Man, I can not wait until Mark does his explanation stream for Iron Lung because way too many of you have made a LOT of assumptions about the lore then go on to state it as fact in character analysis.
For the record:
It is intentionally ambiguous whether Simon ACTUALLY had anything to do with Filament Station blowing up. He says all the blame was pinned on him because he was one of the only survivors and we have no reason to not believe him.
We have no evidence that proves Simon had any connection to any deaths prior to Filament Station. The body count mentioned could have ALL come from Filament Station as it was a battle that spanned 9 days.
Based on the flashbacks we get Simon was telling the truth about not intending for what happened at Filament station. We see him stand there getting yelled at when the initial explosion happens. If he intentionally blew up Filament Station why would he just be standing around waiting for it to happen?
For all we know he was told they were going to the station for resources as a soldier. This is something that had been going on between Eden and the COI for a while. If true, we have no idea if Simon even had a choice whether to be a soldier or not. (Remember, he says Eden tattooed him against his will)
Eden had all the reason in the world to believe that the COI was coming for them the same way they colonized and took over all the other existing space stations.
Simon does not seem to believe in Edenās religious fanaticism however he does have some behaviors and comforts that come from having been raised in that culture. Based on the symbolism and what Simon says about Eden, he has a complex relationship with them.
If there is content outside of the game and movie that youāve seen that contradicts any of this then let me know. Maybe iāve missed something from the film, but I havenāt seen anyone bring up any scenes or dialogue that contradicts this. Again, if you have evidence to the contrary please share it.













