Carrd
I have a take that seriously risks not just censorship by Tumblr but probably being taken out of context and ripped to shreds as well: the rights of suicidal people are a matter of bodily autonomy.
"suicide prevention" is a phrase that means a lot of things. some of those things are inarguably good: providing effective crisis support, counseling, and material assistance (e.g. housing, food, DV shelters, financial help, childcare, caregiver support, healthcare access initiatives, job training/better unemployment support, free therapy, peer support spaces, addiction/harm reduction services, etc etc etc) to people in extreme distress tangibly reduces the likelihood that they will kill themselves. we should keep doing these types of things. they are not what I'm arguing against right now; they are voluntary and wanted by the people that utilize them.
but other times, the phrase is used to predicate the use of force and coercion toward particular outcomes, often by physically preventing access to means via confiscation of possessions and/or restricting movement and/or subjecting the person to 24/7 supervision and/or giving high doses of medications with severe long-term effects and/or the use of invasive and sometimes life-altering interventions such as ECT, all often without the patient's consent and many times despite explicit protestation.
The latter approach, in my view, is unethical and violent, full stop.
Forcing someone to undergo medical treatment against their explicit wishes is unethical. Restricting someone's movements even when they are not a threat to others is unethical. These are not universally held views, but they are common ones, especially among those on the left - these principles also undergird a lot of pro-choice, anti-carceral, and pro-immigration advocacy. But do you know why that is, what the underlying source of the ethical transgression is? Those actions subvert a person's control over their own body and life.
One of the most basic consequences of bodily autonomy, at its core, is that no one else owns your body except you. No one can ethically dictate what you do or don't do to your own body.
My contention is simply that this principle includes suicide and self-harm.
Now, to be clear, I believe it is deeply tragic when people kill themselves. If you're reading this and you feel even remotely suicidal, or if you ever do in the future, I hope very deeply and very sincerely that you decide to live. There are good parts about the world and you deserve to experience them. But that is not my choice to make for you. That shouldn't be anyone's choice but your own. I think it is ethically good to do everything possible to suggest and convince you that life is worth living, because I think life-affirmation in the form of promoting well-being, connection, and community is among the highest moral goods, but force and coercion shouldn't enter into it.
This is because I don't want to live in a society that has to force people to be alive when they don't want to be. Not in the sense of "I don't like how society operates so I don't want to live," to be clear; I am not suicidal and haven't been in a fairly long while (although I have struggled with thoughts to that effect in the past), but in the sense of "I feel it is imperative to create a society that people affirmatively want to live in." That's our most important social project; that is our most important work.
And this conclusion reveals something that fascist and capitalist societies are deeply invested in hiding: suicide, like other forms of social murder, is not a simple result of illness or mere unexplainable tragedy. High suicide rates are a statistical condemnation of a society which alienates us and erases our needs. Suicide as an act says far more about society than it says about an individual. It is a total rebuke of the world stated in such severe terms that the author signs it with their own life. This is why our sociopolitical system is so keen to not just prevent it by any means necessary but also to minimize discussion of it. It's an unavoidably bad look for those in power when suicide rates rise.
The best suicide prevention will always, always consist of improving the world and improving quality of life, both on the individual and collective level, not locking up or overmedicating the patient.





















