Charlie and his daughter.
"But papa, if I let them out they won't ever come back and if they never come back I won't be able to tell them I love them." Tears were pouring down her face as she sat in the middle of their yard clutching a jar of butterflies desperately.
Charlie sighed and sat in the warm grass next to her, wiping her tears with his thumb. At first he wasn't sure what to say, she was five now and had an uncanny ability to turn most conversations into a merry-go-round of illogical arguments which almost always left him questioning everything. This time he decided on a different approach.
"Oh, well, I suppose if that is how you show love for something then they will have to remain in the jar then." He said passively, praying to Merlin she wasn't on to him. He picked a long, wide blade of grass, put it between his thumbs, pressed it to his lips and pushed his breath through, making a low whistling sound.
"I will feed them and I will love them forever, I promise." She said, wiping her wet cheeks with her arm.
"I know you will, you have the biggest heart of anyone I know, but butterflies don't live forever do they? How will you love them after they've gone?" He leaned forward and picked a small dandelion, the white remnants of its maturity dancing with the air.
"Oh, um, well, I think I would maybe love them how we love Uncle Fred." She had the jar lifted and peered inward, watching the iridescent wings flutter.
Charlie's heart ached terribly at her answer while at the same time wincing from how painfully excellent of an answer that was. He watched her think intently at the glass comfine and found himself wondering what she was thinking.
"We do those things to remember him because we don't have him here with us, but the butterflies, they are here and need to be loved in a different way." He scooted ever so slightly towards her and watched the creatures with her , letting himself be part of the moment.
"My absolute dearest one, if we hold on to things out of fear of losing them, then we could lose a little bit of ourselves instead, and that's no good is it?" He placed his hands over hers and lowered the jar, she gazed at him with welling eyes.
"Would they be unhappy?" She finally asked.
"Yes," said Charlie "I would think very. Look at the space around us, the space they are meant to occupy, and then think how strange it may be to suddenly occupy the space of a pickling jar. I don't think you would ever truly want to be the reason another living being felt that way." He gazed at her and took in her off-kilter mess of curls atop her head and the wildly intense look on her face; if she thought any harder she might burst.
"It's like this dandelion" He said, holding it up and twirling its stem between his fingers, "I love these flowers, and I would very much like to keep this and hold onto it. But if I did that then all of these little bits would never have a chance to be taken by the wind to create more dandelions."
Charlie breathed deep and blew onto the flower, sending its tendrils off to be lifted by the breeze. They spun effortlessly in the air as they were led to their new path on the wind.
He heard a small sniffle and looked down to see her slowly unscrewing the lid to the jar; he smiled brilliantly, hiding it as best he could. He could hear her mutterings to the creatures.
"I love you all and I know it hurts me to let you go, but it would hurt you more if I kept you. So you go now and make more dandelions. I will love you like I do my Uncle and it will be okay, I know it." Her voice was small and tender, it carried with it the unbridled love of a small child.
As she lifted the top the butterflies made their way, one by one, out of the jar. The final two to leave flurried around her face, gracing her cheeks with fluttering kisses before joining the wildflowers. Charlie only just realized that he too was weeping.
"You did so well my love, truly." He wrapped his arm around her and pulled her in close, catching a delicate scent of pancake batter and wood shavings. He nuzzled his face deeply into her curls and breathed deeply, his ears rang from the clarity of the moment. Pulling away he brought his arms around his knees and gently nudged himself into her.
"You know, we do actually have to talk about the whole Uncle Fred tributes." He raised his eyebrow as she looked to him with a smug little grin.
"Papa, Uncle George said that the best way to honor his memory is to have one mischief worth managing a day." A quick spark shot across her eyes like a firebolt.
"Ah, I see, so it was Georgie-boy. Well, I think we need to brainstorm some new mischiefs' because catapulting a garden gnome into the bathroom while your mother is drawing a bath, well, we may need to dial it back a bit." He only slightly joked, there were heavy undertones of his "dad" voice.
"Yea," She said leaning into him and picking a wide blade of grass and sticking it between her thumbs "it was epic but the recoil from the catapult sent the recycling cauldron flying into the compost bin. That dumb Cockatrice was over there and he must have sparked from the scare and the whole thing caught on fire and exploded." She said nonchalantly, like it wasn't the first Charlie was hearing of it.
Charlie whipped his head around so quickly he felt a vertebrae pop. Before he could utter a word she was picking up the remnants of the beautiful moment they had just shared together and got to her feet.
"I'm sorry, what?" He said, completely floored.
"I'm okay papa, I mean it's a wreck back there, but I'm fine!" She quickly leaned in and kissed him on the cheek while he was still stunned and began to walk back towards the house
"It's? As in "it is"? As in, it is currently a wreck?" He scrambled to his feet and took off after her, his brain still processing the information.
She giggled heartily and from the depths of her belly as Charlie caught up to her and scooped her into his arms. He showered her with smooches and stern demands for answers.