lemon lavender shortbread cookies
main masterlist
brightest of lights masterlist
synopsis: BOL CH 4: after having dinner there the night before, alfred encourages you to come back again for his birthday. jasonâs just a little nervous, because alf is his favorite, and he doesnât want to cause a scene on his day. but you? you're nervous for an entirely different reason.
wc: 4.5k
an: here we go! chapter 4 of the bol series! featuring alfred's birthday! (there's an incocnsistancy regarding alfred's birthday its different in some comics but for the sake of this story and plot we're sticking with this)
Jason stirs his coffee in slow circles. Itâs still early in the morning, and the apartment smells like toast, eggs, and the faintest hint of burnt butter. You're leaning against the kitchen island, mug tucked against your ribs, hair still damp from a quick shower. Your movements are relaxed, the kind of soft shuffle that can only be born in sleepy mornings.
Jason's got a soft smile on his face, left over from his birthday the day before. It was late when you both got back from the Manor, but that didn't keep you from ending the day on the sofa. You laid together, in that close way that really only existed in the odd quiet hours, and watched Pride and Prejudice, eating through a box of Haägen-Daz bars, pointing at things with the popsicle sticks you were left with.
"What'd you decide on?" Jason asks, flipping a pancake and bringing you back to the current moment.
You can't help but quirk a brow, "Heâs already seen me bleed out, Jase. Think heâll forgive a sub-par gift?"
"Absolutely not. Heâs still offended Tim once got him a Batman mug."
That earns a soft snort from you, "noted."
Jason smirks, passing you a plate, "so?" he prods.
You roll your eyes but smile, accepting the breakfast, and pushing yourself to sit up on the counter. You wince a bit as your body contorts against your stitches, and Jason sends you a warning look, but you continue to smile innocently, as you settle and tuck in.
"Well, actually, I was thinking I might make him something," you admit.
"What?" Jason pauses, and for a second, his full attention is off the stove, and on you.
"Lemon lavender shortbread cookies to pair with this specialty blend of earl grey that I found in Chinatown last week," you finally concede.
"You're gonna bake?" Jasonâs still staring with an awe filled look.
You were a skilled baker, your grandmother had been a formally trained patissere chef, and since the woman had practically raised you, you'd picked up a few skills of your own. You didn't bake often, it led to nostalgic feelings that often left you... unmoored. But every so often there's an occasion special enough to call for it.
More often than he'd like to admit, Jason's found you baking after hard missions. Tough losses, near misses, trying to make something good in the midst of all the bad cloying to you. He always understood. Keeping you quiet company, and forcing you to stop when your hands started shaking too bad.
"Figured with all the effort Alfred puts into feeding your family, I can make him something in return," you shrug, pointedly focused on your eggs and pancake, ignoring the way Jason was staring at you.
It's that stupid gentle look, that makes you want to spill every single thought you've ever had.
"He'll love it," Jason finally says.
Your lips twitch up, and you let out a sigh, "I could use a sous chef," you hint after a few moments of silence.
"I'd be honored," a warm hand lands right above your knee.
You're forced to look at him then, his hair a curly mess atop his head, eyes soft, his hand is warm, and you can feel the callouses against your skin.
You let it linger⌠just for a second, and then you let out a breath and roll your eyes, shoving Jason back with an open palm. âYour pancake is burning,â you mutter, and he whips back around.
âOh, shit.â
...
âYou know,â Jason says from his perch on the counter, legs swinging slightly, âfor someone who practically begged me to be their sous, you glower everytime I so much as think about touching something.â
You glance at him with a smirk, wrist deep in sugar and flour. And itâs a sight, all big and bulky, in shorts that are borderline sinful around his thighs, and a Wonder Woman sweatshirt that Steph had gifted him last nightâ which heâd giddily tossed in the wash as soon as you guys got home. His curls look so soft today-
âYou really could just let me help you,â he adds on.
You force yourself to stare back down at the dough youâre forming and clear your throat, âI donât recall begging. And if I remember correctly, the last time you helped me in the kitchen, you nearly burned your eyebrows off.â
Jason grins. âItâs only a fire hazard if you donât know how to flambe, and I know how to flambe. Plus, Alfred would revoke my kitchen rights if I ever burn down any kitchen. And at the moment, Duke, Damian, and I are the only ones with kitchen rights, and I refuse to lose to them.â
âWell, as long as our intentions are clear, Chef. Now pass me the lavender, will you?â
He reaches over, but after a beat, he shifts, holding it just out of reach, âsay please.â
You narrow your eyes, âJason.â
He dangles the herb like a cartoon villain, âPleeaaase?â he goads.
You huff, toss a bit of flour in his direction. He pretends it hits him like a gunshot, over dramatic as always, as he tumbles off the counter, clutching at his chest and keeping the lavendar in his grip balanced the entire time.
You roll your eyes, wiping your hands on a rag, and pick up a lemon, âlavender. Now. Or I swear Iâll zest this lemon onto your pillowcase.â
Jason laughs, finally handing it over, âone might interpret your threats of violence as a love language,â he says a playful smirk on his lips.
You hum, focused on measuring, using the back of your spoon to swipe the excess, âone could make that interpretation,â you muse.
âYeah,â he says so casually you almost miss it, âpretty bold of me, huh?â
You pause your measuring for just a moment. âMaybe just bold enough,â you offer softly.
The beat of silence stretchesânot uncomfortable, but charged in that way things sometimes are with him.
âWell, you know me. Never met a limit I donât want to push,â he shrugs, clearing his throat.
The moment breaks, and you smile despite yourself, âI think thatâs the exact warning you gave me when I moved in.â
Jason watches as you knead the dough together with deft hands, sleeves rolled up and brow furrowed in concentration. He doesnât say anything else. Just studies the way a few locks have slipped loose from the messy bun at the back of your head, the soft crease in your nose when you focus, the calm that settles over you when your hands are busy and your thoughts quiet down. Youâve got some flour on your cheek, but all it does is add to your charm.
âYouâre staring,â you murmur without looking up, you always seem to know when heâs looking.
âIâm observing,â he counters, not bothering to move his gaze away.
You glance up at him, amused. âWell, observe that if this batch comes out wrong, Iâm blaming you.â
âIâll take full responsibility,â he says, hopping down from the counter to grab the baking tray. âBut only if I get to eat your tragic failures.â
âBold request,â you scoff, scooping dough with practiced hands, âI would never subject your delicate sensibilities to my failures,â you add.
âI donât think you could make something I wouldnât eat,â Jason snorts.
You flick a bit of zest at him. âWanna help me roll these out.â
âSee? You do need me.â
âMaybe,â your lip quirks, always, you think privately. âBut donât let it go to your head.â
Jason grins again, pulling off the sweatshirt before coming around the counter.
âToo late,â he winks, reaching for the rolling pin and giving you a gentle shoulder bump.
...
When the oven timer dings, you nearly rip the mitts off the hook.
Youâd spent the entire time while the cookies were baking over-analyzing your process. Youâd washed the dishes wondering if youâd over worked the dough, or if youâd let it chill long enough.
Jason watches from his spot on the stool, sipping the last of his coffee as you open the oven with more intensity than is strictly necessary. Wincing a bit at the ominous little creak the door gives, he was going to have to take a look at that later this week. A blast of warmth escapes as you pull the tray out and set it down carefully on the trivet.
You stare at them, lips tugging down.
Jason waits, watching as your wring your fingers together, waiting for them to set for a few minutes. The kitchen smells downright delightful with the notes of lemon and lavender in the air, as you eventually start moving the shortbread's to your cooling rack. Though Jason notes your frown has not yet dissipated.
You continue to stare, expression unreadable as you take one of the cookies and snap it in half. Thereâs a bit of a snap, but it looks clean and crumbles in your fingers as you stare down at it.
He can see it on your face that youâd already made a decision as you half-heatedly bring a piece up to taste.
He leans forward, âWell?â
You exhale sharply through your nose. âTheyâre absolute rubbish.â
Jason blinks, âWhat?
You point at the tray with the sort of resigned despair usually reserved for funeral eulogies. âThe edges are too brown, the textureâs wrong, the lavenderâs too subtleâŚâ
Jason snorts, already reaching for one. They look and smell incredible, like the ones youâd see on an add or a professionalâs blog, picture perfect, he thinks, stuffing the cookie in his mouth. âoh fuck,â he says around his mouthful of shortbread, âtheyâre delicious.â
You swat at his hand as he reaches for anotherâhe dodges easily, plucking more shortbreads off the rack anyway.
âJason, they need to cool beforeââ
He takes another bite.
Your eye twitches as you cut yourself off.
He chews slowly, eyes closing just slightly. âOh, no,â he says, mock-serious. âYouâre right. These are trash. Burn the kitchen down, youâll never recover.â
âStop it,â you huff.
âIâm doing this for you. You canât possibly let these exist. Iâll eat them all. Every last one. No one has to know, donât worry.â
You throw the closest thing you can at his headâ an oven mitt. He catches it easily, still munching on another cookie.
âTheyâre not balanced,â you argue, hands gesturing as your frustration mounts. âTheyâre meant to melt, notâcrumble like regret.â
Jason blinks, then grins. âIs that what they taste like? Regret? Huh. I always assumed itâd be less lemony.â
You groan, dragging a hand down your face. âI shouldâve started with the lemon sugar, and I shouldâve zested over the sugar bowl, that way the oils would land on the sugar. The flour was offâI used the metal scoop instead of weighing it. Rookie mistake,â you grumble, glaring in betrayal at the cookies on the rack.
Jason finishes a fourth cookie and speaks around the bite. âBabe. I would eat these off the floor.â
You stare at him like heâs got two heads.
âTheyâre incredible,â he promises you.
That earns him a scoff and he frowns watching as you reach for the bowl again, muttering something about âadjusting ratiosâ and âfixing the butter-to-flour balance.â
Jason stands, crosses the kitchen, and places a hand lightly on your arm, just as youâre pulling out the scale.
âTheyâre really good,â he says, quiet this time. âYouâre just panicking âcause itâs Alf.â
You sigh.
âThatâs the problem,â you mumble. âAlfred will know the difference between a sub-par shortbread and an excellent one. I refuse to put a shitty shortbread in front of the British Butler who can make a perfect tea service in less than an hour and still have time to polish his shotgun to gleaming perfection.â
He squeezes your arm gently, looking at the clock, âso we make another batch. We got time,â he says gently and you nod, taking a breath. âBut we keep this one. For scientific purposes,â he adds on, reaching over for another cookie.
You roll your eyes and huff, âFine. You can have the regret cookies.â
Jason grins like heâs won something, âI will cherish every one.â
...
Jason watches you from the other side of the counter, arms folded, a fond smile tugging at the corner of his mouth as you mutter under your breath about lemon/lavender ratios.
âYou know, I donât think you get this focused when youâre patching me up after a mission.â
You donât bother looking up, âThatâs because you bleed on my throw pillows.â
âFor someone who usually bakes to decompress, youâve gotten awfully worked up,â he counters.
âI am not worked up,â you argue.
âYouâve elbowed me out of my own kitchen, threatened me with a dough hook, and youâre vibrating.â
âI just want them to be right,â you say, exasperated, as you finally move your gaze from the dough and back to Jason. âAlfred deservesâI donât know! More than mediocre cookies with a lopsided bake.â
Jason rounds the counter, gently plucks the zester from your hand, and bumps your shoulder with his.
âTheyâll be perfect. Heâll love âem. Because theyâre from you. He wouldaâ loved the first batch.â
You blink, a little thrown at the sudden calming effect his words seemed to have. âStop being sincere, youâre throwing off my mania,â you huff as you grab the zester back.
âIâm sorry our years of friendship are conspiring against you,â he mocks.
You spare a few seconds to glare at him before shooing him back out of the kitchen again.
...
Youâre staring down at the empty mixing bowl, hands on your hips, jaw clenched. The second batch of dough is sitting in the fridge, chilling. The first batch rests nearby on the cooling rack, half-eaten, because Jason has no self-control.
But you arenât laughing. Youâre tense. He sees it in the way your shoulders curl in, in how your eyes are bouncing from the recipe card to the bowl to the oven thermometer like the world might end if you blink wrong.
Jason walks over, slower than usual, and leans a hip against the counter next to you.
âWhatâs going on in that head of yours?â
âThis was supposed to be easy,â you mutter, eyes fixed on the bowl. âJust a simple family recipe. Iâve made it before. But now everything feels too much or not enough, and the butterâs too soft, and the lavender might be stale, and what if he hates them, or worse, what if heâs polite about them?â
Jason waits a beat before gently reaching out, doing his best not to laugh in the face of your frankly ridiculous panic, instead focusing on brushing flour off your cheek with the back of one knuckle.
âOkay. First of all, the lavenderâs not stale, you and I both tasted it. Second, I am not polite and Iâve eaten half of the so-called disaster tray. ThirdâŚâ
He takes your hands, flour and all, and wraps them lightly in his.
âTake a breath.â
You blink, âI am breathing.â
âYouâre panicking and calling it breathing.â
You glare at him, but your hands stay in his.
âJason,â you whisper.
âI know,â he says, just as softly. âYou want it to be perfect. You want him to feel seen. To feel appreciated.â
You nod once, too fast.
âBut he already does. These cookies? Theyâre just a bonus.â
You sniff and blink too quickly, âYouâre annoying when youâre right.â
âIâm always right,â he corrects, then tilts his head. âBut Iâll accept annoying if it gets you to stop looking at the flour like it personally betrayed you.â
You let out a shaky laugh, and he squeezes your fingers once before letting go.
âNow,â he says, nudging the bowl with a grin, âwhat say you and I tackle the Not-Rubbish Batch together?â
You finally smile, small but real. âFine. But youâre on sprinkling duty.â
Jason mock-groans, already reaching for the sugar, âShouldaâ known this was a trap.â
The scent in the kitchen is exactly right. Lemon bright and warm, lavender soft in the air. You slide the last tray out of the oven with more care than Jasonâs ever seen you use on anything but him.
He sidles closer while you plate the best dozen, tilting his head to admire themâand you.
âWhatâs the verdict, O judgmental one?â
You arch a brow at him, tired but satisfied, âthey donât look horrible,â you relent. Jason smirks, and your eyes level into a glare, âDonât say âI told you so,â itâs smug.â
He shrugs, amused, leaning down to you a bit, âI am smug. Youâre justââ
You shove a cookie into his mouth before he can finish. âHere. Chew on that instead of your ego.â
Jason takes the bite, still grinning, even as he mumbles, âWorth it.â
...
The biscuits are secured under the seat of Jasonâs bike, along with his gift, wrapped with clean folds. Your arms are wrapped around his waist, your helmet resting against his back. Youâd left the kitchen a little worse for wear than youâd prefer. Youâd caught Jasonâs wince at its state, but promised youâd clean up once you were back later in the evening.
âStitches?â is the first thing he asks as you both pull the helmets off.
âTheyâre good,â you promise.
He squints at you.
You roll your eyes, and pull up on the side of your brown leather jacket and the white sweater you had on underneath.
Jason smiles at your easy agreement. His fingers skim your side causing your nose to scrunch.
âCold,â you mutter when he glances up at your expression.
âSorry,â he says, though heâs still smiling at you as he pulls your gauze to the side.
âYou know, some might consider this an invasion of privacy,â you note, looking down at Jaosnâs hands as he analyzed each stitch.
âOne could make that interpretation,â he teases, throwing your words from this morning back at you.
You roll your eyes, scoffing.
âThey look good,â he finally decides, pulling your sweater back down.
âCan we go inside now?â
âYes, lemme grab the gifts,â he nods, lifting the seat.
You hold your helmet in one hand, decorated with constellations, painted on one night when you couldnât sleep. Your fingers trace over the constellation of Orion, eyes flickering to Jason.
âHey,â you say suddenly.
âYeah?â He asks.
âIâm really proud of you, you know?â The words slip past your lips, while your mind lingered on thoughts of the warrior the constellation was named after.
Jason freezes, one hand holding the gifts, and the other about to push the motorcycle seat back down. He turns his head, and you see the flush peaking at the tips of his ears. You canât help the fond smile that takes your lips as he slowly pushes the seat. He turns back to you, clearing his throat and tugging a bit at his collar.
âI-uhâŚâ he starts but cuts himself off.
âI mean Iâm proud of you pretty much every day,â you add, realizing where he was stuck. âBut today? Today Iâm proud of you for being here, even though I know youâve spent more time at the manor in the last week that you have in the last three months.â
Jason drops your gaze, and then he turns to look at the Manor itself.
He shakes his head, and runs a hand through his hair, âFamily, right?â
âRight,â you nod, looping your arm around his.
His lips quirk on the ends. Not quite a smile, but itâs enough for you to see him, Jason. He turns to stare at you. âLetâs do it,â he finally says, and begins walking forward, pace just slow enough for you to match.
...
Youâre welcomed in by Stephanie, who does her best British accent, dressed in a three-piece suit, and emulates Alfredâs posture and mannerisms to the best of her ability.
âSteph, thats a nice suit,â
âThanks. I stole it from Timâs closet like a month ago, and took it to a tailor.â
You canât hide the snort this time around. It gains you a roll of the eyes from Jason and a bright beam from Steph.
âItâs kind of freaky,â Jason murmurs low to you, behind her back, as she leads you forward.
âI fear weâve underestimated her,â you concede.
Jason snorts, âdoubtful.â
You hide your smile behind your hand as you both arrive in the kitchen.
She leads you both into the kitchen where you find the rest of Jason's siblings seemingly hard at work. Itâs a full ensemble. Dickâs on a counter pulling out the nice dishes and plates, Timâs moving what must be the catered meal (you wouldnât trust any of them in a kitchenâŚ. maybe Damian⌠maybe), and Steph slipped out of her Alfred persona and was crouched in front of the oven.
âQuite the production,â you say softly.
âWell, none of them should be trusted to make more than a bowl of cereal,â Jason reminds you and you canât help but quirk a smile.
âWhat about her?â you ask, nodding your head at Stephanie.
âStephâs got an exception.â
âOh?â
âBrownies.â
âShe can bake?â you ask with a small smile.
âNo.â
âJason.â
âOnly brownies, nothing else.â
âYour family never ceases to surprise,â you snort.
He sends you a dubious look but shrugs, before handing you the gifts and moving to help. Jason moves easily in the kitchen. You can almost imagine the teenage version of him trailing after Alfred.
You hold Jasonâs gift and the small tins that make up your own as you watch. Its only a moment later when you feels someone come up behind you.
âHello, Damian,â you greet softly.
âTt. There's no feasible way you could have known it was me,â he argues, stepping in line with you.
âProcess of elimenation,â you smirk.
He rolls his eyes, though eventually peers at the gifts in your hands, shooting you a questioning look.
One you choose to ignore, to his annoyance and your joy.
âHow is your injury?â
You tilt your head, âItâs fine, your brother is just overly cautious.â
Damian snorts, and looks offended a second later for allowing such a sound, much to your amusement.
âTodd is rarely cautious, overtly or not.â
âGuess Iâm just special then,â you shrug.
âPerhaps so,â is what Damian finally offers up.
You had meant it, in part as a jest, but Damian doesn't argue and your eyes flick back to Jason who's arguing with Tim about proper serving dishes, and you know itâs true.
"High praise from the peanut gallery," you mutter, smiling.
...
Dinnerâs less chaotic than most gatherings. Alfred insists on a proper meal, real silverware and polished glasses. The table is fullâBruce at the head, the rest spread out, You're sat beside Jason, across from Steph.
You sit and listen as everybody exchanges stories. Jason stays on the edge of a few conversations, as if heâs afraid to jump in. Part of you recognizes that he may have never heard a few of these stories, that he hadnât been there.
You let your knee bump his whenever he gets a little too quiet. His knee presses against yours as his shoulders relax. Itâs halfway through a story Dickâs telling, about how Alfred has always shouldered more than necessary, and to his credit, heâs doing a good job of talking around what was being shouldered at the time this story took place. Picking and choosing his words carefully enough, but everyone in the room could read through the lines. After someone had gone away.
Your knee presses to his again, and this time as it pulls back, his hand drops to it. Warm and calloused as he holds your knee in place. You blink, turning to him slightly, and when you see the tense line of him, you purposefully look back to Dick. Letting Jason ground himself, with a hand on your knee and your attention elsewhere.
...
Itâs not until the meal is done, and dishes are picked up when you manage to catch Alfred alone in the hallway. Everyone has started migrating to the sitting room with their cups of cocoa. Stephanie, Jason and Duke arguing over peppermint sticks versus marshmallows versus whipped cream.
You gently hand him the tin of cookies, and the other of tea. "Lemon Lavender Shortbread," you tell him softly, almost shy. âI thought they'd pair well with this blend of Earl Grey I found.â
Alfred peers down at you over his glasses. Opening his the shortbread tin.
You hesitate before adding, âthey were my grandmotherâs recipe.â
Thereâs a subtle ease in his shoulders as the gentle scent hits him, âI assure you, I shall thoroughly enjoy them."
You smile, a little nervous as he closes the tin. You nod, preparing to go join the rest, but he stops you with a gentle, "Miss (Y/L/N).â
"Yes?"
He smiles, rare and genuine. "Itâs no small feat to become part of this family. They can be quite loud and appear daunting, and sometimes, despite the number, they can be lonley. It is a kind thing, isnât it? To be seen, to be known?â
You blink, caught off guard.
âIt is, I think, my only wish; that they should all find someone who will know them.â
You stare at him, a few moments longer, âYouâre a little too insightful, for my mental stability, Alfred.â
The olderman offers you an amused smile, one hand gently squeezing at your shoulder, âit comes with time and age, my dear,â before he walks away.
Jason is waiting for you on the couch by the time you make it over there.
âAll good?â
You turn to Jase, eyes tracing over blue-green eyes, the white streak of his hair, the small scars that litter his face. The bump on his nose from where heâd broken it too many times for it to ever be straight ever again.
âYeah, Jase. Alfred liked my gift.â
Jason offers you a bright smile, the charming boyish one that warms you from the inside out every time he turns it on you.
âTold you,â he smirks, bumping your shoulder.
Yeah, you did.
...
everything tags: @butterfly-skinnylegend
dc taglist: @batarella @escapenightmare @uh-oh-howd-i-get-here @seamlessepiphany @ye-olde-trash-panda @snake-in-a-flower-crown @11om
bol taglist: @mxtokko @myxticmoon @pink-panda-pancakes @luvelyxp @arestemper @c-losur3 @boobilater @mercuryathens @atomicpeachmaker @midnightridercassie @casiiopea2

















