I don't know; I think we need to think about how we talk about practicality re: historical women's clothing
because one of the most common criticisms leveled at almost any mainstream western style for women pre-1920s is "it was impractical!!!!"
and like. okay. impractical for what though?
sure you can't like. I don't know. wrangle an escaped farm animal back into its pen in full Natural Form. but most women weren't doing that, any more than most of us are now, and the ones who were....wore Work Clothing during livestock-wrangling hours
had someone tell me the other day that you couldn't work a 9-5 job in Second Bustle dresses
you could go to the office in this. you could send memos to Janice in accounting in this. you could work many types of non-food retail in this. you could do several different types of museum jobs in this. you could be a dressmaker, miliner, seamstress, or lady journalist in this, at the time. you could be a doctor in this, although nowadays we know you shouldn't.
what do you MEAN you can't work a 9-5 in this? there are so so so many jobs, modern and otherwise, that could be done in exactly this outfit
I make most of my own clothing from patterns that usually date to like 1869 or 1879-82. long skirts and corsets and the whole shebang (well, okay, I do corset sometimes and bra sometimes, but I digress). my average day is walking to the train, taking the train to work, either sitting at a desk or walking around a museum for several hours, running errands, taking the train back, and walking home
dressing like a Victorian vampire countess is no impediment to my daily life whatsoever. and I average 2 miles of walking per day, so I'm MORE active than most of my fellow USAmericans on a daily basis
on the flipside. can you do aforementioned livestock-wrangling in modern fashion jeans? in trendy oversized tops? is the Clean Girl Aesthetic 100% practical and possible to maintain in all situations that could possibly arise?
what's that? it doesn't matter because you don't have to do those things in your clothing and you'd wear different clothing if you did?
OH WOW. WHO WOULD HAVE EVER CONSIDERED. SUCH AN IDEA.
surely not our Dumb-Dumb Stupid Brainless Ancestors, But Only the Women, Who Were Complete Idiots With No Concept Of Situational Clothing Adaptations
I need a drink
The Closet Historian rants a little bit about this in her sleeve drafting video - about how she gets a lot of comments about how the fancy things she's sewing don't have a huge range of motion, and yeah it's true they don't, but if she's just going to wear them to dinner or an art museum then why does it matter if she can't do gymnastics in them?
(Also I have had people say similar things about 18th century menswear, though to a much lesser extent. The first one that comes to mind is my mother going "ooh of course you'd need servants to do everything for you" in reference to my big puffy shirt sleeves. Which is very demonstrably nonsense as there are tons of depictions of people with big shirt or shift sleeves doing work, and everyone would be wearing them including servants because they were just normal underwear. And some people will just assume that anyone wearing any silk at all must be super rich and couldn't possibly have any work to do. because every historical job ever including the indoor ones must involve large amounts of dirt? I guess?)
We also forget that there are skills associated with wearing clothing.
If you watch older movies / TV, you see a lot of men wearing suits who unbutton their suit coat when they sit down and rebutton it when they stand up. Most of them do it without appearing to notice. As someone who never wears a suit coat, I don't know if I would think to do this. Does that make suits impractical?
As someone who wears long-sleeved shirts in winter, I automatically shove my sleeves up to do wet or messy tasks with my hands and pull them back down afterward. Would someone who never wears long-sleeved shirts think to do that? Would the resulting wet / grubby hems show that long-sleeved shirts are impractical?
Someone who is used to wearing a long skirt will treat it differently when going up stairs, either by lifting the front hem or by moving their legs around differently on each step. I know that this is a learned skill because I remember learning it as a child. Does an inexperienced wearer tripping on their hem mean that skirts are impractical?
It is awkward to put on or remove a winter coat while wearing mittens. Most people who wear these things regularly handle them in the right order without thinking. Does someone getting stuck in their sleeves mean winter clothing is impractical?
The average modern person would have trouble moving through life in a corset and layers of petticoats because we haven't developed the necessary skills, not because the clothes are inherently impossible to move in.


























