I have answered a few asks about TADC because I know how important transfem Jax has been to a lot of people, and I donβt want to take that away from anyone, but I am very critical of the use of the song βIsnβt She Lovely?β being reclaimed as a coming out scene, when the original song was written by a Black man about the birth of his Black daughter. Keeping in mind the racism from some of the voice actors, and the lukewarm apology from the creator, it is very insidious to me to take a Black-specific song and reclaim it as something else. It very much feels like βtaking Black art without caring about the bodies that made it.β
Obviously, this has already been pointed out by Black people in the fandom, but I wanted to bring it up because Iβve had a few asks about that song specifically that Iβm not comfortable with answering. I am extremely happy that Jax is canonically transfem because even though Iβve never watched the show, Iβve witnessed peopleβs excitement about it, and Iβm not trying to rain on anyoneβs parade, but Iβm also not going to pretend like the racism doesnβt exist because thatβs not the kind of blog Iβm running here. Any other song couldβve been used, and perhaps there wasnβt much thought put into its choice; Iβm sure it wasnβt a deliberate act of malice, because from an outsider perspective that song seems to fit perfectly, but that ultimately doesnβt make it any less harmful, especially given the context surrounding the production.
I feel similarly about how United In Grief by Kendrick Lamar became a popular TikTok sound for people to make funny jokes about something going wrong when the original lyrics are specifically about Black grief. Or about the new trend of βthe saxaphones are getting louderβ taken from Boyz N The Hood, which is a movie about Black-American experiences that a lot of (white) people using this sound likely havenβt even seen.
Iβm not saying itβs inherently bad to use these songs in different contexts, but itβs a pattern that keeps repeating of Black-specific art being taken by white people without the original context in mind and being used for their own experiences instead. Itβs important to at least notice this pattern.
#and franklyβ¦ #the fact that it wasnβt an intentionally malice decision IS racism in itself #because even though the song is by a Black singer his thoughts and emotions he put into the lyrics were not taken into consideration #people donβt *usually* just write music just to write it. music is emotionally charged. hence using music in such a big scene #β¦ but they DID NOT CONSIDER him or his daughter because they are Black
Prev tags, youβre right and this is also extremely important to bring up






















