Iām literally on shift as a nurse at the hospital (but also on my 15 min break #responsibleblogger) rotating a post in my head Iāve been thinking about for a while entitled āOkay But Like IS Marta From Knives Out A Good Nurse??ā And i really do hope that post finds its way out of me and onto the page, but christ the mental draft of it is so long. Maybe I can just get away with posting the conclusion: no sheās not, and yes she is, and also itās complicated in ways that have almost no real life parallels. Surely no supporting evidence necessary.
Because while there is overlap between the definition of Good Nurse vs Good Person, nursing has a professional code of conduct. Thereās patient autonomy and safety, thereās duty of care, thereās equitable and impartial treatment, etc. So the question is: by the yardstick of our profession is she upholding the standard of care?
By the professional standards of nursing, when she gives the medication without checking the label, she fails at doing a universal safety check that can have catastrophic consequences. Letās ignore the fact that the meds were maliciously switched (weāll get to that, itās a real fuckin wrench in everything). The fact is that she should have verified that she had the right medication rather than go by routine. Med error is so so easy in part because passing meds can become so routine. Especially in home health. You lose the fear of fucking up, you donāt check something bc youāve done it a hundred times before, oops something goes wrong.
Additionally, she fails to assess her patient. Harlan is not showing any signs of morphine overdose. (I also want to be clear as Iām saying all this: if I thought I had given someone 100x their morphine dose and then lost the narcan, my asshole would have fallen out so hard you would have heard a clunk when it hit the floor. I like to think I wouldnāt let the dramatic old man rope me into an elaborate coverup, but like. He was very convincing. Anywayā)
Most importantly, she does not admit her error. Every single person in healthcare will make a mistake. If you are lucky, it doesnāt cause any harm. If you arenāt lucky, you think about what you did for the rest of your life. Sometimes youāre lucky and you still think of what you did for the rest of your life. Whatās important is not keeping mistakes secret. It doesnāt help the patient harmed by the mistake to pretend there isnāt a problem or that you donāt know what the problem is. And on a larger scale, it doesnāt let the system know what happened, how the mistake happened, and what we can do to stop it. Marta doesnāt tell anyone what happened, largely in part bc Harlan is fucking wild and so hyped to die dramatically, but still for the point of nursing argument: she conceals her mistake.
And that causes about every problem in the film. Because if sheād been like āHarlan, this is insane, I am calling an ambulanceā the med switch up would have been caught because he would have been fine. So much of the situation was out of Martaās controlāliterally, malicious interference with the medication and hiding the reversal agent, like whatās she supposed to do about thatābut after the error happened, she engaged in a cover up.
And the moment in which Marta is a by the books Good Nurse is when she performs CPR and calls 911 to save someone she believes is blackmailing her and is the only person who knows Harlanās death is her fault. She is providing care to someone in need regardless of her personal situation. She is owning up to what she did to prevent further harm. In a world in which Harlan was dying from a med error, she provides the family closure regarding his traumatic suicide. Being a Good Nurse means owning up to your mistakes, even if it is too late to save the patient, because we canāt find ways to address problems we donāt know exist.
But like to get back to the murder of it all, her failure to check the medication DID prevent a catastrophic med error. Like yeah she fuckin t gave the right med! She did know it by touch! And on one hand, thatās kinda bullshit, but on the other hand, I know what dilaudid feels like when I draw it up. I know what Ativan looks like in a syringe. And to be clear I would not give anything on a purely vibes based premise, but with experience you do get a nursing sense thatās difficult to articulate. Itās knowing someone has a fever from the doorway of their room, or that someone has a GI bleed from the faint smell of their poop, or that someone is in the early stages of sepsis from a glance at their respirations, or that someoneās getting delirious from just a passing comment they make. Intuition is not a consistent safety system, and also it is an invaluable asset. Sometimes you just know something isnāt right. That cannot be the entire basis of your practice. But it helps!
Marta knew the med was right because sheād drawn it up a hundred times before. Thatās horrible safety practices, but also she was right. If sheād done the med check correctly by verifying the label on the vial, then she would have killed Harlan. So in this sense, ignoring protocol and going by pure intuition resulted in the correct decision in the context of unknown but extraordinary circumstances (Chris Evans). So like. Not sure exactly what the takeaway there is. I think mainly just murder is wrong.
And also just generally speakingāstepping back from the murder of it all once againāHarlan clearly liked her. Marta and Harlan had good therapeutic rapport, by which I mean they enjoyed each otherās company which was probably Harlanās chief need. Like medications, treatments, those are all good, but so is talking to patients like theyāre people and making them feel comfortable. I mean, she did that so good she got millions of dollars and a mansion. Girl knocked it out of the park.
So is she a Good Nurse? Iād say overall yeah. While at times throughout the movie, she is more concerned with being a Good Daughter or a Person Who Isnāt In Jail, the overall impression is a compassionate person who is normally competent at her job, tries to save others despite her personal situation, and takes responsibility for her mistakes. I think thatās why she rings true as a character who is a nurse, even if you could quibble with the exact medical details.
But like. To be clear. 1) Holy shit you should read the labels on your drugs. And 2) do not let a man with a knife throne take charge of your emergency response.
