Transcript: Vimm's Lair has been asked to remove many games from The Vault on behalf of Nintendo, Sega, Lego, and the ESA. While most of these games (and the hardware to play them) haven't been sold in decades, ultimately it's their prerogative so these games are now gone for good.
This was posted on the home page of Vimm's Lair today (June 6th, 2024) a huge loss for game preservation
To give a sense of scale for how many games this has affected, here's the previous post by Vimm from June 5th, 2024:
Two new requests arrived from opsecsecurity.com today. One on behalf of Sega Corporation requesting the removal of 188 games. The other is on behalf of the Entertainment Software Association requesting removal of 3114 games. The requested downloads have been removed.
There was (hopeful) speculation by Vimm's Lair users that these requests were made by copyright trolls, i.e., people sending in spoofed takedown requests to make a webmaster panic and/or remove a bunch of files, wasting everyone's time. As trolls do. Back in April of this year, Garry's Mod had a similar takedown request by Nintendo to remove 20 years of content in Garry's Mod that was based on Nintendo IPs [source: tomshardware.com]. Vimm reached out to Garry about the Vimm.net takedowns and confirmed that they were coming from the same people that had requested the very real takedowns for the Garry's Mod content.
From Vimm's May 25th, 2024 Vimm.net update on the first round of takedowns sent:
1. mm-nintendo.com is a fake domain that's not owned nor operated by Nintendo. Corporations contract out services all the time. That doesn't make them any less real. mm-nintendo.com is registered by MarkMonitor, a known brand protection company. The operator claims to represent Nintendo of America and Garry's Mod can attest they do.
In that same message board post, Vimm also proposed that these takedowns were very likely sourced by using an AI to find images of Nintendo IPs with which it then generated the takedown request since Nintendo uses opsecsecurity.com for their email, who offers "Protecting Online Brand Identity and Reputation" as one of their services. On opsecsecurity's page for this is listed such an AI tool:
Visual Artificial Intelligence (AI) to spot more forms of infringement. Infringements often manifest in online brand logos, trademarked text, and product imagery. Our platform uses Visual AI to focus on these visual aspects of branding and related media. By augmenting text-based detection, Visual AI is not restricted by channel, and also mitigates emerging threats. Visual AI organizes potential infringements by indicators found in the image for efficiency and enforcement at scale.
I'm adding this information because people were getting pissed at Twitter/Tiktok users for talking about Vimm's Lair—bringing traffic and publicity to the site—which has gotten archival and piracy sites or emulation tools taken down before. This may have contributed to it, but Nintendo and Sega were going to find these eventually anyway.
While it's deeply upsetting to see such a respected archival site as Vimm's get slapped by the Nintendo Hammer, we need to use this as a reminder that the internet is an ephemeral place; if you find something online that you enjoy, DOWNLOAD IT and make backups. The deleted Vimm's Lair files will live on within the servers of other ROM/ISO websites, but they will only survive if people save them, make copies, make backups of their copies, and continue to share these files. Do not rely solely on cloud services.
Repost, reupload, rehost.
Genuinely afraid that one day all hardware will be sold by either Google, Microsoft, or Apple. And all of them will have programs in it that allow for back doors and automatic removal of whatever they’ve defined as “you’re not allowed to have this”
If you don't already know this there's a push for open hardware, of particular interest is SBCs (I think Banana Pi is open hardware but the wording is a little unclear) which often can be used as alternative desktops. If open hardware can catch on we can fight against that





























