I keep thinking about Louis reading Claudia's diary entry to Bruce, and it honestly isn't out of character, but it feels like such a violent violation in a way, compared to the other things he's done with her diaries. And while I'm not saying the other incidents were okay, I can see how he would justify them to himself as being for her. That's a lot harder to do this time.
BUT. This is Lestat's story. How much of that was what really happened? Did Louis recite those pages from Claudia's diaries to Lestat? Were those even really her words? I think finding out more about Louis's relationship with Lemuel will actually hugely affect my reading of this scene, because that phone call at the end could so easily be Lestat projecting the same insecurities he always has about Louis partners (and I think black men, especially), and if so, that may be a cue to remember that this is Lestat's story. We also see Louis fly, which Louis himself says he can't do, and which we never saw him do in the objective reality scenes we got in IwTV.
Lestat was the one who first opened Claudia's diary, not Louis. Louis went with it, and he did plenty later, but Lestat started it. He chose to violate her privacy because of how she acted after he hurt her in a way that echoed his own trauma.
Louis reading that entry is intercut with Lestat's flashback. The show is making a connection for us. But Lestat is telling this story, right after spending an episode trying to convince himself his relationship with his mother is okay by trying to convince us, so how much of this is him making a connection for himself? His hallucination of Magnus mentions to Claudia by name in Lestat's side of this scene. No one else gets a name.
This is the same episode where he talks about Nicki; both watching Nicki lose his grip on reality and spin out into self harm, and literally watching Armand burning him, and the parallels between that and Lestat burning Claudia's dead lover are so strong, as are the ones between Lestat letting Nicki convince him to make him a vampire and him letting Louis pressure him into making Claudia a vampire. No doubt the memory of what happened with Nicki made him reluctant to get too close to Claudia, and I think his response to her behavior after the burning of her lover was probably deeply influenced by that. Louis's and Claudia's accounts of him during that time are so different from the person we see in his own memories leading up to Nicki's death, and I don't think that's solely a matter of who's telling the story.
Lestat is so defensive about what happened on that train, telling sideways truths that don't answer for what he was really accused of. "Did I threaten Claudia with rape on a train?"—maybe not, but unless for some reason it was changed in the book, that wasn't really the question.
Are we watching Louis violate Claudia in possibly the worst way he ever has (except maybe getting Lestat to turn her in the first place), or are we watching Lestat, finally, and far too late, think about how much her trauma, inflicted or mocked and exploited by him, resembled his own?





















