I’ve seen a lot of people saying that if you’re not that sexuality you shouldn’t write characters or stories around such things since it’s objectifying.
And as someone who is currently writing a book where the two main characters and the main relationship is gay I’m a lil scared.
I’m don’t identify as gay or a man, I identify as AroAce Agender. I was wondering if anyone has any opinions on this? I’ll probably write the story anyways (worst case I’ll keep it to myself), but I would like to know of other peoples opinions on this.
(They don’t fuck btw, the romantic relationship between them is PG as they are both Asexual and the romance is quite short)
Listen. You can write whatever you want. Forever. You could write them fucking nasty on every page of you wanted. You could write them doing kink. You could write them making out in a coffee shop.
The argument that if you are not X sexuality you can’t or shouldn’t write characters who are that sexuality is the same bullshit argument that people use to say if you’re not a POC you shouldn’t write characters that are POC or that people of one gender can’t write characters of another gender. That ‘advice’ is small minded and inherently broken because it assumes that if you don’t have X characteristic, then you can’t possibly understand people with that characteristic. It’s othering.
That’s not to say that writers don’t have a responsibility when writing characters with characteristics they don’t have. Do your research. Talk to people with those characteristics and learn about them. Ask someone from that group to read your work and point out issues. Really interrogate your work to find if you’re including any unconscious biases. Make sure you know the difference between a character flaw and a stereotype.
Writers are always writing characters who don’t share characteristics they have. If they didn’t, most of fiction couldn’t exist. Writing is how we explore the world, our community, and ourselves, and how we invite others to share in that exploration. One of my favorite pieces of my own writing is a short little story about a first date between a bisexual man and a man who is only just coming to realize he may also be bisexual. I’m an ace woman who has had a single kiss with another woman. Just because I didn’t share the characteristics of being male or identifying as bisexual didn’t mean I couldn’t relate to how my characters were feeling or how they would react to each other. I could use my own experiences trying to identify myself and translate them for my characters.
People are people, no matter what characteristics they have. The idea that a characteristic like sexuality, gender, or race would disqualify you from being able to write a person with a differing characteristic is fundamentally based on the (incorrect!) assumption that those characteristics are enough to make one person entirely alien to another, and that’s the road to fascism, baby!
There’s always going to be someone who has a problem with your writing. Always. That is the nature of art. You’ll never sand away all the corners that could poke someone; you’d just end up with a pile of dust. It’s not your responsibility to make sure you don’t offend anyone; that’s literally impossible. But if you’re treating the group you’re characterizing respectfully, doing research, avoiding harmful stereotypes, and writing with creativity and compassion… you’ll be fine.















