for the last time yâall cannot âmiku made thisâ harry potter. you cannot separate harry potter from jkr and her bigotry because the text itself is FULL of it. a short list of the bullshit thatâs in hp that yâall cannot pretend doesnât exist within the actual text:
-the goblins who run the banks, which are obvious antisemitic caricatures
-rita skeeter, a transmisogynistic caricature (the books often reference her âmasculine featuresâ and sheâs portrayed as being predatory and spying on children)
-boys being unable to enter the girls dormitories (innocuous on its own but becomes very sinister when you know her beliefs)
-the fact that thereâs maybe 5 canonically black characters in the books (hell i can only think of 3 off the top of my head)
-the house elves just LOVE being slaves and when hermione tries to free them shes viewed as being âweirdâ and over the top about it
-the horrific treatment of cho chang, who is (to my knowledge) the only canonically east asian character
-the fact that thereâs a âpureblood supremacistâ house in hogwarts and everyone is just fine with that
-likening lycanthropy to AIDS is troubling on its own but especially considering fenrir greybackâs big goal was to âspread itâ is⌠oof
-the whole WOG gay dumbledore fiasco gets even worse when we remember that he was apparently in love with a fascist. also the fact that she said he âturned asexualâ afterwards which is not how asexuality works
-the fact that hermione was 14 and viktor krum was 18 when he took her to whatever that fuckin dance was called and this is just seen as totally fine and not weird at all
and thereâs SO much more, this is just all i can remember off the top of my head. like⌠yâall canât pretend these flaws in the books donât exist. the movies are just as bad and in some respects even worse, especially considering the lack of characters of color. you CANNOT ignore this shit when youâre reading or watching harry potter. and this isnât even getting into the fantastic beasts series and the mess of stuff that comes with that.
jk rowling has BEEN a racist antisemitic transphobic bigot. we KNEW this.
yâall are allowed to like harry potter. nobodyâs gonna stop you. i understand that for some people itâs very meaningful to them and i get that. but you have GOT to be critical of it. you canât just pretend jkrâs voice isnât there. it is, and itâs a big part of the story. you can like problematic media (theres some problematic media that i enjoy critically) but itâs irresponsible to consume it uncritically and without examining it through that lens.