I'd like to share my thoughts on Shadaria and the discourse regarding the ship as someone relatively new to the STH fandom (apologies if itâs redundant or youâve heard it all before).
To be transparent, I first discovered STH on my cousinâs Sega Genesis in the mid-90s when I was a pre-teen, before moving on to the Sony PlayStation. I didnât really engage with the franchise or join the fandom until Year of Shadow and the release of the third live-action film. I enjoyed the first two movies as fun, popcorn-style entertainment, with a cast I liked. Still, it was Sonic 3 that truly drew me deeper, mainly because of Shadow and Mariaâs relationship.
When I first witnessed that girl and her hedgehog companion on screen, sitting in that bed of daisies, holding hands and gazing at the stars, I didnât think of them as siblings. After I went down the information and character history rabbit hole, i.e., watching playthroughs of SA2, and ShTH, SxSG as well as scenes from the Japanese version of Sonic X, (because no way was I trusting a 4KIDS dub to be faithful to the original anime), I still didnât see them as siblings.
At the conclusion of SxSG Dark Beginnings Episode 3, I couldn't help but notice a classic shoujo anime romance style filter in the scenes where Shadow imagines a life with Maria on Earth had she lived. It evoked memories from my childhood, regarding both anime and Western animation. Growing up in the 90s, I frequently saw interspecies romantic relationships portrayed as a common trope in the animated shows I watched. Think Gargoyles, TMNT, or Biker Mice From Mars; relationships like Vinnie and Charley, Leonardo and Karai, Belle and Beast, and notably, Goliath and Elisa Maza, were familiar examples. To me, Shadaria seamlessly fits into this group, which is probably why I love them so much, beyond their story and individual characterizations.
Of course, the ARK Siblings' relationship is an entirely valid view, as Shadow and Mariaâs relationship is open to interpretation. And if the ship isnât your cup of tea, thatâs perfectly fine. What is not fine is the harassment and bullying that occur simply because one likes a ship that you donât care for. I am a firm believer in the old fandom rule of âdonât like, donât readâ or simply donât engage if something isnât for you.
(I know that's easier said than done in this age of social media, where likes and clicks drive the algorithms and engagement. That dopamine hit is strong, after all.)
That said, I will also address the other major issue with Shadaria: the mental gymnastics involving canon that anti-shippers engage in.
âShadow and Maria have a canonical brother/sister relationshipââ
My brothers and sisters in STH shipping fandom, yaâll be out here shipping Sonadow so yaâll couldn't care less about canon. But when it comes to Shadaria, suddenly canon matters? Pick a lane, please!
Anti-shippers cite the ShTH manual as reason and definite âproofâ of Shadow and Mariaâs sibling relationship. Um, excuse me, but never, not once in their entire existence thus far, have Shadow and Maria referred to each other as brother or sister in game canon. If they truly saw each other that way, they would let it slip a few times in game dialogue by now. You know, like Commander Abe Tower has regarding his own relationship to Maria, âMaria was like a sister to me,â and âthe only familyâ he knew. How Maria herself has said that Abe âfeels like my little brother,â and Gerald says in his journal that âMaria has become like a big sister to young Abraham.â **Note that Gerald doesnât use the sibling descriptor when referring to Shadow and Maria's relationship.
I donât put much stock in Western english language game manuals of yesteryear, such as the ShTH manual stating something like, âMaria was like a sister to Shadow,â as I lived through the DIC Sailor Moon debacle of âHaruka and Michiru are cousins", and 4KIDS censoring and localizing the original Yu-Gi-Oh, Sonic X, and other series to appeal to a much younger demographic, cut and dry Western sensibilities and network advertisers. Heck, even Toonami edited its afternoon programming back in the day. And "like siblings" does not make them siblings. Being raised alongside someone does not necessarily mean you're related to them or that you perceive them as your brother or sister. It all depends how the characters themselves view their relationships with each other. Thus, I do not consider the SEGA America shared promo image of Dark Beginnings, which features Maria and Shadow reaching out to each other, captioned âlike long lost siblings.â as gospel. But eh, to each their own.
Finally, I want to emphasize that Shadaria doesnât interfere with your Sonadow, Shadamy, or any other Shadow ship you enjoy. Maria is long gone in canon, after all.
(Iâm harking back to canon here, cause anti-shippers seem to consider it to be non-negotiable when it comes to fandom interpretation and works)
While the fan girl in me wishes SEGA would bring Maria back permanently, perhaps through reincarnation (in the vein of classic anime that dealt with that particular trope such as Yu-Gi-Oh, Inuyasha, Sailor Moon, and PSME) I highly doubt it will happen. And SxSG was, I feel, a swan song for Shadaria. Of course, that wonât make me love the ship any less, and itâs just my opinion based on where I see things heading within the franchise.
Anyhoo, thatâs all I got for now. Thank you for attending my TED Talk.