I’ve been thinking about how much of certain movements are about “self-sufficiency”, which always makes me wonder how you can provide for everything you need. I don’t think you can. I think there are ways to be more independent and stable, but it always comes down to “well what about everyone else?”. Should we be talking about “community sufficiency” instead? Where everyone together joins to make sure everyone has what they need? Not only can you divide labor, but also you can specialize and have different skills.
I was literally just thinking about this, because of John Seymour’s unintentionally hilarious chapter on community building in “The New Complete Book of Self-Sufficiency: The classic guide for realists and dreamers.”
Seymour is considered the “founding father” of the self-sufficiency movement, but his stuff is highly specific to his time (1970s) and his place (the British Isles) so he may not be familiar outside of a certain context. His chapter on forming a mutual aid collective contains about a page of advice on selecting the right pub for the initial meetings, which is about as much space as he dedicates in other chapters to tasks like spinning flax and killing a pig: it’s that important to get the pub setting correct. He also felt it was important to script the whole process out carefully, as he appeared to intuit that everyone reading his book, and all of their potential community members, would certainly be as socially awkward as him. After advising us on How To Convince Strangers to Meet You In A Pub With An Eye To Becoming A Mutual Aid Collective, he then casually reminds us that we are all, after all, going to be insufferable assholes:
That’s rather nice, to know that even if you irritate John Seymour in a pub at your first meeting by being too opinionated about mangelwurzels or kicking off about craft beer, he’d still consider you to be (bizarre but valid) friend material. Relatable! But then:
I’M sOrrY sir ????
Anyway
If it helps you win any arguments
The “”“”“founding father”“”“” of self-sufficiency was very invested in the concept of community, collective action, etc, and it may amuse you to quote him on it.

















