Opening the AO3 tag of a fandom which was huge in the LJ days is both wonderful and terrible because it’s always like
1. Yes this person did port most of their fic to AO3. But this fic is a sequel to one a friend of theirs wrote and that one didn’t make the jump.
2. This fic is supposed to have art but wherever they were hosting the images went under years ago.
3. One of the big fandom classics made it here but there was apparently at one point more content in the LJ comments. The link is broken.
4. Everyone keeps referencing a particular ship manifesto/influential meta. They’re referring to it by an acronym with no links. It may still be out there but it is unfindable
5. There was apparently a whole community around one particular AU/character interpretation. A single example remains.
This is of course on top of the epic highs and lows of older fandoms in general such as
High: the person who wrote this fic is now the [redacted] award winning, New York Times bestselling author of [redacted] and it shows in the quality.
Low: otherwise fascinating AU ruined by inexplicable sidelining and/or bashing of the female characters. Author is not only explicitly aware of this bias but unrepentant.
High: the library is huge, and almost everything is complete. And if it’s not complete you can go in accepting the knowledge that it never will be completed and appreciate it for what it is
Low: “gay for you” and “I’ve never been with a man before” way more prevalent than you get now (these days people can be gay or bi without crazy hoops to jump through)
High: bookmarks and collection rec lists galore. Many of them very well curated.
Low: comment etiquette was different and people seem to have been ok with others being just straight up mean and gatekeepy sometimes?
Silver lining of not being able to find all the fic in the depths of live journal tho is that if I actually write the fic I’m thinking about I won’t be navigating around someone else’s take on the same idea.
I’m a big fan of two cakes but it’s usually best to not taste the other cake before you bake yours, and that can be hard to ensure when you’re coming to the potluck fifteen years late and you had a chocolate craving yesterday.





















