Poor First Impressions || Caleb Widogast ||
A/n: I love him, this man needs so much love.
The first time the Mighty Nein encountered you, it was, in Fjord’s professional opinion, an absolute disaster.
They had been traveling through a stretch of dense woodland, the kind where the canopy grew so thick it swallowed most of the light, leaving everything in a muted green haze and the air was quiet, too quiet and that alone had Beau on edge, her eyes scanning constantly, shoulders tight.
“I don’t like this,” she muttered. “Feels like something’s watching us.”
“It’s a forest,” Nott whispered dramatically. “Everything’s watching us.”
Caleb said nothing, but he slowed his pace slightly, gaze drifting upward. He felt it too of course, it would be impossible not too. It was a dangerous presence but something else, something he couldn't place his finger on but then he felt something above them that made the hair on his neck stand up.
“…halt,” he said quietly.
Fjord stopped immediately. Yasha turned. Jester nearly walked into Beau.
“What?” Jester whispered, already excited.
Caleb lifted a hand slightly, eyes narrowing as he looked into the trees. "There is something—”
A shape moved, it was subtle, almost invisible in the tangle of branches and leaves but once you saw it, you couldn’t unsee it.
Nott’s voice came out as a horrified squeak. “Oh no.”
Beau squinted. “Is that—”
“It is a spider,” Caleb confirmed.
It was in fact a spider….A very large spider.
Perched above them, legs stretched across multiple branches, body blending almost perfectly into the shadows. It hadn’t moved yet, it just sat their in silence.
Which somehow made it worse.
Jester leaned forward, fascinated. “Oh wow, it’s kinda pretty—”
“No,” Fjord said immediately. “No, it is not.”
Caleb took a slow step forward, cautious but curious, eyes fixed on the creature.
“…it has not attacked,” he murmured. “Perhaps it is not—”
He shifted his weight and then a twig snapped under his boot.The sound echoed louder than it should have.
Everything happened at once.
The massive shape above them flinched not lunging, not striking….more like startled, terrified.
And then the spider shifted as it fell out of the tree, the transformation was sudden, chaotic as limbs twisted, the form collapsing in on itself before expanding again and suddenly there was a bear.
A very large bear, dropping directly out of the tree.
“…NEIN—” Caleb managed before the bear landed directly on Caleb.
There was a solid, earth-shaking WHUMP as several hundred pounds of fur, muscle, and panic crashed directly into him, knocking the breath completely out of his lungs.
Caleb hit the ground flat on his back, all air leaving him in one violent exhale.
The world went white for a second and above him the bear froze, for one long, horrified heartbeat and then you screamed
A full, high-pitched, panicked scream that echoed through the trees like you had just realized what you had done.
Caleb stared up at you, dazed, blinking.“…ich—”
You scrambled off him instantly, shifting mid-motion, fur receding, form shrinking, limbs reshaping until suddenly their was a human on him.
You were a human, standing in front wide eyed. Disheveled and completely mortified.
“Oh my gods—!” you gasped, hands hovering like you didn’t know where to put them. “I’m so sorry…I didn’t....I thought you were—!”
You made a helpless, flustered gesture at… everything, pannicking as Caleb tried to sit up.
Failed as the air still hadn’t returned to his lungs.
Jester clapped her hands in delight. “SHE WAS A SPIDER!”
Beau stared. “She was as bear and nearly crushed him.”
Nott wheezed. “She turned into a bear on him.”
Fjord pinched the bridge of his nose. “Of course she did.”
Yasha just watched you, calm but attentive, clearly assessing whether you were a threat.
You looked down at Caleb.
Your face went even more horrified.
“I’m so sorry…! I didn’t mean to…I just.I got scared and then I panicked and then—!”
Then another.Then…“—I’m sorry!”
And you ran.Just… turned and bolted straight into the forest.
Leaves rustled faintly where you had disappeared. The Nein stood there still processing what just happened as the leaves slowly fell.
Beau crossed her arms. “Well.”
Nott burst into laughter. “That was incredible.”
Jester bounced on her heels. “I LOVE HER.”
Fjord exhaled slowly. “We got attacked by a spider that turned into a bear that turned into a woman who apologized and ran away.”
Yasha nodded once. “She seemed nice.”
On the ground, Caleb finally managed to suck in a full breath, everything hurt.He pushed himself up slightly, one hand braced against the earth, still staring in the direction you had fled, expression somewhere between stunned and deeply confused.
“…what,” he said hoarsely, “just happened....."
No one answered him of course, because none of them knew how to even answer.
But somewhere deep in the forest you were still running and whether Caleb realized it yet or not that would not be the last time you quite literally knocked him off his feet.
The second time the Mighty Nein encountered you, they were ready.
Or at least, Fjord said they were ready.
They moved more carefully through the forest now, eyes constantly scanning the trees, the underbrush, anything that might suddenly turn into a spider, or a bear, or a woman who apologized and fled like a startled deer.
“Alright,” Fjord said quietly, voice low as they walked. “If we see her again, nobody startles her.”
Beau snorted. “Nobody startles her? She dropped a bear on him for stepping on a twig.”
“That was not intentional,” Caleb muttered, still faintly bruised in both body and dignity. "She also did not drop a bear on me…she was the bear." He muttered as if that made the situation better.
Nott grinned. “I dunno, you looked pretty intentional when you hit the ground.”
Jester clasped her hands. “I hope we see her again! She was so cute!”
“She punched the wizard with a bear,” Beau said.
“She was the bear and she said sorry!” Jester countered.
Yasha said nothing, but her gaze drifted ahead, sharp and observant. “She is here,” she said quietly.
You stood in a small clearing ahead, back turned to them, crouched near a cluster of plants. You seemed… calm this time. Focused. Gently brushing dirt from the roots of something you’d gathered humming softly as your body swayed.
Jester gasped immediately, grabbing Beau’s arm about to approach. “It’s her!! it’s spider-bear girl!”
“Don’t,” Fjord hissed, grabbing her sleeve.
Nott snorted. “The one who flattened Caleb.”
“Let me handle this,” Caleb said softly.
Every head turned to look at him.Beau raised a brow. “You?”
Caleb straightened slightly, brushing off his coat as if that alone might restore some dignity from the last encounter.
“I startled her before,” he said, quieter now, more thoughtful. “If I approach calmly… slowly… she will not feel threatened.”
Nott leaned toward Beau. “This is going to go so badly.”
“Yeah,” Beau murmured. “I’m not stopping him.”
Yasha gave him a small, supportive nod as Jester leaned in, whispering loudly, “Don’t get sat on again!”
Caleb ignored them as he took a breath as he began to walk forward.
Carefully placing each step, avoiding twigs, keeping his movements controlled, deliberate. His eyes stayed on you, studying your posture, your stillness.
He got closer.And closer and he was just a few steps behind you now now.
He hesitated and very gently as he reached out placing a hand on your shoulder. Then that's when everything went wrong.
You exploded into motion.A sharp inhale, a startled gasped as you spun around so fast it blurred, your fist coming up on pure instinct.
Your knuckles connected solidly with Caleb’s face, his head snapped back.There was a stunned pause as Caleb dropped.
Their was Silence.Utter, absolute silence as you froze.Eyes wide.Hand still half-raised.
“Oh my—” You looked down at him, then up and saw the rest of the Nein staring at you from the edge of the clearing.
Beau’s mouth was already open.“…no way.”
Nott looked like she was about to ascend from pure joy, as she wheezed, clutching her stomach. “TWICE. You got him TWICE.”
Jester had both hands over her face, vibrating.“Oh my god!!!! YOU PUNCHED HIM—!”
Fjord dragged a hand down his face so slowly it looked painful. “We had a plan.”
You looked back at Caleb who was still unconscious.
“Oh my gods….I did it again—!”
You took a step back, horrified, hands flying up to your face.
“I’m so sorry….I didn’t…I didn’t mean to…he just….he touched me and I—!”
You made a helpless, frantic gesture, like you were trying to explain the entire situation at once and failing miserably.
Jester immediately stepped forward, delighted. “Hi! You’re back! That was amazing—!”
“Jester, no,” Fjord said, not even opening his eyes.
You squeaked, full panic mode activated. “I didn’t mean to hit him...I swear. I just got scared and—!” You backed up another step.
Beau pointed at you. “Don’t you dare—”
You then took another step back, followed by another as you held your hand to your chest. “I’m sorry!” And then your ran away, again! Gone into the trees before anyone could even try to stop you.
Another long silence fell over the clearing as Nott nodded enthusiastically. “She’s my favorite person.”
Beau dragged a hand down her face, grinning despite herself. “That’s gotta be some kind of record.”
Jester bounced in place. “I love her so much.”
Fjord finally opened his eyes, looking down at Caleb’s unconscious form with a deeply tired expression. “We need to stop letting him approach her.”
Yasha stepped forward, kneeling beside Caleb again, checking him with practiced calm. “He’ll wake up.”
Caduceus, who had been quietly observing, tilted his head slightly. “She is very apologetic for someone who keeps knocking him unconscious.”
“Yeah,” Beau said. “It’s kind of her thing now.”
On the ground, Caleb groaned faintly, stirring, his hand lifted weakly toward his face. “…this,” he mumbled hoarsely, “is becoming a pattern…why does she not like me."
Jester crouched beside him immediately, grinning. “Noooo, she just gets nervous and commits violence.”
Nott snickered. “You’re her favorite.”
Yasha helped him sit up, steady and patient, while he winced, pressing his fingers carefully to his jaw.
“…I think,” Caleb said slowly, voice strained, “we must try a different approach.”
Behind him, Jester bounced on her heels. “Next time we should wave! Or bring snacks! Or both!”
Nott perked up. “Ooh….yes, snacks!”
Fjord sighed. “We are not luring her like a stray animal.”
Beau shrugged. “I mean… it might work
Behind him, the others erupted into laughter. And somewhere, deeper in the forest, you were once again running for your life, completely unaware that you had just become the single most dangerous recurring event in Caleb Widogast’s existence.