Let me present to you : the âGuilty as sinâ analysis - Elriel version
So we all remember how SJM posted Guilty as Sin in her Instagram story a while back ? When she was probably working on ACOTAR 6 đ„ ? Well letâs come back to that, and dissect it to see how it might pertain to Elain ( and also elriel) story in the next book.
I know this analysis has probably done a million times but hey ! Itâs always fun to see how everyone interpret it, especially with SJM recent update on the book.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âDrowning in the Blue Nile/ He sent me âDowntown Lightsââ
There is blue ( self explanatory)
But there is also the reference to The Downtown Lights - The Blue Nile which is literally about longing, yearning, not knowing if the other feels the same ( â Sometimes I walk away / When all I really wanna do / is love and hold you rightâ ) which awfully sounds like Azriel when he left Elain in the foyer after nearly kissing her.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âMy boredom's bone deep, this cage was once just fineâ
I think by now we all realized Elain is no longer the fragile flower, boring female in the background. Even others start to slowly notice it. Even us, readers, can sense the shift .
But Nesta cut her off, seething at the pity about to be thrown her way. âLook who decided to grow claws after all,â she crooned. âMaybe youâll become interesting at last, Elain.â
Elain remained in the doorway, her face pale but her expression harder than Nesta had ever seen it. âYou do not decide what I can and cannot do, Nesta.â
Challenge filled each word. Challengeâfrom Elain, of all people.
âShall I tend to my little garden forever?â When Nesta flinched, Elain said, âYou canât have it both ways. You cannot resent my decision to lead a small, quiet life while also refusing to let me do anything greater.â
In the Feysand BC, they even heavily hint it. Feyre says that maybe Elain is not as docile as everyone thinks she is. Rhys agrees that there is something about her.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âI dream of cracking locks, throwing my life to the wolves or the ocean rocksâ
SJM herself said in an interview about how Elainâs dreams will beâŠtormented, brutal :
âElainâs now going to have dreams about ripping ivy out and the ivy creeping in through the windows to strangle her at night, because let me tell you, the ivy does not want to go.
Although taking about ivy; there is this idea of Elain escaping something suffocating, getting out of a situation, a feeling.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âCrashing into him tonight, heâs a paradoxâ
Again, the foyer scene. They did not expect to see each other there. She did not expects things to turn out how they did, seeing, smelling, feeling Azriel want and need. She also did not expect him to pull out last minute, saying this was âmistakeâ.
âAzrielâs hand slid up her neck, burying in her thick hair. Tilting her face the way he wanted it. Elain's mouth parted slightly, her eyes scanning his before fluttering shut. Offer and permission. He nearly groaned with relief and need as he lowered his head toward hers.â
Also Azriel a second later ;
âAzriel was left standing before Elain, who still awaited his kiss. His stomach twisted as he pulled his hand from her hair and step backâ
In this scene, in Elainâs eyes ( whoâs not aware of Rhys being here), Azriel is the archetype of a paradox. One second heâs all in, and the next he says itâs a mistake ? My dearest Elain is disoriented, not understanding what went wrong (đą)
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âI'm seeing visions, am I bad? Or mad? Or wise?â
Elain being a Seer. No one, not even herself, understood at first. They all thought she had gone mad, except Azriel who was able to understand her, going as far as telling the other she is the one they need ( kinda wise) :
âShe doesnât need anything,â Azriel answered without so much as looking at Lucien.
Elain was staring at the spymaster nowâunblinkingly.
âWeâre the ones who need âŠâ Azriel trailed off. âA seer,â he said, more to himself than us. âThe Cauldron made you a seer.â
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âThese fatal fantasies giving way to labored breath. Taking all of me, we've already done it in my headâ
Elain in lusting over him too. She probably dreamed of him the same way he did of her. Azriel saw her shivering and shuddering, smelled her arousal, offer and permission. :
âHer arousal drifted up to himâ
â"Yes," Elain breathed, like she read the decision. Just this taste in the dead of the longest night of the year, where only the Mother might witness them.â
âAzrielâs hand slid up her neck, burying in her thick hair. Tilting her face the way he wanted it. Elain's mouth parted slightly, her eyes scanning his before fluttering shut. Offer and permission.
The song is probably an inspiration and a way for SJM to say Elain feels the same.
And people think Azriel is disgusting, only lusting after Elain, as if Feyre didnât start with Rhys saying she wanted âfunâ, a âdistractionâ. Of course Azriel also feels lust, juste like Elain does. The books, ( and their books ;) ) will explore it all, including spicy scenes, just like SJM did in most of her books.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
âIf long suffering propriety is what they want from me, they don't know how you've haunted me so stunningly.â
We know Nesta, Azriel, and Elain herself are not a big fan of Elain mating bond. They want her to be free, to choose freely. Even though nesta is mated, even she sees Elain mating bond as some kind of toxic propriety. Azriel canât stand the smell of it, canât stand the image of Elain and Lucien together. Even Nesta notices it ( and also doesnât seem to disapprove the idea of them, which says a lot judging how she loves Elain). Elain herself shy away from it, not wanting to explore it, seeing it as a prison almost. And yet Rhys, and to some extent Feyre ( although I love them both), are encouraging her toward him, partly as a pawn for political gains.
ïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”âżïž”âżàšâĄà§âżïž”
â I choose you and me... Religiouslyâ
I mean⊠this one is kinda straightforward. The mention of choice and religion. The whole debate on Elainâs choice. Her marrying for love and beauty. Not for political gain like it was predicted for Nesta. The multiple mentions of questioning the cauldron ( Feyre, nesta, azriel, elainâŠ), their religion, when comes the question of Azriel and Elain. What if their religion was choosing, being each other choice. Azriel questioning the cauldron so outwardly in the BC, going to save Elain at the risk of dying. Elain buying him gifts (but not Lucien), choosing thĂ© spend the night showing him her garden plans. Her willing to kiss him although Lucien is upstairs. They are choosing each other again, and again, and again⊠almost religiously.
Also, SJM talking about exploring mating bonds and oneâs agency over it, choosing someone for love, choosing by ourselves. I know she said she wonât tell if sheâs writing about it or not but come onnnnn, why would she even say that and never mention it or using it again ?
Anyway, thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
©ïžCredit ( for the wonderful dividers) : @olenvasynyt