Can we stop treating canon facts like an offense? Fandom etiquette in the AvM / AvA community needs a serious reality check.(PLEASE READ)
There is a deeply toxic trend happening across YouTube, X, and other platforms where fans who stick to the actual canon genders and pronouns of Alan Becker's characters are being targeted, harassed, and aggressively antagonized.
I want to preface this by saying that everyone I have personally interacted with in this fandom so far has been wonderful. I haven't personally dealt with this toxicity, but I keep seeing it happen to other fans in comment sections It has reached a point where people are starting fights in the comments section the second someone uses correct, official pronouns.
Let's lay down the absolute, indisputable facts of the series so there is zero room for argument:
The Main Cast are Male: Alan Becker and the crew consistently, permanently refer to the Color Gang (The Second Coming, Red, Blue, Yellow, Green), The Chosen One, and The Dark Lord as he/him.
The Lore Backs It Up: Characters are explicitly named King Orange and Lord. In the latest AvM Alan made a comment stating Purple is a male, he then deleted it. Not to mention in Alan's other channel Alan Becker Clips he constantly referred to the characters with canon pronouns, DJ also referred to them with their canon pronouns.
The Exceptions are Specific: The only canonically female characters are clearly established, such as Orchid (Purple's mother) and Mitsi, and recently The Conductor.
These are Alan's characters. He created them, he wrote them, and he owns the rights to their canon identities. Discarding the creator's explicit words and claiming you "don't trust his statements" isn't a valid critical take āyes I've actually seen someone say that, and with all the pride too and NO ONE actually stood up to thatā it is just straight up disrespect to the person whose art you are supposedly here to celebrate. You do not get to dictate a universe over the person who built it.
Let's clear up the inevitable deflection before anyone tries it:
This is not about homophobia, transphobia, or being anti-queer headcanons. Do not hide behind social justice buzzwords to justify being toxic. Fandom has always allowed for creative liberties, Alternate Universes (AUs), and personal headcanons. If you want to headcanon a character as female, non-binary, or anything else for your own art and stories, go for it. No one is stopping you.
But there is a massive, unacceptable line between enjoying your own headcanon and forcing it onto other people.
When someone watches the show, hears Alan use "he/him" and writes a comment using those exact same canon pronouns, they are doing nothing wrong. Attacking them, correcting them with your personal HCs, or acting like they are doing something offensive for simply watching the show as written is completely unhinged behavior.
Your headcanon is a fanmade modification. Canon is the original thing. You can play with your modifications all you want, but you have absolutely no right to harass the people who prefer the original. Stop turning comment sections into a battlefield just because reality doesn't match your personal fanfiction.
I've stated it before and I'll state it again, this does not disregard your HCs, but some people out there are getting hurt because they simply follow the canon, and I wanted to acknowledge this fact so everyone knows.