I just got back the feedback on my thesis from my first advisor. This is what she sent me:
Thank you for sharing your thesis draft. I want to commend you on the depth of research, the richness of your narrative, and the clear contribution your work makes to Carnival scholarship. It is evident that you have invested significant effort and thought into this project.
Overall, this is an impressive and original thesis. With the suggested adjustments, it has the potential to stand as a powerful scholarly contribution.
I feel… so immensely proud.
One of the things that they kept telling me was that my subject (I did a biographical thesis on bandleader Raoul Garib) had to have contributed something unique to the field of Carnival or I had to find some area of study that had previously been unexamined.
And it was only about three quarters of the way through writing that I found what my thesis was actually about.
I found the thing that had been unexamined. And it was actually pretty big thing.
I found that the critical examination of popular mas (masquerade) in the 70’s and 80’s only centered one person: Peter Minshall. And that it failed to examine the philosophy behind all other practitioners, but their philosophy was clearly and repeatedly articulated through interviews and through the mas itself. The scholarship of carnival history has never recorded, until now, what that philosophy was. And I show that it was an approach to the art form that was just as legitimate, and deliberate, as his was.
That’s the crux of it.
I spent weeks poring through decades of old newspapers, digging up articles going back to 1975. I read every single magazine article from the Trinidad Carnival magazine that was produced pertaining to my subject. Garib was pitted against Minshall repeatedly, but by the time he stopped producing mas, the internet age was upon us and his work stayed there, in the archives. My research was an attempt to bring his accomplishments into the modern age. Because the subject is my uncle. And if I didn’t write the paper, then nobody would. And in doing so I found out something much more interesting about the way we have recorded and examined our art form and its practitioners. That is to say, that we didn’t. We have let their stories fall to the wayside and their accomplishments have died with them.
The one thing I discovered in writing this thesis is how much I love doing research. I could do that for a living. Writing the paper? Not so much lol. But I apparently did a really good job of it too, so I’m very, very pleased about that.
I wrote that thesis while I was still undergoing chemo. I had to adjust my dosage to finish it because it was taking so much out of me. But I did it. I got it done. I’m so proud of myself for persevering.
I present on Friday. I’m really excited to share my findings. I’m an expert now, on this era of Carnival history, so I’m really going to enjoy talking to people who are as interested in the subject as I am.
Rex immediately suggested I pursue a PhD after reading that feedback. I was like dude after all this, you want to stick me behind a desk again? No way. I want to be outside. Doing things. It’s time for me to live again. I’ve spent three years pursuing this degree. It’s time to put it behind me and move on. I’m nearly there.
I’m wrapping up a really significant period of my life that was very hard on me. So it makes my accomplishment that much sweeter to know that I did a really good job of it. I’m laying, here basking in the feedback.
This feels really, really good. 😊














