āNew York, New York, Scorseseās splashy, cynical, and masterfully-made postwar musical, was egregiously cold-shouldered upon its release, as was the singular star turn of Liza Minnelli, doing an adoring yet galvanizing variation on Mama Judy Garland's legendary A Star is Born role. As Francine Evans, an aspiring 1940s singer who falls under the influence of De Niroās callous, captivating saxophonist, Minnelli is perpetually in motion, propelled by an insatiable need to please audiences and lovers alike. Minnelli is, of course, a stupendous, show-stopping singer-dancer with a walloping and finely honed talent that decidedly belongs to the bygone studio era in which her mother rose to otherworldly stardom. Minnelliās artistic mastery is startlingly reminiscent of Garlandās yet differentiated by the pure, jubilant passion she exudes at all times when performing; has any artist ever radiated more graciousness for an audienceās gaze than Minnelli, as if the enormity of her abilities didnāt already demand our undivided attention? But, more than anything else, itās the actressā tough-minded, deeply-felt emotionalityāculminating in an elevator descent of tremulous, heartbroken stillnessāthat proudly places her Francine beside Garlandās Vicki Lester, Julie Andrews' Maria von Trapp, Barbra Streisandās Fanny Brice, and Minnelli's own Sally Bowles in the eternal pantheon of preeminent, pitch-perfect musical performances.āĀ ā Matthew Eng