"The sting is everything, innit?"

the jacob wysocki tulpa manifesting inside my brain:

I personally don’t think Ted started out his career as the nicest person in the world, especially after his dad died. I think he was probably a right asshole and tried to be the best coach he could be. He wanted to win and he wanted them to feel the pain he was going through.

I think it took a reality check to bring him back.

I think Beard coming back after he got out of prison because Ted was the one sturdy thing he had pulled him out and I think Michelle probably also told him the person he is on the field isn’t the person she fell in love with and if he’s gonna act that way to a bunch of young guys, then how’s he going to treat his own kids?

And that’s where everything switched. He took all of his father’s lessons and that kindness he found while searching through the attic made him realize he wanted to be a good man like his dad.

Everyone wants to write a morally grey character right now, and I get it, they're fun. But there's a very specific way this goes wrong, and it's that "morally grey" quietly turns into "good person who did one bad thing that one time." That's not grey. That's just a good guy with a sob story.

The Don'ts

Don't give them a bad action with a get-out-of-jail-free backstory. If your character did something genuinely awful and the narrative immediately hands the reader a tragic childhood to explain it away, you haven't written moral complexity, you've written an excuse. The backstory can exist. It just can't cancel the action out.

Don't make their morality entirely reactive. A character who's only ever "bad" when provoked and otherwise a total sweetheart isn't grey, they're good with a temper. Grey characters make choices that aren't forced on them, and some of those choices should make the reader genuinely uncomfortable.

Don't let the narrative agree with them too much. If every other character eventually comes around to "well, they had a point," you've built a soapbox, not a person. Let some people in the story stay angry at them. Let the consequences actually land.

Don't confuse grey with edgy. Swearing more or being sarcastic doesn't make a character morally complicated, it makes them a good character with a mouth on them. The moral part has to come from the choices, not the vibe.

The Dos

Do give them a real want that isn't evil, but a method that is. The want should make sense. The method should still cost something. A character who wants to protect their family and starts poisoning knights to do it, that's grey. The goal is sympathetic, the method genuinely isn't.

Do let them be right sometimes and wrong other times, on the same issue. Consistency is for heroes. A grey character can make a correct call in chapter three and a horrifying one in chapter twelve for the exact same underlying reason.

Do give other characters valid reasons to distrust them, permanently. Not everyone needs to forgive your morally grey character by the end. Some relationships should just stay broken. It's more realistic, and honestly, it's more interesting.

Do let them know what they're doing. Self-awareness is what separates grey from misguided. A character who genuinely believes they're the hero the whole time is a different archetype. A grey character usually knows, on some level, that what they're doing isn't clean, and does it anyway.

Why This Matters

The whole appeal of a morally grey character is that the reader isn't sure how to feel about them, and if you resolve that tension too early, you've killed the thing that made them interesting in the first place. Let people argue about your character after reading their story. That's the goal, not a problem to fix.

Looking For More Writing Tips And Tricks?

Check out the rest of Quillology with Haya; a blog dedicated to writing and publishing tips for authors!