see i'll always be on the side of "jimmy died when RAPHAEL exploded cas, not when lucifer did" bc 1) it frees my boy jimmy only like a couple weeks after the rapture and 2) it makes his burger obsession in my bloody valentine even funnier. he blames his behavior on a dead man.
I do see... I kinda always thought Cas meant Jimmy as in, human, the human part of him, his body, his vessel was causing the cravings. Not that Jimmy was still in there with him.
Cas says, "It's my vessel-- Jimmy. His, uh, appetite for red meat has been touched by Famine's effect." I thought he was just saying Jimmy to clarify for Dean what he meant by 'my vessel'. That even without Jimmy's soul it in, the body he inhabits still remembers Jimmy's humanisms.
Which honestly, on deeper thought about this, opens a whole can of worms to explore how Cas experiences humanity being skewed to some of Jimmy's interpretations; desires, wants, needs, interests, kinda... everything. Now that could make some interesting fic!


















