The Issue with Endeavorâs Atonement Arc
Iâm somewhat late to the discussion on this, but I feel like the reason Endeavorâs atonement arc was such a hit for his fans and such a miss for his critics was because his atonement arc was almost entirely characterized by others coming to him, just so he could grow as a person.
It sounds pretty accusatory, but this aspect about how he went about his atonement has been bugging me ever since the war arc when all the Todorokiâs gathered in the hospital.
One of Endeavorâs first line of thoughts upon waking up wasnât âwhere has Touya been all these years?â or âwhat exactly caused Touya to become a villain?â or even âwhy didnât Touya come back home?â but instead a thought about how he, Endeavor, could not fight his mass murdering son.
And then, of course, the rest of the Todorokiâs gathering to assure him that he isnât alone in this, and that Shouto is going to deal with Dabi himself. So now Endeavor does not have to confront Dabi at all.
Which is what my main problem with Endeavor is. While the baggage and abuse the Todorokiâs went through is explained, itâs never truly been addressed by Endeavor. Itâs instead focused internally in him and how he feels (and how he perceives others to feel). Nothing about the neglect Natsuo or Fuyumi faced, the abuse Shouto/Rei went through, or the way Dabi was groomed into his hero idealism.
Even the point of view Endeavor takes on how he should fix/help his family is rather singled minded. Which is to say that all of the family lives together, excluding Endeavor. This works out for Natsuo, who wants that, but not for Fuyumi, who 100 percent wants all of her family to be together. You could even include Rei wanting her family to be together too.
Itâs not surprising that he takes Natsuoâs (and somewhat of Shoutoâs) viewpoints seriously, as though they are all rather conflicting, they are also similar in how all three of them are assertive, outspoken, and strong-minded (in Natsuoâs case, physically intimidating too). The wants of Fuyumi and Rei (even the idea of her) are left behind.
And then we get to the final war arc. Instead of fighting Dabi, trying to reach out to his son, Shouto is left to the task. There really is something about how Endeavor, who gave shape to a âfailed creationâ that is Touya, had Shouto, who is meant to be a perfected version of himself, deal with Dabi.
In the end, much like how Shouto decided in the beginning of the series to come to Endeavor to intern at his agency, Dabi was the one that had to come to Endeavor too, with the rest of the Todoroki family following, because Dabi knew Endeavor would not come (or even look!) to him. Once again, Endeavor did not reach out to his family but instead had to have his family reach out to him.
This isnât bad writing, or a failure on Endeavor as a person (person, not character) and in fact is pretty realistic. It isnât uncommon for abusive parents to grow older and mellow out, and to then try and âfixâ family relationships, often to not address why, exactly, those relationships needed to be fixed in the first place. But it sure is pretty bleak.