"I wrote a eulogy for my best friend last week. Then I read it to him. At the pub. On a Tuesday."
He was alive, holding a pint, looking at me like I'd lost my mind. Maybe I have.
I'm Mick. I'm 70. The man across the table was Barry. Seventy-two. Best mate for 46 years. Met on a building site in 1979. He dropped a plank on my foot. I called him something unrepeatable. He bought me a pint after the shift. Haven't gone a week without talking since.
Three months ago we went to a funeral. Bloke we'd worked with. Cancer. The eulogies were beautiful - people saying what he meant to them, things they'd clearly never said to his face. And all I could think was, he can't hear any of this.
Every beautiful sentence. Every "he changed my life." Said to a room of crying people and a box of wood.
I turned to Barry. Whispered, "What a waste."
Drove home. Couldn't sleep. Because I realised, if Barry died tomorrow, I'd stand up and say extraordinary things about this man. Things I've never said in 46 years. And he'd be in the box, missing all of it.
So I wrote them down. Took a week. Harder than expected - not finding the words, but admitting I had them.
Rang him. "Tuesday. The Crown. Need to read you something."
"Have you joined a book club?"
"Just come."
Same corner table. Pint of bitter. Crisps. I pulled out the paper. He saw my hands shake.
"Mick. What's this?"
"Your eulogy. I'm reading it now because I'm not wasting it on a day you can't hear it."
"Have you gone mad?"
"Probably. Shut up and listen."
I read it. In a pub. To a man very much alive and very much uncomfortable.
I told him about the plank and how it was the best injury of my life. About the night he drove forty minutes in rain to help change a tyre. About how he rang every day for three months after my divorce and never once asked "Are you alright?" - just talked about football and weather, because he knew I didn't need a question. I needed a voice.
I told him he was the funniest man I'd ever known and his jokes were terrible and both things were true. That he'd been a better father than he thinks. That his wife's a saint and he knows it. That I'd have been a worse man without him.
He didn't look at me. Stared at his pint. Jaw tight. Doing that thing men do when the feelings arrive and they'd rather swallow glass than show it.
When I finished, long silence. Then he picked up his pint, took a sip, and said,
"You're paying for the next round. And the one after."
That was his answer. Perfect. Because Barry doesn't say "I love you too." He says "you're buying."
But in the car park, he hugged me. Not the quick back-pat. A real one. Thirty seconds. Neither let go first.
And he said quietly into my shoulder, "Don't read that again at the real one. I want new material."
Who would you write a eulogy for - while they're still here?
Don't wait. The flowers can't hear. The box doesn't laugh. Say it now. At the pub. Over a bad cup of tea. You'll feel ridiculous.
They'll look uncomfortable. It'll be the most important thing you've ever done.
Read them the speech while they can still hug you in the car park.â
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
I maintain that the best summation of my feminist beliefs are that men and women are not fundamentally different. There are a few quantifiable differences if you average out every woman and every man, but they are not qualitative. And most of them are socially constructed, and would be fixed if we started treating men and women the same. Neither is inherently smarter, neither is inherently kinder, neither is inherently more stoic or stronger or angrier or softer. Everyone is obsessed with the differences between women and men, with finding them and creating them and distancing themselves from the "other half". It's fucked up
Toward evening, as the light failed
and the pear tree at my window darkened,
I put down my book and stood at the open door,
the first raindrops gusting in the eaves,
a smell of wet clay in the wind.
Sixty years ago, lying beside my father,
half asleep, on a bed of pine boughs as rain
drummed against our tent, I heard
for the first time a loonâs sudden wail
drifting across that remote lakeâ
a loneliness like no other,
though what I heard as inconsolable
may have been only the sound of something
untamed and nameless
singing itself to the wilderness around it
and to us until we slept. And thinking of my father
and of good companions gone
into oblivion, I heard the steady sound of rain
and the soft lapping of water, and did not know
whether it was grief or joy or something other
that surged against my heart
and held me listening there so long and late.
thinking about how quietly heartbreaking it is that ilya is seen as this super good ally by every queer character in game changers when ilya so badly wants to be open and proud about his sexuality. no one reads him as gay or bi, and he can get away with a lot because of it, but that is also so lonely because he feels this distance between him and an openly gay character like harris who is so comfortable with his sexuality and is at the point where he doesn't need to hide it or shield himself from the world. whereas ilya needs to be read as straight for both his protection and to protect his relationship with shane. and there is something so heartbreaking when you are not out, but people just assume you're straight and use heteronormative language to describe you and a potential partner/your future, and you have to just sit there and bite your tongue. and it's not safe to be out and you know this realistically, but there is a part of you that so badly wants someone to look at you and see you for what you really are- especially around other queer people.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Ilya accidentally lets slip during a lowkey interview that he doesn't have a lot of free time lately because he's been studying for his Canadian citizenship test between games, practice, and other obligations, so that he can pass his first try at it.
"What even is riding? What is governer general? So many weird English words. Don't get me started on history. Why do I have to remember there was strike in Winnipeg a hundred years ago? Was Scott Hunter there?"
The clip goes somewhat viral, but it doesn't spread far until he's doing a post-game interview where one reporter, after asking their question about the game, asks, "Where does the name 'Canada' come from?"
"What?"
The reporter kind of embarresedly repeats, "Where does the word 'Canada' come from? It's on the Canadian citizenship test."
Ilya stares blankly for a moment then says, slowly, "It means village, I think. From Indigenous language? Why are you asking questions from citizenship test?"
The reporter shrugs. "You said you were having dfficulty studying for the test. Maybe it helps with studying?"
And THAT clip goes viral along with the first. It starts a trend of reporters asking questions from the Discover Canada study guide whenever the opportunity arises. It starts as a bit, but soon people get in invested and genuinely want to see Ilya pass his citizenship test. Fans start asking him questions from the study guide too, whenever they meet him at official events or out and about.
The first thing he does when he gets the results (after celebrating with the Hollanders and going to the bathroom to have a little cry over it), he posts them online and thanks everyone who helped him study.
yeah yeah i took an unintentional hiatus because farm stuff and no time and little internet. the bigger work is still stuck, sorta lodged sideways ever-given-style in the suez canal of my mind, but here is not quite a crackfic that I have inevitably taken too seriously.
I kept trying to get other people to write this premise and nobody quite did, so here's Shane Hollander taking Ilya Rozanov's word for it about his dick size, and maybe over-preparing.
Nine, on AO3
Maybe he just had to buy a dildo and compare it that way. It wasnât like he couldnât stand to have a few around. But he didnât want to be the kind of guy who had like eight dildos. Was he going to be the-- what was that fairy tale? Goldilocks. He was going to be Shane Goldilocks and the Eight Dildos. This oneâs too small! This oneâs too big! This one vibrates--
God help him.
When I first was outlining this (ok i have never outlined shit in my life i was just sort of vibing) i thought Ilya would be jealous of or threatened by a dildo that 1) shane owned that was 2) bigger than him, which I thought would be hilarious, but as i was writing this that failed to materialize. because like damn, no, shane hollander's dildo and ilya are allies, and ilya is smart enough to know that.
He's very jealous and threatened by anyone that might come between him and Shane, but the dildo is just a sign of Shane's commitment to the kind of sex Ilya knows he can give him.
yeah yeah i took an unintentional hiatus because farm stuff and no time and little internet. the bigger work is still stuck, sorta lodged sideways ever-given-style in the suez canal of my mind, but here is not quite a crackfic that I have inevitably taken too seriously.
I kept trying to get other people to write this premise and nobody quite did, so here's Shane Hollander taking Ilya Rozanov's word for it about his dick size, and maybe over-preparing.
Nine, on AO3
Maybe he just had to buy a dildo and compare it that way. It wasnât like he couldnât stand to have a few around. But he didnât want to be the kind of guy who had like eight dildos. Was he going to be the-- what was that fairy tale? Goldilocks. He was going to be Shane Goldilocks and the Eight Dildos. This oneâs too small! This oneâs too big! This one vibrates--
God help him.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
one of the things i find most compelling about ilya and shane is. well. imbalance. it's so rich it's so goddamn full of minerals it's insane. yes there's the closer to the surface stuff. the shane has, ilya has not. friends, teammates, family. yes yes, all important, all good stuff, but it's more it's---
okay so ilya can read shane like a book, which is no surprise. this boy, with his upbringing? would be able to spot an emotion from a mile away. this boy has a masters degree in microexpressions and he would have graduated at the age of like, eight. the tempo of the tapping fingers on the bench, the weight of footfalls on the floorboards, the "is their bed made today?", "is he wearing his rings today?", the "she didn't hug me as tight and he shut the door just a bit too loudly and fuck i don't want to come home from hockey practice," because reading the room is surviving it.
that boy's every breath was inextricably tied to the unpredictable beast of one, nay, two, angry men and a desperately sad woman. there was no room left for him to expand.
enter ilya freshly, what, 17? hockey prodigy, safe from family-induced suffocation by 4000 odd miles. he's a pro. he clocks shane in about as long as it takes for him to light his fourth cigarette. he sees the freckles and that gay panic and he thinks, im going to have some fun.
and he clocks him again and again. he sees shane so well, he sees the perfectionism, he sees the pressure he sees the anxiety and the discomfort and the head-down-ass-up-yearning to get cracked and is blind only to the fact that shane could possibly see something worth more than hotel room fucks in him.Â
but over time? over years and years? the weight of seeing is heavy. particularly when it's not, well, reciprocated? at least not to the same extent. shane's particular brand of issues lend themselves to a kind of self-centredness that just does not give way to picking up on those microexpressions like ilya does. ilya has to reach that point of vulnerability (which is so utterly torturous for an avoidant) where he has to actually say the shit out loud, before Shane really notices and kicks himself into gear. that shit is heavyyyyy.
we are 11 years down the line by the end of TLG right? reid does touch on this a little bit in that book ya, but I guess, i want more. what does the next 11 years look like? this dynamic cannot continue and end well. so, what? someone put it under a microscope and lemme seeee
girl u gotta warn me before u point the bat signal directly in my eyes. (you pointed it at the sky iâm just already standing over it breathing heavily)
i think yes, not being anticipated in the way ilya has a 30-year endowed chair professorship in Clocking it Studies does hurt. to some extent hypervigilance is an implicit cry for someone else to be as careful with you as you are with the world
and also! shane is without an agenda or assumptions or intuition. he just asks, and heâd like to hear the answer, and heâs completely willing to go in the wrong direction and be physically turned towards the problem. andâitâs also okay if ilya isnât ready to share. i would imagine that the implied patience of that, the âiâm here whether or not you rip yourself open for me,â is its own safety to be grateful for. two sides of a coin, maybe. i think for ilya much more than shane itâs not possible to get everything he needs from his romantic partner (part of why it irks me so bad that reid gave him no other intimate, consistent ties)âhe needs, and presumably will, find other funny, damaged people with whom the ironic distance isnât distance at all. also, like, how long does it take to completely shed the reflex to hide? i donât think it ever goes away fully. a partner whoâs bugged by that becomes its kind of stress
and when shane does make a jump or an inference itâs so plainly open: âhey, thatâs not what this is, you and me. maybe it was at first, but not now and not for a long time.â what???? for someone who watched for danger, but who would also have caught and been hit just as brutally by vanishing glimpses of care and love, what a fucking relief that what you see is pretty much what you get (after some basic algebra about the closet and control issues and maybe some weird mom stuff. ilyaâs got it), and that what you get is uncomplicated, whole, thorough devotion. secure attachment is no small gift
i dunno i think a lot about how one model for parity in relationships is based on equal rest. i do wonder whether on the whole ilya rests as much with shane as shane does with ilya. if he doesnât i agree itâs for exactly the reasons youâve enumerated
Lothiriel exists in LotR as a mere name in a genealogical table-- the youngest child, and only daughter, of Prince Imrahil of Dol Amroth, she gets married to Eomer early in the First Age and provides him with at least one son. I wrote a great deal about her when I was new to the fandom.
This is my idea of what she and Eowyn, similar to her in age (four years older) would have gotten up to after the fall of Sauron, before the menfolk got back from their last foray into contested lands.
I got the tag on this and was like what's this about and clicked through and thought hey that sounds like something I'd like to read, wait did I write that, and sure enough. I wrote this. I haven't reread it but I'm about to.
I'm gonna guess that while this was uploaded to AO3 in 2014 I probably wrote it around a decade before that. I don't know if I could find out by looking back at my LJ (since ported to Dreamwidth of course) but I should try.
Anyway. wow. Blast from the past. Thanks for the rec!!!
Fic Post: The Honorable Siblinghood of Equipment Managers
So, uh. I finished the core draft of the sequel to Everything You Know, but it's not ready to post yet. Instead of returning to any of my in-progress WIPs, I... did this. Please enjoy the Honorable Siblinghood of Equipment Managers and Shane Hollander's Jockstrap of Theseus. Also a longer-than-necessary digression with Luca Haas, because I can.
In which Shane Hollander has the favour of the Honorable Siblinghood of Equipment Managers (or at least, the South-Eastern Canada regional meeting thereof) (5494 words) by ineptshieldmaid
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Game Changers | Heated Rivalry - All Media Types, Heated Rivalry (TV)
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Shane Hollander/Ilya Rozanov
Characters: OMC (Metros Equipment Manager), Shane Hollander, Dale | Ottawa Centaurs's Equipment Manager (Game Changers), Ilya Rozanov, Luca Haas
Additional Tags: outsider pov, shane hollander's jockstrap of Theseus, hockey superstitions and rituals, small magics, mentions of Gentle Walks With The Swiss
Summary:
The best players, Stefan's mentor had told him, are like racehorses: highly strung, and easily spooked. Hollander was the best of the best. And his career - the challenge of working with him and his particular routines - had elevated Stefan's standing in the Honorable Siblinghood, so it was as much professional debt as favouritism that had Stefan taking a particular interest in Hollander, by the time he came out to the locker room. Stefan expected to be working with him until one or other of them retired. [âŚ]
If, after that, Hollander's skate laces were replaced before they started to wear thin, and if the new laces passed through the hands of at least two fully-sworn Senior or Very Senior Equipment Managers before they met his skates, that was within Stefan's discretion. He never even spoke of it, directly, to his team.
One of my favorite things Harriet says throughout all Sayer's novels is this, when asked by Lord Peter if she thought life was worth living:
"I've always felt absolutely certain it was good--if only one could get it straightened out. I've hated almost everything that ever happened to me, but I knew all the time it was just things that were wrong, not everything. Even when I felt most awful I never thought of killing myself or wanting to die--only of somehow getting out of the mess and starting again."
when you remember you have thirteen thousand words of unfinished fanfic in your google docs and itâs good words and a good fic but it needs another thirteen thousand words to be finished and released into the world and youâre never gonna do that
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
I think Ilya has a little fantasy of being snuggled up on a couch with Shane under one arm and Sveta under the other watching a hockey game and listening to the two of them eviscerate the two teams. It's not even really sexual (although Shane and Svetlana are the two hottest people Ilya knows), its just if he could be one place at any given time with any given people it would be there with them.
Ilya playing 4-D chess with Svetlana because after the first time he watches a game with Yuna and David this fantasy expands: he wants Sveta with her feet in his lap, Shane under one arm, Yuna across from them and David next to her, the three Shane, Sveta and Yuna arguing about hockey while David and Ilyaâs eyes meet and they understand each other on a soul frequency.
But obviously he canât just drag Sveta, whoâs mad at him for leaving Boston, to meet his boyfriendâs parents. And the rare time he has with Shane he doesnât want to spend hosting, even if it is Sveta.
So itâs years down the line before this actually comes about. Theyâre at Ilya and Shaneâs Ottawa home, itâs probably early season and he expects Yuna and Sveta to be on a tear about new rookies and these particular teamsâ new strategies. They are, that part is true.
What he hasnât counted on is Svetaâs thirsting over hockey players. Maybe he thought she might give it up, given sheâs in the presence of Shane Hollander, but no. That goalie is aging well, this defencemanâs longer hair is really working for him, would you look at that smirk on that guy?
Ilya was not prepared for Shane to counter Svetaâs appraisal with âeh, heâs like a beefier version of Carter Vaughn with a busted nose and weaker slapshotâ.
He was really not expecting Yuna to join in. That rising hotshot with dark eyebrows and a smoulder reminds her of a young Chris Chelios. Sveta is right about the goalie aging well but has she considered the coach? Yuna remembers him as a player, he was good on the ice but nothing exceptional to look at, but age and a stylish suit working out well for him.
So this is how Ilya ends up spending the intermission periods trapped between his best friend, his husband, and his mother-in-law, all rating the attractiveness of hockey players past and present.
At some point Yuna remembers that Ilya is attracted to men, and asks his opinion, and he has to admit that while he thinks some of Svetaâs preferences are weird, heâs never really been an ogler of hockey players. Well. Except one.
Ilya snugs his arm closer around Shane.
Yuna and David: *collective awww*
Shane, indignant: liar. You think Scott Hunter is hot. You thought he was hot when we were rookies, you hypocrite!
Sveta, who had noticed Ilya had a thing about Hunter but never got him to admit it: were you two meeting up and talking about hot boys? Iâm jealous, Ilya. Sex with your rival is one thing but youâre supposed to talk to _me_ about boys!
Shane, forgetting his parents as the ghost of his jealousy is summoned: oh it was definitely a sex thing.
Ilya: I THINK THE GAME IS BACK ON
DAVID, a bit behind the conversation: I think Hunter has aged well. Or maybe coming out changed how he carries himselfâŚ
SHANE: Yeah youâre not wrong but I always thought, of the two of them, Vaughn is the more handsome, and heâs certainly no worse for wearâŚ
Sveta high-fives Shane in agreement. Yuna realises she has always thought the same, and sheâs missed out on decades of agreeing with Shane about this.
Ilya could have lived without knowing Shaneâs opinions on their hottest colleagues and rivals, really.
Hi Balls, I was reading your essay post and I am interested by how youâre making fun of the AI generated story winning the literary prize and calling it nonsensical and pointing out meaningless sentences. I remember a few months ago you were calling some fans âlosersâ for making callout posts and blocklist for AI fic writers discovered on ao3? Is this a contradiction of your own opinion or did your stance change and you now agree that AI users should be named and shamed?Â
tldr: you are literally making my point for me.
I genuinely don't know how to say this without sounding patronising but, respectfully, the âexplanationâ for why I hold both opinions at onceâie that the only thing more ridicuous than a clearly AI generated story winning the fucking Commonwealth Short Story Prize of all things is peopleâs reactions to the scandal, and that âfansâ witchunting and harassing fellow fans over perceived AI usage on Ao3 need to get a fucking grip and sit on the naughty step for a whileâcan be easily sussed out if you spent some time thinking about it instead of trying to catch people out or whatever the fuck this is.
when it comes to, idk man, an AI generated Stucky coffee shop AU being posted on Ao3, there is no âinjusticeâ happening, no matter how emotively you frame it. because there are no stakes whatsoever: respectfully, please understand that the judging panel of the Commonwealth Short Story Prize, ie one of the worldâs most famous awards for short fiction that has launched the literary careers of multiple authors across the world, and the editorial board of Granta, one of the most prestigious Anglophone literary magazines, are not logging on to Ao3 and typing in Jungkook/Jimin Omegaverse Spitroasting (include tag: Breeding Kink) in search of the next Salman Rushdie (and I am saying this as someone who wrote queer theory piss fic).
the Commonwealth Prize case is not interesting to me because AI bad and human writing good. the interesting aspect is what the judges' failure to notice this story tells us about how writing gets evaluated by the institutions that hold power over which stories are told, and how. the harm is not "an AI wrote thisâ lmao it is "an institution responsible for certifying literary value demonstrated that its evaluation criteria for a specific writing tradition are so underspecified that they can be satisfied by outright pattern-matching." and this is actually exactly the point i am making about why itâs so fucking irritating to see losers (a term i stand by) publicising lists of fanfics and authors they have decided are ai generated.
anyway. being published on Ao3 is not exactly a marker of quality. anyone can publish on Ao3. i could photocopy a picture of my asshole, superimpose FĂŤanorâs face on it, claim itâs a representation of him in the Eternal Darkness, and then post it on Ao3 tomorrow. if the argument is that AI writing is âlow quality slop that doesnât belong in the archiveâ, then does that mean everything on Ao3 that is humanly written a âhigh qualityâ literary masterpiece? does it mean that only works fitting a certain criteria, such as *checks notes* only three emdashes a page, âdeservesâ to be published on Ao3?
with all due respect, no. just because someone wrote something does not mean the thing is (again I am speaking in terms of literary âqualityâ as judged by competitions and tradpub etc rather than whether or not it appeals to people) worthy of commendation. also donât even try with the âbut the environmental/social impact of AI means people i decide have used AI MUST be harassed on tumblrâ. are you weighing the moral positionality of every author you kudos? what if your all time favourite porno was written by someone who owns a real fur coat? what scale of morality are you using here, and why is the moral worth of another human being contingent upon what you think counts as AI or not AI?
anyway. when you post a fic on Ao3, you are participating in a community, not nominating your fic for the Booker Prize. and this is why fanfic is so diverse and fun and varied in style and form and all that. because most things appeal to someone or the other out there, even if your fic is just a description of Aragorn unbuckling his belt when someone asks him to choose between washing his hair or shitting in his hands and clapping. the whole point of it is that it is fun and not ruled by literary prize criteria. hence, even if someone did write an AI generated fic and posted it on Ao3, they are not exactly seeking a prestigious certification of literary capability and neither is Ao3 or its reader offering that. there is no institution here claiming authority to certify quality, no structural gatekeeping function, no literary tradition being characterised as imitable machinery by the people in power. Ao3 is an archive site. it operates outside literary legitimation because it does not claim to legitimise anything.
which leads to my next point:
bro why do you CARE đ
like if I came across that shitting in his hands and clapping fic, I would just say âewâ and scroll. If I came across a story I suspect to be AI generated, I would do the same thing. I have done this on countless occasions. I would not come onto another website and talk about how Author X should be beaten with hammers for her poop fic. or make a canva graphic of Author Yâs mdash usage? why would I do that when I could just use the time to find a fic I enjoy and read that instead?
if, like i said above, writing a fic and posting it is not a declaration of literary prowess or assumed quality and is simply the act of engaging with a community, then AI generated fics are, as much as you hate to see it that way, doing the same thing. the âwritersâ are engaging with the community with their AI fic. and sure, this way of engagement may be dishonest and what not, but clearly some people enjoy them and have made them popular or whatever, in which case that is a back and forth engagement. is the argument here that a couple of these fics have gotten a lot of comments or whatever? are we pretending that kudos and comments are now the measure of a ficâs quality, instead of reflecting whatever the primary audience in that fandom prefers to read?
there is no prize denoting literary worth that is handed out by kudos or comments or being posted on Ao3, this is just someone reading something and going yeah, I like this. are you going to go hound everyone who commented âgreat ficâ on every single fic where Naruto âgets peggedânot with a plug but a fingerâa quiet, thrumming evocation of the Sexy Jutsu on the tapestry of his pubes, floating on the grammar of his ballsâ??? this is a person in a community saying I enjoyed this; the lit prize is an institution exercising cultural authority in a way that dictates, to paraphrase Roy, which stories are told, by whom, and how. Ao3 is not doing that. Ao3 is doing the opposite of that. Ao3 says âthe person into Aragorn shitting into his hands and clappingâ can post whatever they want.
and like. again. what are you getting out of this? what is the end goal? to harass some twelve year old for writing and posting OCfic using ChatGPT? this shit is always framed through the lens of pedagogical care and âaccountabilityâ but what it actually is is just a pure flame war lol. what is the educational value of slagging off someone to the entire internet over a zero stakes situation with no payoff? what does such an action garner you aside from the chance to chest-thump about your own virtue?
and most importantly, what if youâre wrong?
and this is the point of all points lol, the one that overshadows all the others iâve made so far: the fact that what I am saying in my commonwealth prize writeup isnât a contradiction of me thinking people should not be conducting public witch hunts over fanfic, it actually proves the point i am making! because if these people, who are in terms of writing qualifications and academic background, ostensibly at the topmost layer of the literary world, who have read much much more in their fields than you or I, have, for free, offered us a box of popcorn and an enjoyable demonstration of a reading practice lazy enough to award a prestigious prize to an AI generated story, then what makes YOU so confident that your decision and subsequent public witchhunt is justified, that your eye for ârealâ literature and hallmarks of LLM generated writing, aside from really puerile shit like âgoody proctor used an emdashâ, is somehow better, is somehow good enough to harass people over?
idk man. in my book, a bunch of knowitall chucklefucks harassing people in their own community based entirely on vibes and a sprinkle of ship wars (yeah you mfs think youâre slick donât you đđđ), leads to a far more toxic community than a handful of young or inexperienced writers using LLMs and what not.
what you are doing is encouraging a paranoid reading practice in your own community, the community you partake in for fun! and like⌠man this is the thing that actually gets me, the thing that ties all of this together so bleakly: the paranoid reading practice this attitude is spreading in fan communities, the gleefulness of the witch-hunt, the "I have identified the tells" confidence⌠this is, structurally speaking, the same operation as what the prize judges used, just pointed in the opposite direction.
the judges had a model of what Caribbean literary fiction is supposed to look like and matched the text against it without actually reading it closely or engaging with it. AI-vigilantes on Ao3 have a model of what AI writing is supposed to look like and they're matching texts against that without actually reading them either. both of you are reading for the shape of a thing rather than the thing itself. both of you are outsourcing any actual encounter with the text to a paranoid checklist. and both your guns, subsequently, will misfire with potentially horrible consequences.
and I think the reason I find it worth saying all of this in one breath, the Commonwealth Prize, the judges, Granta uploading the story to some AI to ask about its AIness, the reactionary discourse, and yes, the AO3 witch hunts too, is that ALL of these are varying results of the same root problem, which is that we have collectively gotten very bad at tolerating the uncertainty and discomfort that actual literary engagement requires.
actual reading requires you to accept not-knowing, to at least attempt to stay in the room with a story that isn't immediately yielding to what you are demanding from it instead of deciding that something you do not understand on first skim does not deserve categorisation as ârealâ, requires you to ask "is this doing something I can't yet follow" before you ask "is this doing nothing???â.
itâs an uncomfortable place to be and I understand why people reach for the checklist instead, whether the checklist is emdash counting or "this sounds like the thing I knowâ or âpeople from X ship always use AIâ. but the cost of the checklist, the cost of this paranoid, mechanical, securitised and surveilled reading practice, is that you stop encountering writing on its own terms entirely. and at that point you're not reading, are you? you're just confirming what you already thought, and some poor writer somewhere, who might have made every decision in every sentence and could account for all of it, is getting caught in the net of your refusal to engage with uncertainty.
it all is just so fucking tragic man. like the intellectual honesty of going "I didn't understand this and I wonder why that is" seems to have been replaced by the comfortable "I didn't understand this and therefore it is bad/fake/not worth my time.â and what do you lose here? what is actively being destroyed? the possibility of a real, genuine encounter, the moment of encounter that reading fundamentally is, the experience of a text doing something to you that you weren't expecting it to do, that you didn't have a framework for and had to build one as you read. that experience requires vulnerability and an admission that your existing framework might be insufficient or at the very least not throwing your toys out of the pram the minute you find in a piece of writing something you consider morally wrong.
and yeah maybe youâre right lol. maybe i should be naming and shaming. so here you go: fuck a fanwriting culture that has entirely given up on the idea that reading is something a person can be wrong about in ways that should provoke curiosity, even if the result of that curiosity is just âtbh yeah this is bad writingâ. but alas, apparently we have decided that it's more important to be confident about what you're reading than to actually read it and find out.
anyway these are my thoughts, and iirc @allthingswhumpyandangsty had some excellent thoughts on the matter too but i am too sleepie to find linkie.
I think this was the very good post by allthingswhumpyandangsty re why all of us should be minding our own damn business over our suspicions re whether or not a fic is AI written.