hey girl! I’m a chemistry masters student in my second semester & I’m on my way to committing to a lab for my thesis :) may I ask how you went about committing to a certain lab? As someone who likes a lot of topics, making a pro con list has been so challenging!!
Hi there fellow chemistry student! :D
To be honest, I made my decision rather early (sometime between my first and second years of uni), when I didn't know that much about chemistry yet. I had a favorite professor and thought his research seemed interesting, but I chose *him* rather than the lab/ research area, so to say. Sure, I did some reading and a lot of thinking first, but there was also some luck involved, in the sense that in the end, I really did fall in love with these areas of chemistry.
Still, even in hindsight, I agree with what many other people used to tell me when I was a baby chemistry student: that the supervisor is more important than the thesis topic. A good professor can make tedious work easier and more enjoyable. A bad professor can make you detest the most interesting topic. A TL;DR of how I chose my supervisor: I took his class in my first semester, and he was kind, encouraging, very, very demanding but also very, VERY good at teaching, and I continuously had the impression that I could learn so much more from him beyond that class.
If I could do it all over again, I think I'd do it exactly the same way I did back then: think about who I'd like to work with first, what I want to work on second.
But it's not like I just decided I wanted THIS person to be my thesis supervisor, no more thinking involved. Other things I considered very deeply were:
do I want to do experimental work or theoretical? For me personally this one was easy, because I love being in the lab and am not very good with computers 😅
do I want to do something synthesis-heavy like orgo? I enjoyed doing "simpler" syntheses, one-pot stuff, none of that complex apparatus that organic chemists love, so again, I could reject all the orgo research teams;
what classes do I enjoy the most? Especially the labs - because I wanted to do experimental work - where do I feel really in my element? Which classes do I miss/ could see myself missing in the future? For me that was inorgo and pchem, so an intersection of these two sounded perfect for me;
and similarly, what do I enjoy studying the most? What chemistry-related topics do I seek out in my free time? What gives me that feeling of curiosity and fascination whenever I come across it? Is there any team at my faculty whose research seems to encompass most of those? At the time, I had a newly found interest in coordination chemistry, I was having fun in pchem lectures (don't judge me), and I had always found spectroscopy very intriguing. And coincidentally, there was a research team that merged all three, and my favorite professor happened to be in it.
But really, I would encourage you to spend some time thinking about all these deeply, pick some labs that look promising and skim through a few papers published there to see what sparks particular interest in you, yes, all this, but then just... Leave it for a while. Go for a walk, take a nap, let thoughts simmer in your head for a bit. And then you may realize that you've already made up your mind long ago. It works for me!