Commission Artist Scam PSA: Some Advise on How to Spot Scammers
I kept wondering what the point of these blatant scams was, who would fall for them, and my wonderful best friend recently suggested that it would be easier for (young) writers who never received (fan)art for their fics to be tempted by this.
So in light of these scams getting more and more insidious and less obvious to spot, I thought I'd put together a little PSA.
Since the beginning, they all followed the same scheme, which they still do even if it has grown more elaborate:
they will comment on your fic, often including that they "recently" came across it/read it and really liked it
they will claim that they had "an idea" inspired by the fic that they would like to share with you
if this happens on AO3, they are likely going to try and lure you to a third party site such as instagram, tumblr or Discord to keep talking
they'll tell you that they are a "commission artist"
The scam started out very cut and dry, practically all of these were near word for word identical messages in the vein of "I recently came across your fic [title] and I really liked it! I have an idea that I'd like to share with you. I'm a commission artist, contact me on tumblr/Discord(/instagram to talk more!". They were so identical that it was obvious enough that this was spam already.
They've gotten more elaborate in recent weeks. The very first comment may even completely read like a normal comment. Complimenting the story, often times even asking questions about the plot.
And then you reply. And they reply to you and fall into the above mentioned pattern of trying to reel you in. This is so much more frustrating than the original scam, because you got excited about the comment, especially one that engages with the fic, but then it devolved into another scam attempt and you didn't even see it coming at first.
So, especially for younger, less experienced authors, here is a big piece of advise:
Fandom is an exchange of love. Your work matters. Your work is worth something. Someone else coming into your story and trying to capitalize on it for themselves - claiming they had an idea inspired by your story, but they want money from you? That's not love, that's capitalism.
Real actual artists who feel inspired by your work will create whatever they felt inspired to draw. They will share that love, specifically with you as the one who inspired them.
Also, this is not how commissions work.
A commission artist is an artist you approach with an idea that you would like to see in their style and then you pay them to create that work. Commission artists don't go around to individual people going "Hey, I would like to create this piece of art and you should pay me for it!", that's not how this works. No real commission artist would do this.
Real commission artists also have commission ref sheets that include their pricing and what kind of art they offer, including examples of what they offer with the corresponding prices (head shot, bust, full body, multiple characters, + background, flat vs with shading, etc).
Real commission artists are transparent with what you can expect and with what you would have to pay. They also usually have a blog full of their art that you can browse and see for yourself.
If someone reaches out to you and wants you to pay them to draw but their blog is entirely empty with not a single art piece in sight? That's a red flag.
Not all of these blogs are empty though. Because the main crux of this scam is that these scammers are trying to make you pay for AI slop.
It's getting increasingly hard to spot AI generated images because the generating is getting more and more fine tuned. I'm not good at spotting it and I'm also often reluctant to even try because I wouldn't want to insult a real artist by making wrongful assumptions. After all, AI is trained on real art.
But here is one surefire way to spot if that artist who reached out to you and who does have images on their blog is a blatant scam: If every single image is in a different style, it is more likely that this is AI slop and not the most versatile and talented artist on tumblr. Sure, many artists are dabbling in different styles, but if you have a photorealistic portrait followed by anime art, followed by video game illustration style with intensely detailed backgrounds, no two art-pieces looking remotely similar? Then this was made with AI, I'm afraid.
Here's the TL;DR, or the quick summary reminder of what to watch out for:
if they're trying to lure you to a different site
if they're trying to make you pay for an idea they had
if they claim to be a commission artist but have no commission ref sheet
if they claim to be an artist but have no art on their blog
if they have art but it's all in vastly different styles/none look like they come from the same person [or if you are good at spotting AI and can tell on first glance already]
And remember: Your contribution to fandom is valuable too, real fanartists know this and will cherish that, instead of valuing their own time and creations higher than yours! Real fanartists will not try to make you pay for the art they want to create inspired by your work - real fanartists will simply create that art!
I do wish all authors who encounter this scam that they'll get to experience the joy of having a fellow fan create fanart for their work. And if you do want your fics illustrated and want to reach out to a real commission artist, I hope that this post helps you at least some to tell the difference who to trust and who to block.




















