In the wake of Bryan and Mike doing interviews that will unfortunately be picked apart by the dumbest people you’ve ever seen, I wanted to say this:
It’s insane how we as a fandom do not trust the writers and creators of the original show to create anything beyond it, yet we DO trust things like NATLA and poorly-written fanfiction to do it instead.
Fanfiction, bad adaptations, etc. would not exist if it weren’t for the quality and lasting importance of the original series. And yet here we are saying horrendously OOC and flaccid interpretations of it are more high quality somehow because they better fit into tired tropes and predictable story beats we see in everything else. Anything in the subsequent comics, movies, shows, etc. is a “mistake” and “bad writing.” And it all comes back to Bryan and Mike, and not the dozens of other creatives that had quite a bit of a say in the original show and everything else.
There are three really important things I think the fandom needs to understand:
1 - The quality of the original ATLA and the continued franchise is because of the team of people that worked on it. Things that you both like and do not like were created by both Bryke and not by Bryke.
2 - Bryan and Mike did not hire these people to tell them “no” all the time. These people didn’t “get their ideas through despite the tyranny of the creators.” Showrunners get these people to collaborate with them and be extra opinions on hand that they can trust. That’s why many of them have stuck around in the franchise for so long.
3 - Despite both of these prior points, everything that involves Bryan and Mike’s direct input has been the most high quality releases in the franchise (i.e. not just being credited for creating the original story or exclusively as producers).
The hatred towards these two to the point of implying (or explicitly stating) fanfiction and NATLA’s superiority over them is nonsense. Your limited scope of media and childish inability to consume stories that don’t exactly follow your headcanon is clouding your judgment. Really take a look at how many “bad things” Bryan and Mike have done, and then look at what they’ve actually said and done. It’s almost like you’re writing a fanfiction about them and then subscribing to that being true as well.