with spoons (so theyāre intentionally designed to be sold in sets).Ā
Chopsticks in Japan, though, are often made of wood, are more āchunkyā shaped, and often lacquered. You donāt really buy Japanese chopsticks in sets with spoons like you would in Korea. [Mod Stella honestly prefers using Japanese-style chopsticks because theyāre just more comfortable for her to hold. But she definitely grew up with Korean chopsticks!]
Chinese chopsticks are longer because they eat āfamily styleā which is putting everything on the table and reaching for it. [Mod Jess says,Ā āFamily style is how I certainly eat at home, reaching for things instead of asking to pass them. So itās actually expected that some stuff might drop onto the table itself, which is solved by mopping it after each meal.ā]
But my point is that randomly taking the idea of chopsticks and arbitrarily assigning it to a people group just seems like a really problematic thing to do. Chopsticks have a specific history. We donāt put them in our hair. Some things that are rude in one country that uses chopsticks isnāt considered rude in another. How do you describe that (as well as the reasons why chopsticks evolved differently) while divorcing it from the actual country that uses them?Ā
The idea of randomly assigning cultures to other peoples is a very uncomfortable and frustrating one, so weād advise you to reconsider it.
~Mods Stella, Jess & Colette