Friends, gather round, and let me tell you a story.
It begins, as many stories do, with a spindle.
This spindle was full of an exquisite cop of lovingly spun singles, all ready to be plied. And thus, we come to the plying ball.
A first ball was wound, from the spindle onto the ball winder. There are no pictures of this stage of the story, as I naively believed at the time that all was well. Spoilers: all was not well.
As this singles was to become a two ply, the next step was to wind a second ball from both ends. Doing this step on the ball winder rather than on the spindle as I was plying was one of the few good decisions I made in this endeavor. See, I had had some issues with tangling before, and found that they were easier to sort out if I was not also juggling a spindle at the time. I was confident that I had determined the source of the tangles, though. Clearly, the end of the center pull was somehow slipping under some of the other wraps before I pulled it out. So I very carefully extracted it, making sure there was no way it could have gotten caught anywhere, and merrily began winding the second ball.
For a brief period, all was well with the world. And then- disaster. A loop had caught around the center pull end and was beginning to tangle. Now, I had seen this problem before. I had learned this lesson. Left alone, it would only make itself worse. Immediate action must be taken.
I didn't want to break the singles, so I unwound all the way back to the beginning so I could pass the end through. Pleased with myself for having averted disaster, I continued on.
Disaster, however, was not on board with being averted. There was not one loop intent on catching, but many, and in short order they had made themselves known. In a moment of hubris, I told myself that it would be okay; surely, if I were careful, I could just work through it and eventually the loops themselves would be wound on.
I interject, my friends, to provide you with an important detail not yet mentioned. You see, the ball winder being used for this endeavor, being not the highest of quality, had a tendency to, on occasion, misplace a loop. Rather than resting in its proper place around the outside of the growing ball, a loop would slip off the top or bottom to start a new layer close to the center shaft. I thought nothing of this at the time- a minor cosmetic anomaly, surely, that would have no bearing on the function of the center pull ball. The singles was still following more or less the same path, and a small slip here or there would not cause anything to cross over such that a knot could be formed. I believed the occurences safe to ignore, and not worth the time to unwind and correct. Ah, how wrong I was.
Now, let us return to our tale.
Too much was wound at this point for going back to the beginning to be a reasonable option. The sensible approach, at this point, would have been to break a singles, carefully remove it from the snarl, and reattach it once everything was in order. However, I could not bear to do so. The join would be so inelegant! Think of all the twist I could lose! I resolved, thus, to deal with the small tangle the natural way; I am, of course, quite practiced at recovering yarn barf. Surely I could manage.
This was my next mistake.
As I toiled, various strands began to work themselves together. Eventually, of course, two strands managed to become so entwined that in trying to separate them I broke the singles anyway. And again, and again, such that I ended up with more breaks than I would have had I chosen that path from the start. But at long last, both ends of the plying ball were free and moving smoothly.
Those pieces that were totally detached, I put back on the spindle to try to restore some of the twist that must have escaped in all this breaking and threading and finagling. This also gave me ample time to lament the state of my now horribly nappy and inconsistent singles, a sad fate after their previous incarnation as beautifully smooth and even.
Those pieces were then reattached in their place in the plying ball. Once I could no longer use the spindle to facilitate the joins, I accomplished them by finger twisting each piece about six inches back from the end to build up as much excess twist as I could. I then laid the ends over one another, spit felted them a bit for extra security, then pulled the area taught to allow the extra twist to travel into the join. The areas I joined like this, despite my worries, were fairly inconspicuous.
The areas that got pulled to and fro by my attempts at untangling, however, were not.
Once everything was reattached, the winding could continue. That is not, however, the end of the story. You see, with all the poking and prodding and pulling that happened while I was still in denial about the necessary course of action, several internal loops pulled themselves free to create their own tangle, technically separate from the working ends but still eager to get in the way.
There had, of course, also been loops that slipped off the bottom during the first winding, and those had just as much potential for snags and tangles as the ones at the top. With nothing near them to catch, on, though, they managed to keep themselves mostly behaved with no intervention on my part.
Hoping that if I could keep the clump on top somewhat contained I might be able to proceed with the winding only mildly inconvenienced, I went in search of something to use as a tangle management system. I settled on squeezing all of the errant threads into a binder clip.
This was largely successful. It was also at this time that I discovered that if I unwound the outside end of the plying ball off the bottom rather than the top, it would have fewer opportunities to catch on the unruly protrusion at that end. This kept things manageable enough for the center end to slip through unimpeded despite the loops around it. I continued in this manner - slowly, but at long last making actual progress - until the trail of the outside singles led me straight into the binder clip.
Thus began the next of many rounds of untangling interspersed with sections of winding, thankfully with slightly less to worry about each time through. The first time the tangle was still severe enough that I was once again obligated to break the singles; though this time, having learned my lesson, I did so without hesitation.
On subsequent trips through the tangled mass, I was able to separate out the individual loops sufficiently to free the end without needing to resort to breaking it.
This is not to say that the journey was now easy. I had to be very careful not to let the ball itself rotate, or the bundle of tangles hanging off the top, while nicely contained in their binder clip, would wrap itself around the center pull and trap it. I also had to be sure that every coil of the outside end came off the bottom, and none snuck up over the top to cinch around center pull and tangle bundle together.
It made for slow going, working carefully to avoid these problems, and stopping to correct them when they inevitably happened anyway, but at least I was finally going. The bundle of loose loops grew smaller and smaller until at last, there was only one left.
This one of course was so happy with the way it had plied on itself that when I tried to straighten it out it snapped on me one last time. But eventually, all was once again (mostly) well. A plying ball was at last obtained. A plying ball with sections of singles that were not quite as nice as they had once been, but a plying ball none the less.
This plying ball performed its job admirably. There were no more issues with tangling as it moved from ball back to spindle to add the final twist, and the end result, after far more hours than I'd wanted to spend, was a beautiful(if you ignore the parts that got abraded in the untangling) skein of yarn.
And so, at last, our story comes to a (mostly) happy ending, with many lessons learned.
Lessons learned:
- Be careful when winding the first ball. If any loops slip up off the top, go back and fix them. I don't care how far back they were, go back and fix them.
- If a tangle does start, unless it's close enough to the beginning that it's worth it to unwind the whole thing to pull it through, just break the single. I know that hurts, but one small join will be less apparent in the final yarn than a giant section that's gone super nappy, and the quicker you catch and deal with it the less yarn will get a chance to get caught in the tangle.
- It's slower, but if there's any hint of a tangle up top, pull the outside end off the bottom of the plying ball. The center end can make it through a small bit of trouble, but the outside end will catch on any irregularity and quickly make a tangle significantly worse.
- Some amount of tangle and looping at the top can be dealt with if it's held enough out of the way. I sincerely hope I never have the opportunity to test this, but should I end up in a similar situation again, I'd like to try something like bobby pins to hold nascent free loops out of the way until the winding end reaches them. It's possible that if done quickly and neatly enough that could eliminate the need to break the singles.
- Be careful when winding the first ball.
- No really, be careful when winding the first ball.