Pass the Butterfly
Okay, so Iâve been looking through a lot of Tumblr kwami swap auâs lately. Including some really interesting ones where either Marinette or Adrien wields the butterfly miraculous. Sometimes as heroes, sometimes as villains, sometimes somewhere in between. In one au called âmetamorphosis/aftermathâ, Adrien finds the butterfly after his father was arrested and his motives are evenly split between giving the heroes a reason to stick around, and recreating some of the positive side effects of akumas (when people pay attention to WHY someone was akumatized and try to fix it).
So now Iâm thinking, âYou know who could be a fun character to play with that motivation?
Alya.â
Exactly how that characterization works comes down to 2 options.
1- Much like the metamorphosis au, Alya finds the butterfly brooch after Gabriel is defeated. This version of her was never Rena Rouge and never learned Ladybugâs identity. Unlike Adrien, Alya finds the brooch by snooping around the final battle, rather than Gabriel specifically leaving it for her. This Alya never fully gave up on trying to uncover the heroesâ identities. And as sheâs talking to Nooroo and bemoaning the assumed* loss of the heroes with Hawkmoth gone, she also starts thinking about all the people who were only able to be heard and get a wrong righted because being akumatized made people pay attention.
I feel like Alya would be totally down for breaking a few rules to get the scoop, especially if itâs calling out an injustice.
And outside of the mind control aspect creating new trauma; getting superpowers to play with and an outlet for your frustration knowing that Ladybug will reverse the damage and that you wonât be held accountable? Would be incredibly therapeutic if it werenât for the aforementioned mind control. But I digress.
Basically, by the time the heroes are 2 weeks into their well deserved hiatus, Alya has already talked herself into the idea that Justified Akumas + Keeping the Heroes Around = Good Journalism.
*They probably wouldnât actually disappear without akumas. But Adrien probably needed a couple weeks off because Iâm pretending he was included in the final battle and just found out his father was Hawkmoth. And Marinette was busy rebuilding the miraculous for at least as long. So from Parisâ perspective, they defeated Hawkmoth and decided they were no longer needed.
2- Alya is the original butterfly villain. I have no clue where the heck she would get it from in this au. (Gabriel and Emilie would still need the peacock, unless you just want to pretend Adrien, Felix, and Kagami weâre all born the normal way, in which case do as you please with the peacock.) But she was trying to use it to create superheroes because she LOVES superheroes.
Bad News: Her attempt to turn a bullying victim into a heroic Champion accidentally created an akumatized villain instead.
Good News: Her villain drew out some Actual Superheroes đ¤Š!!! This is the best day of her life!!!
By the time she masters Kamiko vs Akuma, she and her butterflies already have a reputation and she figures she might as well work with it.
As a side note: Where did Alya move from? She was new in âOriginsâ, so maybe that could inform any theories on where she got her brooch from?
Either of these routes, Alya is still boots-on-the-ground chasing and recording the super fights while managing the akuma. Either she adopts a purple sweatshirt to wear all the time and makes her transformation look like that so no one realizes that sheâs changed; or she pulls a âCollectorâ and releases her transformation after creating the akuma.












