I love Luke and Elliotâs friendship, and at the end of the day for most of the book Iâm certain Luke is just trying to be Elliotâs friend. But at the same time, ironically the thing that convinces me most that Luke has liked Elliot all along* is that Elliot Typically only understands about 2/3rds of the subtext the reader gets. Like if he's not seeing it, I think we're supposed to!
*(the moment I pin point is sometime around the rockslide when Luke has to deal with Elliot nearly dying for the first time and when Elliot makes it clear he prefers Lukeâs company over Adamâs that summer, so when they are 14) (there is also that moment at the lake when Luke is doing the EXACT same thing to try and connect with Elliot as the other boys are to flirt with Sereneâ offer to teach him to swim⌠and if u tell me thereâs not subtext there Iâll fight u)
In social situations throughout the rest of the book, Elliot is constantly just slightly wrong and learns it later, leading to hilarious and sad miscommunications. Like you as the reader are meant to know that Myra had a crush on Luke long before Elliot does, that Serene isnât as serious about her relationship with Elliot as he thinks. Youâre meant to understand that when Luke invites Elliot to parents day and to his house for the summer that, though he acts like it doesnât matter to him and Elliot interprets it as Luke only tolerating his company, Elliotâs presence actually means a great deal to him. And Elliot usually does make an effort to interpret why he and Luke are miscommunicating and gets it mostly right⌠except for the glaring potential subtext thatâs added if Luke has a crush on him.
Like the fact that Elliot eventually figures out âohhhh luke got mad at me for how I treated Adam because he is also gay and maybe thought I was being homophobicâ but neglects to see the âsmug blond idiotâ of it all and how that comment could be personally hurtful to Luke⌠especially if Luke already had a tiny crush on Elliot and had read something into Elliot spurning Adamâs obvious flirting all summer in favor of hanging out with him instead.*
Not to mention that one SRB post where she included in the reasons why Adam thought Luke punched him is that Luke has a crush on Elliot
And there are a million moments like that. Like Elliot thinks itâs odd Luke just âdecidedâ to like Dale, but never asks himself why Luke would make up a crush on the spot like that when Elliot asked him about it.
I think itâs interesting that as a reader, youâre essentially trained by the midway point of this book to understand that Elliot misunderstands people, and particularly misunderstands Luke, but we as fans are all still in such disagreement about what exactly Elliot is misunderstanding. Because almost all of it could be interpreted as âKid with an intense unrequited crushâ behaviorâŚ.... but even I think a good amount of it is he just cares about Elliot in general, and wants intensely for Elliot to care about him back in whatever way.
[But to me at the end of the day the, 'Elliot gave Luke a pen once as a reward and Luke just kept it as a souvenir and never used it' thing is the moment that drives me over the edge of like OKAY if Elliot doesn't realize that is weird crush behavior he's NEVER going to figure it out.]
























