Ironically, Iâm posting this to talk about Morning Musume.
This was SNSDâs 1st solo concert, in 2010. The members of SNSD are born 1989-1991, and the earliest began training in 2000/2001, at age 11/12. So this recording is with an average experience of 8 years, ages 20-21.
SNSDâs age range matches that of MMâs Rokkies/6th gen, born late 1988-1989. (not including Mikitty) They debuted with minimal training in 2003, so age 14-15. The height of Platinum Era would coincide in years of experience with SNSDâs, but most any pro will tell you that post-debut XP is so much more than pre-debut, so in practical terms, as of 2010 Iâd compare SNSD and Rokkie veteran-ness to be 5 and 7 years-ish, respectively.
Colorful Eraâs primary vocals are all 9th-11th gen. Thatâs 2011-2012, age range 1994-1999. Counting from Zukkiâs grad this past week, the experience range is 8 years to 4.5 years, at ages 17-22.
Anyways, the linked recording. Compare to the original âI canât believe weâre getting to debutâ rookie energy-ful recording. This is tight, controlled, paced. Instead of trying to display the heights of their vocal talent, like champing-at-the-bit rookie them did, theyâre singing more cutely to match the lyrics and melodic tonal imagery. In later concert tours, theyâd get comfortable/tired enough to start belting a little more again (2013), but that was also after the worst years of them getting overworked. The 2011 performance is still relatively more controlled.
ITNW is usually saved for the âlastâ set or encore set of the concerts, and it shows in the choreography. The dancing is measured, matched to the mid-tempo nature of the song, the veteran SNSD going for smooth and weighted instead of the rookie-sharp that pervades all of the Produce 101 covers. (and all covers of DBSKâs Mirotic, as well) In some tours, the choreo is abandoned entirely for walking and waving to the crowd at their own pace, or the recent ballad version.
Platinum had this same sense of very measured pacing. The Gorokkies (5th/6th gen) all had 5-7 years of post-debut experience under their belts at the start of Platinum Era, when SNSD was just debuting, and passed that pacing on to 7th and 8th gen, though the end of 2010. Hereâs what their concerts looked like in the same position as the OP video, towards the end of a 2010 concert, end of tour, non-ballad number.
Point is, Colorful Era is currently getting around the same experience and age range as SNSD and Platinum Era were in 2010. We should be seeing the same kind of veteran controlled, paced, performance.
We are really, really not.
The Colorful Era I saw at Zukkiâs grad is running themselves into the ground. Theyâre so fucking EXTRA at every moment. They started at 110% (for pacing), peaked mid-to-late concert at 200%, and finally settled during the encore at 170%. The only vocals that didnât go horribly ragged were Honey and the non-Maria members of 12th gen that barely got to sing anything.
These vocals were going even more ragged than how I saw rookie Berikyuu (sans Airi and Momoko) ruining their voices in the long term back in the day. And Berikyuu have never been this fast-paced and EXTRA in their dances, either.
I havenât checked on the recent Momoclo lives, but I have heard that their belter Momoka is having issues. Theyâre the other group that does large-scale solo concerts this EXTRA non-stop.
Iâm really worried about this lineup, guys!