OK so Iâm gonna expand on this post a little bit:
Anakin Skywalker is such a Gordian knot of issues that if you want to have a genuine analysis of his character and where everything went wrong, you kind of have to address all of it:
You have to acknowledge he was a slave child until he was 9. Acknowledge that the dehumanization and lack of control left such a gigantic stain on Anakinâs psyche that he canât even go to tattooine without getting angry
You have to acknowledge that Qui-gon, who was rooting for him and willing to rush Kenobi through the trials just to teach him, who was always in his corner, died. Not only that, but that Obi-wan wasnât ready to take him on due to grieving qui-gon, but took him on anyway to honor his dead master.
You have to acknowledge that palpatine was doing his damndest to sink his teeth into Anakin since they met on Naboo. That a lot of Anakinâs behavior can be traced back to the way that palps has been trying to corrupt this kid and subjugate him, that nobody noticed becauseâŚwell, the Sith have been dead for 1000 years and obi-wan killed the last one, why would anybody suspect palpatine?
You have to acknowledge that, due to all of these factors, Anakin massacred a tusken tribe. Watching his mom die, palpatineâs grooming, hell, even a lack of understanding of the Jedi code you could say, caused him to think murder, even of innocents, was okay. Yes, the decision was made in emotional duress, but alsoâŚAnakin still had a choice. He couldâve left the Tuskens alone, keeping that grief on a leash until he could bury his mother, and then let it out in a healthy way.
But he didnât. He chose the immediate, convenient option: murder.
And then before he can properly process everything, before he can genuinely realize what he did was wrong (which he almost does at the larses), heâs thrust into saving Obi-wan, and then the war.
Part of me wonders if he ever got cognitive dissonance from leading the clones.
Part of me wonders if palpatine nipped that in the bud when he caught wind of it.
The thing is, Anakin has a hierarchy of people he cares about:
Palpatine and Padme on top, obi-wan and Ahsoka in the middle, Rex, the clones, and the Jedi third, and then the rest of the galaxy last.
This comes in clutch when he falls: he listens to palpatineâs machinations because this is the guy that he trusts, right? Palpatineâs never gonna lead him astray, right?
Anakin struggles with being a part of a group, feeling like he canât be like that with the Jedi because he wasnât raised from toddlerhood by them (at least, I believe). In the movie:
He feels that he should be put at the same position of respect as the rest of the masters, but they wonât do that because they know heâs not ready for the responsibility
Yoda (due to not having the context that Anakinâs worried Padme will die in childbirth) accidentally invalidates Anakinâs emotions by telling him that if she dies, she dies
Is told by the Jedi that he has to spy on palpatine (his friend!) because they fear heâs gathering as much power as he can (because he is)
Itâs just little chinks in the armor.
Then, palpatine swoops in and assuages Anakin that Padme can be saved: all he has to do is learn sith powers, and she can be healed!
Throughout the movie, itâs just a slow roll of isolating Anakin from people he trusts, until by the end, Palp has him desperate to be his sithly apprentice.
But again, Anakin has a choice: he couldâve killed palpatine when the man revealed himself as the sith, he couldâve not killed mace either.
Because the moment palpatine told him there was a way to save Padme, he had Anakin hook, line, and fucking sinker.
This is why attachments are bad. Theyâre not love, theyâre desperation, clawing at your feet, sinking their teeth into you and filling your head with fear and paranoia.
Anakin didnât tell yoda about his marriage because he knew Yoda would consider it an attachment, and scold him about it. He didnât tell obi-wan about the depth of his dreams in ep II because he thought that as a Jedi, the concern of his mom dying would be considered an attachment and that the Jedi wouldnât take him seriously.
But again, it was his choice to not give them the full context, because he was embarrassed that he wouldnât be considered a true Jedi.
And that embarrassment, fear, possessiveness, everything, has left its bloodstains.
I donât even know why Iâm writing this, Anakinâs not even my favorite character, itâs just.
Iâm tired of seeing fics where people boil him down to just âannoying idiot that everyone in his immediate vicinity tolerates because something something obi wan something something chosen oneâ
(And I have my problems with how fandom treats obi-wan so if you wanna hear them, lemme know)
Iâm tired of people using the fact that heâs doomed to become darth Vader to just write him off and and do nothing of interest with.
Let him be happy! Let Cody or Rex or the Jedi or bail or whoever be genuinely interested in what he has to say!!! Let him be an interesting character and have him play with the other interesting characters!!!
But also let him be messy!!!!!