Hi. One of the main characters in my story is autistic, which makes her very particular about certain things (i.e. textures). However, sheâs also Jewish, and Iâm worried that I might be feeding the stereotype of Jewish women as complainers and nitpickers. How should I avoid this? Her autism does manifest in other ways but none that I found potentially problematic. Thanks!
Autistic Jewish character
Thanks for raising this, itâs an interesting point. In order to respect your autistic readers, youâll want to make sure her sensory issues arenât written as an annoying choice sheâs making. Itâs an involuntary physical reaction that will hopefully be described with empathy towards her. In my opinion, this solution should also be fine for avoiding the nagging trope, which is usually about how unreasonable the Jewish womanâs actions are and how inconvenient she is to others.
-Shoshi
A writer you should check out is the late Xan West (zâL), who wrote this experience from the inside with several of their characters. Both heroines in Eight Kinky Nights (which comes with detailed content notes so you can skip the chapters with kink or sex if you prefer and youâre just reading for research), the hero in Their Troublesome Crush, and the heroine of Tenderness are autistic and Jewish. Tenderness I remember this being especially relevant, with on-screen stimming, plus itâs a short story and friendship-only, so this may be the most universally approachable option of the three. Just a heads up that itâs about friends helping the MC cope with being dumped, but itâs very loving.
Generally, thereâs a way to approach your characterâs needs in your own tone as a narrator that will coax and guide the reader to understand that their requests are justified. Thatâs more of a writing skill than a diversity skill.
--Shira
One thing we neurodiverse Jewish people LOVE is to look for signs of neurodiversity in Jewish historical figures! Autism is especially easy to read into a variety of different people, places, and eras, and one thing thatâs conspicuously missing from problematic depictions of Jewish women is any connection with Jewishness earlier than 19th-century Europe. Looking for and finding positive representation in her own Jewishness can help her be positive representation herself.
-Meir
So everyone has very good points about Jewish characters and writing the internal narration, but I want to raise a different point: how outside characters relate to these sensory sensitivities will need to be established in order to well and truly avoid this stereotype.
Because autistic people are absolutely seen as nags! Sometimes we kind of are, because the only way to get any respect is often to make a huge fuss to play along with stereotypes in order to get accommodations, because the outside world loves to gaslight about autistic experiences. Thereâs out and out a poem called âGrowing up autistic / growing up gaslitâ that can shine some light on things.
It will be much easier to avoid any sort of naggingâeither assumption or performanceâif you surround your characters with supportive people who accept the sensory issues as soon as theyâre brought up and donât force either suffering or escalation, which can very easily be read as nagging.
Youâre going to need to create some sort of supportive environment where the sensitivities genuinely donât matter for social acceptance, because thatâs pretty much the only way to avoid getting the character to repeat that they need x over and over and over again.
Even better, if theyâre old friends, the sensory sensitivities have already been accommodated long ago and theyâre in a routine of just going through it the way the autistic character needs.
If the autistic character is in one of those gaslight-y situations, maybe consider having one of her friends do the heavy lifting of advocacy? Or backing her up in the advocacy. This will help avoid the worst of the âsingular person wants something ridiculousâ implications that come along with both the Jewish Nag and the Gaslit Autistic presentations.
Youâre going to need to do more work than just establish internal stuff to the reader (you donât specify if this main character is a point of view character, which, if sheâs not, will make internal establishing impossible). Youâre going to need to look at the environment to see what, if any, factors will create situations that make nagging-like behaviour inevitable.Â
Some such situations include:
Disbelief that x can produce y
Assumptions that itâs possible to tough out (for some of us, btw, it actually is, up to a point)
Assumptions that the provided accommodations are good enough (âwhat do you mean, you can hear x through your headphones? We turned the volume down as low as weâll put it!â)
Conflicting access needs (shockingly common, as even within autistic spheres you can get hypo and hyper sensitiveâ for example some autistics need bland food because theyâre hypersensitive to taste, while other autistics need tons and tons of spices because theyâre hyposensitive)
People doubling down on doing a thing because they want to stick it to the âsnowflakeâ (basically everyone disabled has some sort of story or knows of someone who has some sort of story where a coworker or clerk purposely tripped the sensitivity because once they found out about the accommodation, they insisted it couldnât be that big a deal and often landed the person in hospital)
Food workers get special mention because, oh my god, the number of them who will not make your order exactly the way you want it because they donât think you need sugar free or gluten free or anything they consider a âfadâ is a lot
You get the gist. And in all of these situations, you either have to leave, or you have to be firm, or, in worst case scenarios, you have to throw a fit to get it fixed.Â
Having a supportive environment makes all the difference to establish a person is not a nag or nitpicky by nature, and when theyâre in a place where theyâre respected, they are totally different people because theyâre not constantly stressed out and on the verge of meltdown.
Yes, autistic people can be rigid, and very meticulous, but you can show that happening in positive ways, as wellâlike them memorizing the favourite things of all their friends and giving it to them when their friends feel down. Or even just having a harmless routine that goes like: wake up, drink orange juice with their multivitamin, then brush their teeth so they donât taste the juice and toothpaste mix.
Basically, look at the environment on top of the internal. Itâs a lot easier to not be a nag when generally respected.
~Mod Lesya
P.S. for anyone who wants to come in and say âautisticâ is the wrong term: please donât. Itâs the majority-preferred language by quite a lot of the community, including the WWC autistic mods.Â
Published Nov 2021


















