Can I, in fact, get you started on Yesterday? That's the movie premised on everyone just forgetting everything about the Beatles one day right?
Yes, and it drove me nuts because thatâs a great premise! But it was totally wasted in a way that I found extra frustrating, because they only needed to slightly reshuffle the existing pieces and give the love interest some kind of coherent characterization, and they just. did not do that.
So like. The premise of the movie is that Jack, the main character, is a struggling musician who gets hit by a car and knocked unconscious at the exact moment of a mysterious global blackout. When he wakes up in the hospital, he discovers that he is the only person on Earth who remembers the existence of the Beatles.
It takes him a bit to realize this: he quotes When Iâm Sixty-Four to his best friend Ellie at the hospital and she just gives him a weird look. When he plays a bit of Yesterday while hanging out with friends, they all freak out about how good his new song is, and he realizes that something is Weird.
Thereâs a fun scene where he frantically googles Beatles-related terms and comes up empty. âBeatlesâ turns up bugs and cars. Ringo Starr? Never heard of him. We find out that the band Oasis never existed either, and over the course of the movie there are a few more disappearances thrown in as jokes: Coca-Cola, cigarettes, and Harry Potter have also ceased to exist, or never were.
So Jack, who knows most of the Beatles catalogue by heart, and is a decent musician, decides to re-record them. And theyâre instant hits, and he starts getting money and fame and record deals thrown at him, and hanging out with Ed Sheeran (played by Ed Sheeran), and going on talk shows and so on. The movie rapidly turns into a parable about the cost of fame, not letting success change you, remembering whatâs more important than money and power, etc etc.
Itâs just like. kind of lazy about it? and the romance plot feels both incoherent and slapdash, because Ellie has no personality and no comprehensible motivations.
Like, sheâs been Jackâs music manager since they were teenagers, and sheâs been convinced he was destined for greatness since she saw him play Wonderwall at a school talent show, but she also is weirdly convinced that sheâs not good enough for him even before he becomes super famous. But Jack never actually stops being into her, even at the Peak Hubris part of the plot, and he eventually gives it all up and tells the world he didnât write any of the songs as part of a big dramatic love confession. Except itâs never really clear what was holding either of them back in the first place, or why a dramatic love confession was even necessary.
So, here is how I would fix the movie.
First, the romance plot feels super tacked on anyway so letâs just resolve it earlier and give the poor girl an actual job in the plot. Iâd have Jack sit Ellie down fairly early, after heâs released the first few songs and theyâve blown up but before the Fame Spiral starts, and say:
okay. look. I know this sounds nuts but either that accident caused the most specific brain damage in the history of the world, or I remember a different version of reality than everyone else, because I did not write these songs. I just remember them, and no one else does.
And the movie did actually set up a way for him to prove this, but they never used it! for some fucking reason! Because Wonderwall is the song that convinced Ellie that Jack was destined for musical greatness, and Wonderwall has also been erased. Which creates an opportunity, which the movie did not take, for a really effective scene where Jack asks Ellie what song he sang at the talent show. And she canât answer him, which freaks her out because thatâs a core memory! Thats the reason sheâs so devoted to Jack in the first place!
So he starts playing her the song. And she knows sheâs never heard it before, but she also knows that on some level, she recognizes it.
So from that point onwards, Ellie and Jack can be in cahoots, sharing the secret, which allows the romance to develop a lot more effectively and convincingly, and puts Ellie in a better position to talk Jack down from Fame Hubris, and allows Jack to remind Ellie that heâs not actually too good or too famous for her, because she knows heâs actually just the beneficiary of a deeply weird cosmic accident.
Also, thereâs a better way to resolve the romance plot. Ellie has bafflingly low self-esteem, for reasons that are never explained, so like. please explain that, movie. But since half the romance plot is just Ellie going âIâm not good enough for you!â I do have a better resolution than what the movie did.
The only Big Dramatic Gesture Jack does comes at the very end of the movie, and itâs boring and doesnât actually have anything much to do with Ellie â he already hates being famous by then, he wants out regardless. He needs a gesture thatâs actually about Ellie, and allows them to be together and in cahoots again for the rest of the Price of Fame plot.
Which, again, the movie laid the groundwork for at the beginning, and never used.
Iâd have Jack tell Ellie that he knows â is baffled by? but knows â that she thinks she ought to leave him for his own good, and that she thinks his music career is more important than her. To prove itâs not, heâs going to give her a song. A Beatles song heâs never going to record, never going to play, for anyone but her. A song that used to be one of the most famous songs in the world, but is only ever going to be theirs, hers and his, from now on.
He plays her When Iâm Sixty-Four.
That does the trick: theyâre together through the rest of the movie, and decide how to get Jack out of the Fame Trap together, and retire into happy obscurity together.
There is one other optional change, but it would require buy-in from Paul McCartney.
Thereâs already a scene in the movie â one of the best bits of the whole thing, honestly â where Jack meets an elderly John Lennon, who has never been famous and is perfectly content with his life. I think a nice epilogue would have Jack track down Paul, and find him in his back garden, planting flowers and beatifically happy.
After a short conversation in which Paul appears to have no memory of ever ever having been a Beatle, Jack leaves Paul to enjoy his retirement.
After heâs gone, as the camera pulls away and the movie ends, Paul starts to whistle When Iâm Sixty-Four to himself.