hey so. don’t do this.
“coming from a place of respect” there is nothing respectful about a comment like this. this is exactly why I say witch hunt, speculations and accusations harm the writing community as much as ai does, if not more.
I am not saying “you’re an asshole if you think a fic is ai”. I have come across fics that I believe were ai-generated. but instead of asking (accusing) the authors, I make my own decisions whether I’ll continue reading for the benefit of the doubt or quietly exit the fics and look for something else to read.
because with every accusation like this, there’s always a chance of a genuine, innocent writer getting wrongly accused.
last but not least, fanfic writers do NOT owe you anything. they write for themselves and their own enjoyment. their ao3 accounts are their houses and they were kind enough to let you in their houses. for free. (you get to read things for free.) you don’t go into other people’s houses and tell them “actually I think the way you decorate your room is sus. did you actually do it yourself or did you ask a robot to do it for you?”. THEY 👏🏻 DON’T 👏🏻 OWE 👏🏻 YOU 👏🏻 ANYTHING. and I say this as someone who is not a fan of ai fics. if you don’t like what you’re seeing, quietly leave.
*the following is not about the fic in this specific post. in general, I still strongly believe people who let ai write for them should tag their works as ai accordingly. but if we want more people to be honest about it, we’ll have to stop shaming and harassing people who actually tag their ai-generated fics accordingly. harassment is never justified. not to mention, it will only make “ai writers” refrain from tagging their ai-generated works as such. and then there’s no way for anyone to know for absolute certainty if it’s ai. therefore the raise of witch hunt.
yeah no, see this is what im talking abt this is the arrogance and over defensive mentality in writing spaces that make it so toxic. If ur posting your writing on a PUBLIC community platform like ao3 or anywhere else then your work is subject to any kind of comment and critique because it’s fucking public!!!! it’s not a “witch hunt”, ppl are allowed to question the integrity of any work posted on a public platform, period. WRITERS OWE THE PEOPLE WHO GO OUT OF THEIR WAY TO INTERACT WITH THEIR WORK EVERYTHING!!! ao3 isn’t ur fucking hugbox. and im pretty sure there are options on ao3 to make ur work private and only for you to see so???? at this point fanfic “writers” should just call themselves hobbyists with a hyper fixation on making god awful blorbo media slop cus if you’re just doing this shit for urself and u don’t really care to actually CARE about your craft and hone in your skills then whatever ig? maybe we need to draw a HARD LINE between creative writing and whatever tf THIS is…
“If ur posting your writing on a PUBLIC community platform like ao3 or anywhere else then your work is subject to any kind of comment and critique because it’s fucking public!!!!”
“if you’re dressing like this in PUBLIC then you are subjected to being catcalled and harassed by strangers and you’re toxic if you fight back against the ones who harassed you” victim blaming ass mindset.
“writers owe the people who go out of their way to interact with their works” by interacting you mean being disrespectful and rude??? I’d rather these entitled ass readers stay away from my works and any other writers’ works.
instead of looking for an excuse to be an asshole to other people, maybe have you ever tried being a decent person?
There's apparently currently some HUGE drama in the Heated Rivalry fandom because someone discovered the actual way to identify AI-rendered text if that AI happens to be Claude (it's specific HTML in the source code), and several prominent fandomers have been caught faking all their fics.
I don't feel bad for the people who were caught holding smoking guns. They made their choices and tried to pass their work off as real even when one of them was caught leaving the AI prompt right in the middle of the text. (Another tried to blame their beta, and on behalf of betas everywhere I want to drop-kick that person.) But I can't help but wonder how many smaller writers are now scared or don't want to post, and what this will do to the fandom long term. It's a huge fandom, but huge =/= invulnerable.
If you think you've found AI, just hit the back button. For an AI poster, lack of engagement is the worst thing. They'll see the hits go up but the lack of kudos and comments and know something is wrong.
























