Extremely brief local history of North Carolina and a broader context for Sybil and the Forsyths.
Benjamin Forsyth was a Moravian war hero in the War of 1812. Moravians are an ethnic minority and religious sect that settled in North Carolina after first landing in Georgia and then Pennsylvania. Forsyth County North Carolina is named for our Moravian Colonel. Winston-Salem North Carolina was founded as a central hub for the now-Moravian region. Moravians were communal and notably pretty egalitarian, educating both men and women. They also had an ethical opposition to slavery as an institution, but their communal social structure in North Carolina necessitated so much labor that they ended up slave owners anyway. Collectively. Neither private nor personal ownership was allowed. Initially, slaves were more like indentured servants, bizarrely unfree community members. The inescapable inequality and incoherence of the arrangement where white and black Moravians existed in unfree and free categories side by side was untenable and was fed by North Carolina’s particular unease about slave revolts.
Moravian history with slavery honestly mirrors Indigenous history with slavery to some extent. They weren’t staunch abolitionists like Quakers. Rather like several First Nations, Moravians participated in the slave trade, and like the First Nations, they were some of the first people to build resistance to the institution of slavery. Even this resistance is complicated however, as Nation members would return slaves for money or incorporate them into tribes rather unpredictably (a lot of US capture policy was based on pre-colonial Indigenous capture practice). The relationship is ambiguous and ambivalent rather than benevolent, and it persists. See the Cherokee Nation disowning its Black members as the Moravian Church continues to struggle with the work of reconciliation.
This is the history Kaneeka’s name is invoking.
All of this happens before the Civil War, in which North Carolina specifically saw a horrific loss of life (not just Confederate) and went on to suffer some of Reconstruction’s most profound failures.
This is where Silas Scarlet comes in. Former confederate who not only benefits after the war but sets up a damn mine. Mining is not ancient history. Most of the quartz in your electronics comes from North Carolina. But Scotch-Irish farmers pushed into the state’s mountains were the first non-Natives to mine. Early conflicts were between Natives and Settlers over resources. Massive Capitalist Landowners like Silas created an entirely different situation. North Carolina didn’t see labor riots and revolts like its Appalachian neighbors. It just saw constant pointless loss of life.
I’ve provided this context because the South gets treated like some kind of homogeneous political strawman, and Scarlet Hollow is smarter than that.
Sybil is interesting here. She’s an ambiguous figure. Equal parts predator and refugee where the world’s horrors are concerned. Is she Slavic like the Moravians? Scotch-Irish like so many Appalachian migrants? I don’t know that it matters. She’s evoking these conflicts and mixed histories for us so that we look more closely at our own presumed innocence. All of this is of course now made even plainer through Kaneeka’s own ambiguous position and the horror of what Sybil has become. She’s an active participant, and she’s someone who has tried to walk away from the sacrifice before. It’s our family, and thus our PCs who are implicated as the entirely unambiguous rapacious exploiters here. And isn’t it interesting that we’ve been offered a witch to blame.

























