(CW: quotes explicitly promoting dehumanization, ableism, eugenics)
The thing thatās striking about that debate.org thread isnāt that theyāre saying weāre garbage or animals. Itās that, when I look at it, thereās so very little substantial difference between those comments and what Iāve heard tenured professors say in class, or in published writings.
(āPancreatic cancer will kill you in a year, tops. People with autism linger on for decades. Think about the financial ramifications.ā - paraphrased from a neuro professor)
(āThere isnāt an arguement to make. They donāt offer anything to society, they are a massive burden on their caregivers, they are incapable of supporting themselves and their very existence is unsustainable.ā - Debate.org commenter)
(āA developmental disorder that strikes at the heart of that which makes us human: our ability to love, laugh, and encounter others.ā - John Ratey.)
(āThey arenāt even alive. Ā To me a human is a person with the ability to think all that that entails.Ā A mentally retarded person cannot think and are therefore not living full lives.ā - Debate.org commenter)
(āItās as if they do not understand or are missing a core aspect of what it is to be human; to be and do like others and absorb their values. [ā¦]Ā "Their worlds are more barren, their social world is very distorted, and they come out of their world not when you want them to, but when they want to.ā - Bryna Siegel)
(āInventions like tool use, art, math and even aspects of language may have been invented āaccidentallyā in one place and then spread very quickly given the human brainās amazing capacity for imitation learning and mind reading using mirror neurons. [ā¦]Ā I suggest, also, that a loss of these mirror neurons may explain autism ā a cruel disease that afflicts children. Without these neurons the child can no longer understand or empathize with other people emotionally and therefore completely withdraws from the world socially.ā - VS Ramachandran)
(āTheir very existence is a spit in the face of the marvelous achievement and identity of the human race, to advance, innovate, and appreciate and revel at the beauty of the universe.ā - Debate.org commenter)
The difference is in the phrasings, not the substance. And what do we do with that? WhatĀ canĀ we do with that?
I donāt pretend to know. But I think itās really important to acknowledge that what weāre facing here is already a mainstream view. The only difference is the polish.