I'm having a lot of feelings about eddie diaz
I'm not normally one to really participate in fandom spaces but recently I got super into 911 to the point where i've started reading fic and logging into tumblr again, and I'm just having a lot of feelings about eddie diaz and i dont know where else to put them. so here goes...
I see a lot of conflicting things about eddie in fandom spaces, and a lot of opinions about his history and his sexuality and his relationship with shannon. I have my own opinions ofc, but I am so so so fascinated by eddie and shannon's relationship and i'm so upset that the writers fridged her. Just imagine what we could have had with their relationship. I know most of fandom is convinced eddie is gay, but as much as I love buddie, I am convinced that shannon was one of the great loves of eddie's life. (my personal opinion of eddie's sexuality is that he's demisexual/demiromantic, and has really only ever had those sorts of feelings for shannon and buck, his two best friends).
I specifically want to talk about something that I dont really see fandom addressing at all about eddie's time in the army. I've seen a lot of people hating on shannon for leaving like she did, and a lot of people hating on eddie for "running away" to the army during the early years of christopher's life. It was a shitty situation and they were having all sorts of miscommunications that exacerbated the shittyness of the situation, but bear in mind that these are two 18/19 year olds with no college education, no money, no good jobs and a baby on the way. A "normal" baby would have been hard enough, but they had a medically complex child with cp, and what i presume was a rough birth and a long hospital stay for them both, but the bills must have been astronomical. I'm also assuming from the clues we've gotten on the show that they were receiving little to no support from their parents, and in fact, eddie's parents were being actively terrible to shannon and increasing the stress she was under.
All this to say, the only reason this little family was not drowning in medical debt and on the verge of poverty is because of the military benefits and health insurance that eddie was getting, and that his family was covered by. They should have communicated better, and supported each other more, but they were two young adults doing the best they could, each fighting their own wars (shannon was a de facto single mom for a child with cp with evil in laws, eddie was in afghanistan). It makes sense with all these stressors that their relationship imploded when eddie got discharged, especially if shannon's mom's cancer and eddie's injuries and ptsd were more stressors to add to the pile.
But eddie having army benefits and training made it so he could get a firefighter/paramedic job, and enough savings to hire carla and get christopher into that fancy private school that accommodates his needs. So its was a difficult set of circumstances that they had to navigate, but I don't know what they could have done differently and still had the amount of financial security that they did. Its the tragedy of america that they make healthcare so inaccessible that desperate young people with no other option join the military for benefits, especially people of color, but there you have it.
However, I think if shannon hadn't died, they could have had a chance to make it. maybe they would divorce, maybe they would get back together, but I think they would have been friends/lovers who coparented well together and loved each other as family regardless of if they were together or not. They both love christopher so much, and they were both doing their best and they could have had it all. (im crying now)
Adding buck to this dynamic would also be delicious, he's the same age as them but with such a different life experience that he could have taught them to enjoy life again, while they taught him to settle down and be responsible (also throuple???) I love buddie and i want them to be together but the what-if of eddieshannon makes me actually sob. eddie's life is a tragedy and that he's found so much joy and meaning despite everything he's gone through at such a young age is a credit to him. also the showwriters should treat him better. also he's really pretty, his ass is perfect and his big brown eyes are devastating.


















